The 32,000-Year-Old Wolf Head Found in Siberia's Permafrost

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-06-30.

A Preserved Pleistocene Wolf Head Found in Yakutia

Albert Protopopov

In the summer of 2018, a man searching for mammoth tusks along the Tirekhtyakh River in Yakutia, in Russia's far northeast, found the head of an Ice Age wolf sticking out of the frozen ground. Its fur, teeth, skin and even its brain were still preserved. Radiocarbon dating later put its age at about 32,000 years; early Russian reports had suggested around 40,000. The head is roughly 40 centimetres (15.7 inches) long, which led to headlines about a "giant" wolf, but the scientists studying it say the real animal was probably not much bigger than a large modern wolf.

Here is what the find is, why Siberian permafrost keeps producing such remarkable remains, and what researchers hoped to learn from it.

What exactly was found

The specimen is only a head; the rest of the body has not been found. It belonged to a fully grown wolf, estimated to have been two to four years old when it died. The discovery was announced in June 2019, when Russian and Japanese researchers presented it together with other frozen animals from Yakutia.

Albert Protopopov of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) described it as the first time an adult Pleistocene wolf had been found with its soft tissue intact. Wolf skulls and bones turn up regularly in the thawing ground, and a few frozen wolf pups are known, but a grown animal with flesh and fur is something else entirely.

The photograph above, credited to Protopopov, shows how much survives: matted fur, the ears, the dark nose and the teeth that gave the find its "still snarling" look in the press, with a tape measure laid beside it for scale.

A Preserved Pleistocene Wolf Head Found in Yakutia

Albert Protopopov

This side view, again with a tape measure, makes the length easy to read and shows the fur still lying in its natural direction. Look at the back of the head, though: a ragged mass of frozen fur and soil is still attached, which matters a great deal for the size question below.

How big was this wolf, really?

Measured as found, the head is about 40 cm long. For comparison, the head of a modern grey wolf is usually in the range of 23 to 28 cm. On paper that makes the Yakutian wolf look enormous, and many headlines ran with it.

The Swedish geneticist Love Dalén of the Swedish Museum of Natural History, who worked on the find, offered a more sober view to reporters. Once the clump of permafrost stuck to the head is taken into account, he said, "It is not that much bigger than a modern wolf." Ice Age wolves in the far north were often robust animals with heavy jaws, but there is no evidence this one was a monster.

There was also speculation about how the head came to be separated from its body, including the idea that people cut it off. Dalén said he had seen no evidence convincing him of that; erosion, scavengers or the slow movement of frozen ground are all possible explanations.

Why Yakutia keeps giving up Ice Age animals

Yakutia, also known as the Sakha Republic, is the largest region of Russia and one of the coldest inhabited places on Earth. Much of it sits on permafrost: ground that stays frozen all year, sometimes to a depth of hundreds of metres. When an animal is buried quickly by mud or a collapsing riverbank and then frozen, decay all but stops, and the remains can survive for tens of thousands of years.

Two things have made such finds more frequent. Warming summers are thawing the upper layers of permafrost and eroding riverbanks, exposing what lies inside. And there is a large, legal trade in mammoth ivory, so local people spend long seasons searching riverbanks for tusks. Many of the region's best-known discoveries, including this wolf, were first spotted by tusk hunters rather than by scientists.

The same landscapes have produced woolly mammoths, woolly rhinoceroses, ancient horses, a frozen foal and several cave lion cubs, making Yakutia one of the most important places in the world for studying Ice Age animals in the flesh.

What scientists wanted to learn

The specimen was studied by an international group. Protopopov's team in Yakutsk worked on a digital model of the skull and brain using CT scanning, which lets researchers look inside without cutting the specimen open.

A Preserved Pleistocene Wolf Head Found in Yakutia

Naoki Suzuki

This 3D rendering, from the Japanese side of the project, is built from CT scans and shows the head's outer surface and the soil still clinging to it. Naoki Suzuki of the Jikei University School of Medicine in Tokyo led the imaging work. He told the Asahi Shimbun that the team hoped to judge the animals' physical abilities and way of life by comparing them with lions and wolves living today.

In Sweden, a team including Dalén and David Stanton aimed to extract DNA and sequence the full genome. Their questions were big ones: did these Pleistocene wolves interbreed with the ancestors of today's wolves, how inbred were they, and did any genetic traits play a part in their disappearance? They said the work would take at least a year and would be published in peer-reviewed journals.

A Preserved Pleistocene Wolf Head Found in Yakutia

Naoki Suzuki

A second rendering strips away the fur and soil digitally to reveal the skull itself: the long canines, the row of cheek teeth and the bony structure of the snout. Being able to measure the skull this way, without the frozen clump, is exactly what lets scientists compare it fairly with modern wolves.

Who were the Ice Age wolves?

Wolves of the Late Pleistocene in the far north were the same species as today's grey wolf, Canis lupus, but some populations were a distinct type adapted to hunting and scavenging the large animals of the "mammoth steppe". Studies of wolves from Beringia, the region that once joined Siberia and Alaska, show broad, short snouts, large carnassial teeth and heavy jaws, with lots of broken teeth suggesting they cracked bones much as hyenas do. Chemical analysis of their bones points to a diet of horse, bison, muskox and mammoth.

When those prey animals declined at the end of the Ice Age, these specialised wolves seem to have disappeared with them. Genetic studies suggest that most wolves living today descend largely from Siberian populations that spread out and replaced other wolf groups after the last glacial maximum. That is one reason a well-preserved Siberian wolf of this age is so valuable: its DNA could help fill in the family tree of the wolves we know, and of the dogs that were later domesticated from wolves.

The cave lion cubs studied alongside it

The wolf head went on display with a frozen cave lion cub from the same river area, nicknamed Spartak in early reports. Cave lions, Panthera spelaea, were large cats that roamed Eurasia during the Ice Age and died out roughly 14,000 to 15,000 years ago across most of their range.

Several remarkably intact cubs have been found in Yakutia since 2015. Two found near the Uyandina River appear to have been only about a week old, judging by their unerupted milk teeth, and were probably buried by a landslide. Two more from the Tirekhtyakh area, later described in a scientific study as a male about 43,000 years old and a female about 28,000 years old (nicknamed Boris and Sparta), died at around one to two months of age. The female is considered one of the best-preserved Ice Age animals ever found, with fur, whiskers and internal organs intact.

Because the names and details of these cubs were reported somewhat differently over the years, it is worth checking a recent scientific source before quoting any single figure.

Common myths about the wolf head

  • "A giant wolf species was discovered." No new species was announced. It is a Pleistocene grey wolf, and its size is inflated by the frozen soil attached to it.
  • "It is 40,000 years old." That was the early estimate. Radiocarbon dating reported by the researchers gave about 32,000 years.
  • "Scientists will bring it back to life." Preserved tissue can yield ancient DNA, but nothing about this find involved cloning or revival.
  • "Humans cut off its head." There is no convincing evidence for that, according to the researchers.

The real story is impressive enough without exaggeration: a predator that hunted alongside mammoths, looking out of the ice with its fur still on, and offering scientists a rare chance to read its biology directly.

Sources: Smithsonian Magazine, June 2019: Perfectly preserved 32,000-year-old wolf head was found in Siberia; Wikipedia: Pleistocene wolf; Wikipedia: Panthera spelaea (cave lion). Photos: Albert Protopopov; CT renderings: Naoki Suzuki. The find was first reported by The Siberian Times, and Suzuki was interviewed by The Asahi Shimbun.

COMMENTS