Women Wage Peace and the 2016 March of Hope to Jerusalem

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The 2016 March of Hope and Women Wage Peace
Marchers on a 2 week “March of Hope.”

In October 2016 thousands of Israeli women, joined at key moments by Palestinian women, walked for two weeks from the Lebanese border to Jerusalem. The event, organised by the grassroots movement Women Wage Peace and known as the March of Hope, ended on Wednesday 19 October with a rally outside the official residence of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Their demand was specific: restart Israeli-Palestinian negotiations and keep talking until there is a political agreement.

Below is what happened on the march, who the organisers were, what came of it, and how to read some of the bigger claims that were later attached to the story online.

The route: from Rosh Hanikra to Jerusalem

The march set off on the night of Tuesday 4 October 2016 from Rosh Hanikra, the white chalk cliffs on Israel’s northern coast beside the Lebanese border. According to the Times of Israel, about 2,000 people came to the opening event. From there the walkers headed south towards Achziv beach and then on across the country, a journey of roughly 200 kilometres.

The march was timed to finish during the Sukkot holiday. Cyclists riding up from Eilat planned to meet the walkers in Jerusalem on 19 October. Along the way the organisers arranged meetings with Jordanian women at the Island of Peace at Naharayim, on the Jordan River, while Palestinian and Jordanian women organised their own walk from Jericho towards Qasr al-Yahud, the traditional baptism site in the Jordan Valley.

The 2016 March of Hope and Women Wage Peace
Peace marchers rally outside of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s home in Jerusalem.

The final evening in Jerusalem drew a large crowd. Wikipedia’s account of the movement says more than 3,000 Israeli and Palestinian women took part in the march; some press estimates for the closing rally were higher. Among the speakers was Leymah Gbowee, the Liberian activist who shared the 2011 Nobel Peace Prize for leading women’s protests that helped end Liberia’s civil war.

Who Women Wage Peace are

Women Wage Peace was founded in 2014, shortly after that summer’s war in Gaza. Many founders were mothers who had watched their children go into the army and asked a hard question: why do the wars keep coming back, and why are women almost absent from the negotiating rooms where they might end?

The movement describes itself as non-partisan. It does not back a particular map or peace plan. Instead it asks for a negotiated, nonviolent agreement acceptable to both sides, with women involved at every stage. That broad position let religious and secular women, and voters from left, right and centre, march under the same banner. One participant, Raya Kalisman, was reported by the Jerusalem Post as saying that the group had grown out of conversations among mothers about why they were sending their children to fight.

The group grew quickly. By May 2017 it reported more than 20,000 members and supporters, and by 2023 around 45,000 Israeli members.

Why women and peace talks go together

The idea that women should be at the table is not only moral; it is also backed by policy. In 2000 the UN Security Council adopted Resolution 1325 on women, peace and security, which calls for women’s participation in peace processes. Research by groups that study negotiations has repeatedly found that women are badly under-represented in formal talks, and that agreements tend to be more durable when civil society, including women’s groups, has a real voice.

Gbowee’s presence was a deliberate reminder of the Liberian example, where women’s mass, nonviolent pressure helped push warring parties towards an agreement in 2003. The Israeli marchers hoped to apply a similar kind of pressure on their own leaders.

Peace moves elsewhere that autumn

The march was also linked to solidarity events. Organisers listed supporting marches in Jordan, Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco, France and the United States.

The same weeks saw another, very different peace step. On 29 September 2016 the Afghan government signed an agreement with Hezb-i-Islami, the armed faction led by Gulbuddin Hekmatyar. Al Jazeera described it as the first such deal since 2001. It was a reminder that negotiations can succeed even after long and bitter conflicts, although Afghanistan’s wider war continued for years afterwards.

Group meditation and peace: what the evidence says

Some websites that shared the march story added claims about mass meditation reducing violence, often called the “Maharishi Effect”. The idea comes from the Transcendental Meditation (TM) movement, which says that when a large enough group meditates together, crime and conflict fall in the surrounding society.

It is worth being clear about the evidence. Studies of this kind, including analyses of meditation assemblies in Fairfield, Iowa, The Hague and Washington DC in the 1980s and 1990s, were mostly carried out by researchers connected to the TM movement. A widely repeated claim that the RAND Corporation found a 72% drop in terrorism is misleading: RAND compiled databases of terrorist incidents that were later used by TM researchers, but RAND did not run or endorse the meditation studies. Independent critics have argued that the data were selectively chosen and that no plausible mechanism has been shown. Sceptic James Randi reported that Fairfield’s police chief saw no change in local crime.

Meditation has well-studied benefits for individual stress and wellbeing. As a tool for ending wars at a distance, it remains unproven. The marchers themselves were asking for something concrete: negotiations.

Practical ways to support peace

The 2016 March of Hope and Women Wage Peace

The simple “me, us, you” diagram above sums up the starting point of most conflict-resolution work: finding the overlap between two sides before arguing about the differences. Few of us can walk 200 kilometres across a country, but there are smaller steps that follow the spirit of the march:

  • Listen before arguing. Many peace activists recommend Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life by Marshall Rosenberg, a practical guide to expressing needs without blame.
  • Support joint projects. Groups that bring Israelis and Palestinians together in schools, clinics and businesses keep personal contact alive when politics stalls.
  • Read beyond one side. Following reliable reporters from different backgrounds helps avoid the simplifications that feed hostility.
  • Back women’s participation. Encourage the inclusion of women and civil society in any negotiation process.

What happened next

The march did not restart negotiations, which had been frozen since a US-led effort collapsed in April 2014. But Women Wage Peace kept organising, and the march inspired Yael Deckelbaum’s song “Prayer of the Mothers”, which used clips of Gbowee’s speech and spread widely online.

In 2023 the movement and its Palestinian partner group, Women of the Sun, held a joint peace event in Jerusalem on 4 October. Three days later, on 7 October 2023, Vivian Silver, one of the founders of Women Wage Peace and a lifelong worker for Arab-Jewish cooperation, was killed in the Hamas attack on Kibbutz Be’eri. She was 74. Her death was confirmed in November 2023 after weeks of uncertainty. Her colleagues have continued the work she helped begin.

Sources: Times of Israel: Hundreds of women march on Jerusalem for peace; Jerusalem Post: Women Wage Peace rally in Jerusalem; Wikipedia: Women Wage Peace; Women Wage Peace; Al Jazeera: Afghanistan and Hekmatyar sign peace deal; Wikipedia: Maharishi effect; Al Jazeera: Vivian Silver confirmed killed. Original story via The Mind Unleashed.

Related:

Explore the related article: The Hogans' Land Donation and Its Meaning Beyond Price.

COMMENTS