
Cleared land and new plantation blocks inside the PT Megakarya Jaya Raya (PT MJR) concession in Papua province, Indonesia, photographed in early 2018. Photo: Ulet Ifansasti / Greenpeace.
In April 2018, Greenpeace International published photographs, video and satellite analysis alleging that a palm oil concession in Indonesia’s Papua province had cleared roughly 4,000 hectares of rainforest between May 2015 and April 2017. The concession, PT Megakarya Jaya Raya, was linked by Greenpeace to the Hayel Saeed Anam (HSA) group, a family-owned conglomerate whose other subsidiaries had supplied palm oil to Mars, Nestlé, PepsiCo and Unilever.
The short answer to “what did the investigation find?” is this: forest was being cleared for a plantation that was not yet producing oil, part of the clearing appeared to fall inside land the Indonesian government had zoned for protection after the 2015 fires, and the group behind it was connected, through sister companies, to some of the best-known food brands in the world. Below we look at what that evidence showed, what it could not show, and why the case still matters for anyone trying to understand palm oil.
What Greenpeace reported in 2018
Greenpeace released the material on 27 April 2018, in a press statement issued from London. Its researchers compared satellite images over two years and estimated that around 4,000 hectares had been opened up inside the PT MJR concession. For a sense of scale, the organisation pointed out that this is close to half the area of Paris.
The aerial photographs and drone footage were taken in March and April 2018. They show long, straight strips of bare earth, felled timber and freshly cut drainage lines, the typical first stage of a new oil palm estate. According to Greenpeace, some of the clearance sat inside an area that the government had mapped as protected peat landscape in early 2017, under a peatland regulation passed after the disastrous fire season of 2015. New development is not allowed on land with that status.
It is worth noting where this is. Papua is an Indonesian province on the western half of the island of New Guinea. It is not the same as Papua New Guinea, the independent country on the eastern half, even though older write-ups of this story sometimes mixed the two up.
The video above, shared by EcoWatch at the time, gathers the Greenpeace footage from the concession. Viewed today it is best treated as a record of what the land looked like in spring 2018, rather than a picture of its present state.
How the concession was linked to global brands
PT MJR itself was not selling palm oil in 2018; its trees had not even been planted on much of the cleared land. The link to consumer brands ran through other parts of the same business family. Greenpeace said members of the Saeed Anam family had management control over four concessions in Papua with a combined land bank of more than 150,000 hectares.
Two other HSA companies, Arma Group and Pacific Oils & Fats, appeared in supplier lists that the brands themselves had published in early 2018. Arma was listed as a supplier to Mars, PepsiCo and Unilever, while Nestlé reported receiving oil from a mill controlled by Pacific Oils & Fats. All four brands had public “no deforestation, no peat, no exploitation” commitments, often shortened to NDPE.
That is the heart of the campaign argument. If a buyer promises not to source from companies that clear forest, does the promise cover only the specific mill it buys from, or the whole corporate group behind that mill? Greenpeace argued for the second reading. Richard George, a forests campaigner at Greenpeace UK, put the charge bluntly: companies like Unilever and Nestlé claim to be industry leaders
, yet were still buying from the HSA group.
The press release did not include responses from HSA or from the brands, so the published record of this episode is largely one side’s case. That does not make it wrong, but readers should keep it in mind.

An aerial view of land clearance and plantation development in the PT MJR concession, Papua. Photo: Ulet Ifansasti / Greenpeace.
The RSPO question
The case also raised questions for the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), the industry certification body founded in 2004. Several HSA palm oil businesses were RSPO members. PT MJR and the group’s other concessions in the same district were not.
RSPO rules are meant to stop members from keeping a “clean” certified arm while operating uncertified plantations elsewhere in the same group. Greenpeace argued that this was exactly the pattern here, and that the clearing it documented would breach several of the RSPO’s Principles and Criteria, the standard every certified grower has to meet.
This was not an isolated complaint. Environmental and labour groups have long criticised the RSPO for weak enforcement, and research on whether certification actually reduces forest loss has produced mixed results. Supporters reply that the standard has been tightened over time, including a 2018 revision that added clearer rules on deforestation and peat. The PT MJR case became one example in that wider argument.

A Greenpeace team member in a helicopter points out cleared ground and plantation rows in the PT MJR concession. Photo: Ulet Ifansasti / Greenpeace.
Why peat and protected zoning matter
Much of the concern about palm oil in Indonesia is not only about trees. Large parts of the country’s lowland forest grow on peat, a waterlogged layer of partly decayed plant matter that can be several metres deep. Draining peat for plantations dries it out, which releases carbon slowly and makes the ground extremely flammable.
The 2015 haze crisis showed what that means in practice. Fires on drained peat burned for months, blanketing Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore in smoke. One widely cited study estimated around 100,000 excess deaths linked to that haze across the three countries. Indonesia responded by creating a Peatland Restoration Agency and by re-mapping peat areas, some of which were zoned off from further development. That is why clearing inside a mapped protection zone was treated as a serious allegation rather than a technicality.
Papua matters for another reason. As older plantation regions in Sumatra and Kalimantan filled up, the industry began to look east, to one of the largest remaining blocks of intact tropical forest in Asia. Expansion there has also affected customary land belonging to Indigenous Papuan communities. Campaigners in 2018 described Papua as a new frontier, and this concession was one of the first places they pointed to.
What photos and satellite data can and cannot prove
A useful way to read stories like this is to split them into three separate questions:
- What happened on the ground? Satellite comparisons and aerial photos are strong evidence here. They can show when forest disappeared and roughly how much.
- Who controlled the land? This depends on company registries, concession maps and ownership records, which are often hard to obtain in Indonesia.
- How was that company tied to buyers? This relies on supplier lists, which are usually dated snapshots and can change month to month.
The 2018 material was strongest on the first question and drew on published lists for the third. A photo of a cleared hillside cannot by itself prove which chocolate bar or shampoo contained oil from a related company. Equally, a well-written corporate policy is not evidence that every supplier follows it. Good reporting keeps both of those limits in view.
What has happened since, and what readers can do
In September 2018, a few months after this investigation, Indonesia’s president signed a three-year moratorium on new palm oil permits and ordered a review of existing licences. The 2020 target that many brands had set for deforestation-free supply chains came and went, and campaign groups reported that it was widely missed.
If you want to follow a story like this today, a few habits help:
- Check the date of any supplier list before linking a brand to a plantation.
- Look for the maps behind a satellite claim, including the boundaries used and the time period.
- Read company responses and later grievance updates, which buyers often publish when they suspend a supplier.
- Remember that “sustainable” labels vary. RSPO certification, NDPE policies and government rules are three different things.
Boycotting palm oil outright is not a simple fix, because replacement oils can need far more land per tonne. Many researchers argue that better-enforced standards, transparent supply chains and protection for peat and Indigenous land do more good than switching crops.
Sources: Greenpeace International press release, 27 April 2018; Wikipedia: Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil; Wikipedia: Palm oil production in Indonesia; video embed via EcoWatch on Facebook; first reported to us via Truth Theory. Photographs: Ulet Ifansasti / Greenpeace.

COMMENTS