
CC0 Public Domain
In October 2017 a University of Maine psychologist, Jonathan Borkum, proposed a striking idea: a migraine attack may not be the brain breaking down, but the brain defending itself. In his paper in the journal Headache, he argued that the pain, nausea and sensitivity that make an attack so miserable could be side effects of a built-in response to oxidative stress, a chemical strain on brain cells. The short answer to "are migraines the body's defence?" is this: it is a serious, published hypothesis supported by indirect evidence, not a proven fact, and it has not changed how doctors treat migraine today.
Below we explain what the theory says, the evidence behind it, where it is weak, and what it means for people who live with migraine.
What oxidative stress is
Every cell that burns oxygen for energy produces reactive by-products, often called reactive oxygen species. Small amounts are normal and even useful, because cells use some of them as signals. Trouble begins when these molecules build up faster than the body's antioxidant systems can neutralise them. That imbalance is what scientists mean by oxidative stress. Left unchecked, it can damage fats, proteins and DNA inside cells.
The brain is especially exposed. It uses a large share of the body's energy, it is rich in fats that oxidise easily, and its nerve cells live a long time, so damage can accumulate. That is why oxidative stress is studied in stroke, Parkinson's disease and Alzheimer's disease, and why the idea of a brain-wide alarm system for it is plausible.
What Borkum proposed
The paper, titled The Migraine Attack as a Homeostatic, Neuroprotective Response to Brain Oxidative Stress: Preliminary Evidence for a Theory, appeared online on 16 October 2017 and in print in the January 2018 issue of Headache (volume 58, pages 118 to 135). It is a "views and perspectives" piece: Borkum reviewed earlier studies and assembled them into an argument, rather than running a new experiment.
His reasoning runs in three steps:
- People with migraine may carry more oxidative stress. Several studies have found higher levels of lipid peroxides, a marker of oxidative damage, in people with migraine between attacks.
- Familiar triggers add to it. Psychological stress, poor or irregular sleep, noise, certain foods and air pollution can all raise oxidant production in the brain. On this view, a trigger works by pushing an already strained system past a threshold.
- A sensor turns the strain into a signal. An ion channel called TRPA1, found on pain-sensing nerves in the membranes around the brain, responds to oxidants. When it fires, it sets off the neurogenic inflammation that is part of a migraine attack.
The University of Maine summarised his view of an attack as "a particularly violent return to homeostasis": a forceful effort by the brain to bring itself back into balance.
The parts of an attack that may protect the brain
The most interesting part of the paper is its walk through the individual events of an attack. Borkum looked at cortical spreading depression (the slow wave of nerve activity linked to aura), platelet activation, leakage of plasma proteins, nitric oxide production, and the release of serotonin, substance P, CGRP and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF).
In laboratory work, animal studies and research on interrupted blood flow to the brain, many of these events appear protective. Depending on the study, they reduce the production of oxidants, raise antioxidant enzymes, lower energy demand, prevent cell death, support the growth of new mitochondria, and release growth factors that help existing neurons survive and new ones form. Borkum also pointed to feedback loops linking these events, which led him to suggest they behave as one coordinated system rather than a random cascade.
The comparison he drew is with fever or coughing. Those symptoms are unpleasant, but they are part of the body's response to infection, not the infection itself. If migraine works the same way, the attack would be the reaction, and the real problem would be whatever keeps generating the oxidative stress underneath.
How strong is the evidence?
The paper's own subtitle calls the evidence preliminary, and that is a fair description. Three cautions matter:
- Much of the support comes from cell cultures, animals and stroke research. It shows that these mechanisms can protect neurons in those settings, not that they do so during a human migraine.
- A protective purpose is hard to test directly. Researchers would need to show that brains which have migraine attacks end up healthier than they otherwise would, which is difficult to measure.
- Antioxidant pills are not a proven shortcut. Large trials of antioxidant supplements for other diseases have mostly been disappointing, and high-dose beta-carotene and vitamin E supplements have been linked to harm in some groups. So "fight oxidative stress" does not automatically translate into "take supplements".
Borkum kept developing the idea. In a 2021 review in Neurochemical Research he argued that brains prone to migraine run an energy deficit between attacks, either because a hyperexcitable brain needs more energy or because its mitochondria supply less, and that this shortfall is a source of the oxidants that set attacks off.
Why migraine research matters so much
Migraine is far more than a bad headache. The Global Burden of Disease study estimates that it affects about 14% of people worldwide in a given year, around 1.16 billion people, and ranks it among the most disabling conditions of the nervous system. It is roughly two to three times more common in women than in men, especially between the ages of 30 and 50.
An attack often comes in phases: an early "prodrome" with yawning, food cravings, mood changes or a stiff neck; an aura of flashing lights or zigzag lines in about a third of people; a headache phase that lasts from 4 to 72 hours in adults; and a washed-out "postdrome" afterwards. Because it strikes during working years, it costs economies heavily in lost work days.
Where treatment has gone since 2017
While the oxidative stress theory remains a hypothesis, treatment has moved forward along a different path. In May 2018 the US Food and Drug Administration approved erenumab (Aimovig), a once-monthly injection developed by Amgen and Novartis. It was the first of a new class of preventive medicines that block CGRP, a signalling molecule released during attacks. Other CGRP antibodies and tablets called gepants have followed, and major headache societies now list CGRP-targeting drugs as a first-line option for prevention. Triptans remain a standard choice for treating moderate to severe attacks once they start.
Interestingly, CGRP is one of the molecules on Borkum's list of possibly protective signals. That is a reminder that blocking part of an attack can bring real relief even while scientists still debate what the attack is for.
Practical takeaways
- Keep a diary. Recording attacks, sleep, meals, stress and, for women, the menstrual cycle helps you and your doctor spot patterns. The NHS recommends this as a first step.
- Regular routines help many people. Skipped meals, dehydration, disrupted sleep and too much caffeine are common triggers.
- Talk to a doctor if attacks are frequent, getting worse or hard to control. Preventive treatment exists and has improved.
- Get urgent help for a sudden, extremely severe headache, weakness on one side of the body, confusion, loss of vision, a seizure, or a headache after a head injury. These are not typical migraine signs.
For now, the idea that a migraine is the brain protecting itself is best seen as a thoughtful hypothesis. If it holds up, future prevention may focus less on silencing attacks and more on easing the hidden strain that sets them off.
Original paper: Jonathan M. Borkum, The Migraine Attack as a Homeostatic, Neuroprotective Response to Brain Oxidative Stress: Preliminary Evidence for a Theory, Headache 58(1), 2018. DOI: 10.1111/head.13214. Earlier report: Medical Xpress, with material provided by Wiley (journal page: Headache).
Sources: PubMed: Borkum, Headache 2018; University of Maine news; Neuroscience News on Borkum's 2021 review; Wikipedia: Migraine; Wikipedia: Oxidative stress; NeurologyLive, 17 May 2018; NHS: Migraine. Image: CC0 public domain.
Related:
- How To Stop A Migraine Instantly
- Missing This Vitamin In Your Diet Can Increase Your Risk of Frequent Migraines By 300%
- 16 Of Nature’s Best Natural Pain Killers
- An NSAID Painkiller-Risk Infographic and Its Limits
- Hydration and Dehydration: Correcting Common Claims About Water
- A Sciatica Exercise Video: Movement and Its Limits
- Top 10 Exercises to Strengthen Your Back and Reduce Back Pain
- Ten Tips From A Shaolin Monk On How To Stay Young
- This 122 Year Old Woman Has The Most Important Secret To A Life Of Longevity
- One Injection Reverses Diabetes Symptoms Without Side Effect
- How To Clean Your Arteries With One Simple Fruit
- Tooth Decay: Early Remineralisation Versus an Established Cavity
- Five Foods and Common Liver-Cleansing Claims
- Garlic on an Empty Stomach: Traditional Claims and Clinical Evidence
- Garlic Soup Made With 52 Cloves of Garlic Can Defeat Colds, Flu and Even Norovirus
- Foods Promoted as Medicines
- 19 Foods and the Limits of Liver-Detox Claims
- Turmeric and Drug Comparisons: What the Cited Studies Can Establish
- Black Seed and the Limits of Cure-All Claims
- 11 Ways to Naturally Boost Your Metabolism for Weight Loss
- 15 Herbs Discussed for Respiratory Health: Evidence and Safety Questions
- Food Matters: Questions for Reading a Nutrition Documentary

COMMENTS