Zuckerberg's 2018 Testimony to Congress: The Internet Reacts

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

On 10 April 2018, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg appeared before a joint session of the US Senate Judiciary and Commerce committees to answer questions about the Cambridge Analytica data scandal. Forty-four senators took part, and the next day he faced the House Energy and Commerce Committee. It was his first appearance before Congress, and while the questions were serious, millions of people watched the live hearing online and turned it into one of the biggest comedy events of the year on Twitter.

Below is the background to the hearing, followed by a selection of the tweets and memes it produced, with notes on who wrote them and what they were referring to.

Why Zuckerberg was called to testify

In March 2018, former Cambridge Analytica employee Christopher Wylie went public with the story of how the political consulting firm had obtained Facebook data. The information had been collected through a personality quiz app called “This Is Your Digital Life”, built by researcher Aleksandr Kogan. Zuckerberg said around 300,000 people installed it, but because of how Facebook’s platform then worked, the app could also collect data about their friends. Facebook later said the data of up to 87 million users may have been shared improperly.

Around the same time, Facebook reportedly confirmed that it used automated tools to scan links and images sent through Messenger for abuse, which added to public unease about privacy. Claims that the company read every private conversation go further than what was reported; the scanning described was automated and aimed at spam and abuse.

What happened in the hearing

Zuckerberg, wearing a suit rather than his usual T-shirt, apologised at the start: “It was my mistake, and I’m sorry.” Over roughly five hours, senators asked about data sharing, election interference, regulation and whether Facebook is a monopoly. Senator Dick Durbin asked him to name the hotel he had stayed in the night before, and he declined, which made Durbin’s point about privacy in a single exchange.

The best-remembered moment came when Senator Orrin Hatch asked how Facebook could sustain a business when users do not pay. After a pause, Zuckerberg replied: “Senator, we run ads.” That exchange, and a few others, fed the impression that some lawmakers did not understand the platform, although other senators pressed him hard on consent and accountability.

The reactions: tech support for Congress

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

robbysoave

Reason editor Robby Soave captured the night’s most common joke within hours of the hearing starting: a young tech founder explaining the internet to much older lawmakers. It became the dominant framing of the coverage, sometimes unfairly, since several senators asked pointed questions about data and consent.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

bobvulfov

Writer Bob Vulfov imagined a senator using the hearing to ask about FarmVille, the Zynga farming game that was hugely popular on Facebook around 2009 and 2010. The joke played on fears that the session would be spent on trivial questions rather than privacy.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

StephenAtHome

Late-night host Stephen Colbert joked that Zuckerberg could not leave a room full of senior lawmakers without fixing their wifi. The tweet appeared shortly after midnight, as the reaction continued into the next day.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

KFILE

CNN reporter Andrew Kaczynski asked which senator would be first to raise a grandchild ignoring a friend request. The jokes about the senators’ ages were common; the average age of the Senate was in the early sixties at the time.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

ditzkoff

Dave Itzkoff of The New York Times invented a question for Senator Chuck Grassley, then chairman of the Judiciary Committee, about the free trial disks that America Online mailed out in huge numbers in the 1990s. Grassley was 84 at the time of the hearing.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

gilbertjasono

Jason O. Gilbert put another imaginary question in Grassley’s mouth, this time about finding a Hotmail account. Hotmail was a separate email service, bought by Microsoft in 1997, which is exactly why the line is funny.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

dens

Foursquare co-founder Dennis Crowley joked that parts of the testimony sounded like holiday tech support for relatives. Coming from a tech founder, it was a friendly nod to how often Zuckerberg had to explain basic features.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

xLiserx

A play on Facebook’s own relationship-status options, which have included “It’s complicated” since the site’s early years. The joke summed up the public mood toward the platform in spring 2018.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

quintabrunson

Actor and writer Quinta Brunson needed only four words, captioning a photo of the press pack around the witness table as a sequel to The Social Network. The image shows the wall of photographers that greeted Zuckerberg as he took his seat.

The reactions: is he human?

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

IStillSupportTrump

An animated meme added a “smile” slider beneath Zuckerberg, as if his expression were being adjusted by software. His carefully neutral face during long questioning was the raw material for dozens of jokes like this.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

AlternativeFactss

A widely shared image placed a line about gathering data to understand humanity beside a still of Zuckerberg looking unusually serious. The “Zuckerberg is a robot” theme was already an old internet joke, and the hearing revived it.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

stillgray

Ian Miles Cheong wrote a mock dialogue in which “The Zuckerberg” accidentally reveals itself as an infiltration unit before changing the subject to fishing. The joke builds on the same robot theme, with the timing of a short comedy sketch.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

slyscorpion

This edited still shows an aide behind Zuckerberg urging him to tick an “I’m not a robot” box, the CAPTCHA test familiar to anyone who has filled in an online form. It is one of the best-known images from the hearing.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

OctopussSevenTwo

Zuckerberg took sips of water throughout the session, and a captioned GIF framed each sip as a careful imitation of human behaviour. The misspelled caption is part of the joke.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

MatthewTeague

Journalist Matthew Teague placed Zuckerberg beside Data, the android officer played by Brent Spiner in Star Trek: The Next Generation. The resemblance in pale complexion and fixed expression made it one of the more inventive comparisons.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

JHickman

Jonathan Hickman’s four-word tweet, in capitals, ran under a still of Zuckerberg entering the hearing. It became one of the signature lines of the day, with more than 11,000 likes.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

MikeZakarian

This tweet paired the hearing with an image of an expressionless humanoid robot. It is one more variant of the android theme that dominated the day.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

Bmac0507

A close-up of Zuckerberg’s calm expression was captioned as the look of someone who knows enough to destroy everyone asking the questions. Jokes about Facebook knowing everything about everyone were a natural response to a hearing about data collection.

The reactions: faces, hair and The Social Network

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

ZackBornstein

Comedy writer Zack Bornstein pointed back to Facemash, the 2003 Harvard site on which students compared classmates’ photos, and contrasted it with Facebook’s later political influence. His tweet drew more than 170,000 likes, among the most of any reaction that day.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

BrandyLJensen

Writer Brandy Jensen aimed her joke at the CEO’s haircut rather than his testimony. Light, personal jabs like this made up a large share of the reactions, alongside the more serious criticism.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

joshuatopolsky

Joshua Topolsky, a technology journalist and founder of The Outline, used the familiar “record scratch, freeze frame” movie cliché. It suggests a narrator about to explain how he ended up in front of Congress.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

IfyNwadiwe

This tweet set a laughing photo of Zuckerberg beside his stern face at the hearing, comparing it to a student whose parents have been called into the principal’s office. The contrast between relaxed and formal Zuckerberg became a template for many memes.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

timkmak

Politics reporter Tim Mak made a similar comparison: Zuckerberg as he appears on his own Facebook profile versus Zuckerberg in a Senate committee room. The point was that the hearing showed a side of him users rarely saw.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

PeteBlackburn

Sports writer Pete Blackburn joked that Zuckerberg looked as if he had not slept since MySpace, the social network that was larger than Facebook until around 2008. The reference reminded readers how quickly online platforms can rise and fall.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

DanaSchwartzzz

Comedy writer Dana Schwartz focused on his short, straight fringe, comparing it to an impulsive home haircut. With more than 30,000 likes, it was one of the most shared jokes of the afternoon.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

amberdiscko

Amber Discko paired a photo of Zuckerberg drinking water with a caption about realising one’s actions have consequences. It reflected a serious theme in light form: the hearing was about accountability for how user data had been handled.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

GermainLussier

Germain Lussier noted that Jesse Eisenberg’s portrayal of Zuckerberg in the 2010 film The Social Network looked more convincing with every real-life appearance. The film was directed by David Fincher from a screenplay by Aaron Sorkin.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

MarciaBelsky

Comedy writer Marcia Belsky compared Zuckerberg’s polite, patient expression to a partner listening to the same party story for the fifth time. Many of his answers were variations of promising that his team would follow up.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

OctopussSevenTwo

An edited GIF shrank Zuckerberg’s face into a child-like caricature over a live news caption, with a quote about Snapchat. It is a reminder that many of the most viral items were edits rather than real moments, so they should be read as satire.

Tweets Reacting to Mark Zuckerberg's Congressional Testimony

sylvioso

Posted two days before the hearing, on 8 April 2018, this tweet argued that Jesse Eisenberg’s twitchy screen version had been “ahead of its time”. It shows that the comparison to the film was already circulating as the testimony approached.

What happened next

The jokes faded within days, but the consequences lasted much longer. Cambridge Analytica filed for bankruptcy and shut down in May 2018. In July 2019, the US Federal Trade Commission voted 3–2 to approve a $5 billion penalty against Facebook over its privacy practices, one of the largest fines of its kind. The scandal also helped push data protection and the role of social media in elections to the centre of political debate in many countries.

For readers today, the hearing is a useful reminder of two things. First, the settings that control what apps can see about you and your friends matter, and it is worth reviewing them from time to time. Second, viral reaction images are often edited or invented, as several of those above are, so a meme is not a record of what was actually said.

Sources: Wikipedia: Facebook–Cambridge Analytica data scandal; Fortune: Mark Zuckerberg’s most awkward moments before Congress; The Next Web: Highlights of Zuckerberg’s sit-down with 44 senators; Hearing video on YouTube.

COMMENTS