Is Loneliness as Bad as Smoking 15 Cigarettes a Day?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Loneliness and Health: Understanding the Comparison With Smoking

The short answer: loneliness and weak social ties are linked to a higher risk of dying early, and researchers have compared the size of that risk to smoking about 15 cigarettes a day. That does not mean feeling lonely damages your lungs, or that a lonely evening equals a pack of cigarettes. It means that, across large populations followed for years, people with poor social connection die sooner on average, by a margin similar to some of the best-known health risks.

The comparison went viral in May 2018, when the health insurer Cigna published a survey of 20,000 American adults suggesting that the youngest adults were the loneliest of all. Below is what that survey actually measured, where the cigarette figure comes from, what it can and cannot tell you, and what helps.

What the 2018 Cigna survey found

Cigna ran its survey online with adults aged 18 and over, using the UCLA Loneliness Scale, a long-established questionnaire in which people rate how often they feel left out, isolated or lacking companionship. Scores run from 20 to 80, and higher means lonelier. The national average was 44.

The surprise was the age pattern. Generation Z, then aged roughly 18 to 22, averaged 48.3. Millennials scored 45.3, baby boomers 42.4, and the oldest group, people aged 72 and over, 38.6. In other words, the people most often pictured as lonely, the very old, reported the least loneliness, while those just starting adult life reported the most.

Some of the headline percentages were striking too. Nearly half of respondents said they always or sometimes felt alone or left out, 54% said they felt that no one knew them well, and about two in five said they lacked companionship or that their relationships were not meaningful.

Two findings ran against popular assumptions. First, the survey found no clear correlation between social media use and loneliness: heavy users were not markedly lonelier than light ones. Second, people who had more face-to-face interaction each day were less lonely in every age group. Working far too much, or too little, was also tied to higher loneliness, which suggests the workplace is a real source of social contact for many adults.

Cigna’s chief executive, David Cordani, summed up the result bluntly: “Half of Americans view themselves as lonely.”

Where the 15 cigarettes comparison comes from

The cigarette figure did not come from the Cigna questionnaire itself. A survey of how people feel at one moment cannot measure how long they live. The comparison traces back to research led by Julianne Holt-Lunstad, a psychologist at Brigham Young University.

In 2010 she and two colleagues published a meta-analysis in PLOS Medicine that pooled 148 studies covering 308,849 people, followed for an average of seven and a half years. People with stronger social relationships had about a 50% greater likelihood of survival over the study periods than those with weaker ties. The authors called the effect comparable to well-established risk factors for death, and the journal’s summary noted it was similar to smoking and alcohol use and larger than physical inactivity or obesity.

Holt-Lunstad later translated that effect size into an everyday image, roughly the mortality risk of smoking up to 15 cigarettes a day. The line spread widely, and in 2023 the US Surgeon General, Vivek Murthy, used it in an official advisory calling loneliness and isolation an epidemic. In the NPR coverage of that advisory, Murthy said that about one in two US adults reported measurable levels of loneliness, and that young people were the loneliest group.

A risk comparison is not a literal equivalence

What the comparison does and does not mean

A risk comparison is a way of conveying scale, not a statement that two things are the same. Several points are worth keeping in mind.

  • It is about averages. The finding describes large groups over years, not a forecast for any single person.
  • It mixes different measures. The 2010 analysis included studies of marriage, living alone, network size, social support and feelings of loneliness. The strongest links came from complex measures of how integrated people were in social life; simply living alone showed the weakest association.
  • Cause and effect are hard to separate. Nobody can randomly assign people to have few friends. Illness can cause isolation as well as follow from it, and the authors acknowledged this.
  • Loneliness and isolation are not identical. Isolation is objective: few contacts. Loneliness is the painful feeling that your connections fall short of what you need. You can be surrounded by people and still lonely, or live quietly and feel content.

So the fair takeaway is not “loneliness is literally as deadly as smoking”, but “social connection belongs on the same list of health factors as smoking, exercise and weight, and deserves to be taken as seriously.”

Why loneliness might affect the body

Researchers have proposed several pathways, and the evidence for each is still developing. One is chronic stress: feeling unsafe or unsupported can keep the body’s stress systems switched on, and long-term stress is associated with inflammation, higher blood pressure and poorer sleep. Another is behaviour: people with fewer close ties may have less help noticing symptoms, getting to appointments or keeping up healthy routines. A third is mental health, since loneliness overlaps with depression and anxiety.

The Surgeon General’s advisory linked social disconnection with higher risks of cardiovascular disease, stroke, dementia, depression, anxiety and premature death. These are associations drawn from many studies, not proof that loneliness alone causes each condition. If loneliness is affecting your sleep, mood or health, talking to a doctor is a sensible step.

Why young adults score so high

It seems backwards that the most digitally connected generation reports the most loneliness. A few explanations are commonly offered. Early adulthood is full of transitions, such as leaving home, starting university or a first job, and moving cities, and each one breaks up existing friendships before new ones form. Older adults have often settled into long relationships and routines. Younger people may also be more willing to admit to feeling lonely on a questionnaire.

On social media, Holt-Lunstad told NPR that how people use it matters more than how much. Passive scrolling tends to be linked with worse feelings, while using platforms to arrange meetings and talk with real friends is linked with better ones. That fits Cigna’s finding that daily in-person contact, rather than screen time on its own, was what separated the less lonely from the more lonely.

A risk comparison is not a literal equivalence

Practical ways to feel more connected

The habits that help are not glamorous, and they are easier to list than to keep. Still, the research points in a consistent direction.

  • Prioritise face-to-face time. A regular coffee, walk or meal with the same person builds closeness faster than occasional large gatherings.
  • Use your phone to meet, not to watch. Message a friend to make a plan instead of scrolling through their updates.
  • Protect sleep and movement. Exercise and rest support mood and energy, which makes it easier to reach out. Group activities such as a running club, choir or volunteer shift combine both.
  • Keep work in balance. Cigna found both overwork and too little work linked with loneliness. Small chats with colleagues count.
  • Help someone else. Murthy has described service to others as one of the strongest antidotes to loneliness. Volunteering gives structure and a shared purpose.
  • Be patient. Friendships take repeated contact to form. Feeling awkward at first is normal, not a sign that it is not working.

If loneliness has become heavy or persistent, or comes with low mood or thoughts of self-harm, speak to a doctor or a mental health professional. In the US, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline is available by call or text.

Common myths about loneliness

“Only older people are lonely.” Both the Cigna survey and the 2023 advisory found young adults reporting the highest levels.

“Social media is the cause.” The 2018 survey did not find a simple link between social media use and loneliness. The way people use it seems to matter more.

“Being alone means being lonely.” Solitude can be restful. Loneliness is the gap between the connection you want and the connection you have.

“It is just a feeling.” Decades of research tie social connection to physical health outcomes, which is why public health officials now treat it as a health issue rather than only a personal one.

Sources: Holt-Lunstad, Smith and Layton, “Social Relationships and Mortality Risk”, PLOS Medicine (2010); NPR via KQED on the 2018 Cigna loneliness survey; NPR on the 2023 Surgeon General advisory. Images: film stills shared via 9gag; the second and third are from Spike Jonze’s film Her (2013).

COMMENTS