Smoker's Lungs vs Healthy Lungs: What the Viral Video Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-12-13.

A Smoking Demonstration Using Lung Specimens

A short video shared by Amanda Eller, a nurse from North Carolina, shows two pairs of human lungs being inflated with air side by side. The healthy pair turns pink, swells and then slowly empties, the way lungs should. The other pair is black and stiff, barely expands and then collapses almost at once. According to the caption, it came from a person who smoked a pack a day for 20 years. The clip spread across social media in May 2018 and was viewed millions of times.

The video is graphic but not gory. It is worth watching because it shows something statistics cannot: what years of smoke do to the organ that keeps us breathing. The video is embedded further down this page.

What the video shows

Lungs work a bit like elastic balloons. When we breathe in, they stretch. When we breathe out, natural recoil pushes the air back out without any effort. In the healthy lungs in the video you can see both stages clearly.

The smoker's lungs behave quite differently. Eller explained to viewers: "These lungs are COPD lungs, cancerous lungs." She said the tissue had lost its elasticity, so instead of filling and emptying smoothly, the lungs stretch a little and then snap straight back. The dark colour comes from tar and other particles in tobacco smoke that build up in the lung tissue over years.

A demonstration like this has limits. It shows two specific organs, not an average, and we do not know every detail of either donor's health. Even so, the damage it shows matches what doctors and pathologists describe in long-term smokers.

COPD: the slow loss of breath

COPD, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, is an umbrella term for long-term lung conditions that make it steadily harder to breathe. It includes emphysema, where the tiny air sacs in the lungs are destroyed, and chronic bronchitis, where the airways stay inflamed and clogged with mucus. People with advanced COPD can become breathless just walking across a room.

COPD was the fourth-biggest cause of death in the world in 2021, with about 3.65 million deaths. Smoking is the largest single risk factor, behind more than 70% of cases in high-income countries. Air pollution and workplace dust and fumes account for many cases in people who have never smoked. The damage of emphysema is permanent. Treatment can ease symptoms and slow the disease, but it cannot rebuild destroyed lung tissue, which is why stopping early matters so much.

Smoking and lung cancer: the numbers

Lung cancer is the disease most closely tied to smoking. According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC):

  • People who smoke cigarettes are about 15 to 30 times more likely to get lung cancer, or die from it, than people who do not smoke.
  • Smoking is linked to roughly 80% of lung cancer deaths in the United States.
  • Even light or occasional smoking raises the risk, and breathing other people's smoke can also cause lung cancer.

You may still see claims online that male smokers are only 23 percent more likely to get lung cancer. That badly understates the risk. The comparison is in multiples, not percentages: smokers are many times more likely to develop the disease. In the UK, Cancer Research UK has estimated that smoking causes around 86% of lung cancer deaths.

Smoking also raises the risk of many other cancers, including those of the mouth, throat, oesophagus, bladder, kidney and pancreas. It is a major cause of heart attacks and strokes too.

The global toll

The World Health Organization says tobacco kills more than 7 million people every year. That includes more than 1.6 million non-smokers who die from exposure to second-hand smoke. There are about 1.2 billion tobacco users worldwide, and around 80% of them live in low- and middle-income countries. The WHO is clear that there is no safe level of exposure and that all forms of tobacco are harmful.

In some countries the trend is improving. In 1962 more than 70% of British men and about 40% of British women smoked. By 2024, the Office for National Statistics found that just 9.1% of adults in Great Britain smoked cigarettes. Smoke-free laws for workplaces and enclosed public places, introduced across the UK in 2006 and 2007, higher taxes, plain packaging and support to quit have all played a part.

Common myths about smoking and lungs

"It's too late to bother quitting." It is not. Stopping at any age lowers the risk of lung cancer, heart disease and stroke over time, and it slows the decline in lung function. Some damage, like emphysema, cannot be undone, but quitting stops it getting worse as quickly.

"A few cigarettes a day is harmless." The CDC notes that even light or occasional smoking raises lung cancer risk. There is no safe threshold.

"My grandfather smoked and lived to 90." Some smokers do live long lives, just as some people survive car crashes without a seatbelt. Risk is about odds. Across millions of people, smoking shortens lives by years.

"Black lungs always mean a smoker." Not always. Coal miners, people exposed to heavy air pollution and city dwellers can all have darkened lung tissue. But in smokers the discoloration usually comes with the loss of elasticity shown in the video.

If you want to stop

Many smokers want to quit, and many need several attempts before they succeed. According to the WHO, counselling and medication can more than double the chances of quitting for good. Stop-smoking services, nicotine replacement products and prescription treatments are available in many countries, often free or at low cost.

If you smoke and are worried about your lungs, or you have a lasting cough, breathlessness or chest pain, talk to a doctor. They can check your lung function and help you find the support that suits you.

Sources: Interesting Engineering, May 2018 (Amanda Eller video); CDC: Lung cancer risk factors; World Health Organization: Tobacco fact sheet; Wikipedia: Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; Wikipedia: Smoking in the United Kingdom. Video embedded from YouTube.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. I was diagnosed of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) in 2012 at the age of 63. I had been a heavy smoker, my symptoms started out with dry cough and shortness of breath, i ended up in the hospital, on a ventilator. I should have known it was coming, but like most smokers, thought it would never happen to me. My COPD got significantly worse and unbearable because of my difficulty catching breath. Last year, i started on a natural COPD Herbal therapy from Natural Herbal Gardens, i read a lot of positive reviews from patients who used the treatment and i immediately started on it. I had great relief with this herbal treatment. I breath very much better now, no case of shortness of breath or chest tightness since treatment. Visit Natural Herbal Gardens website ww w. naturalherbalgardens. com. This COPD treatment is a miracle!!

    ReplyDelete