Fast Radio Bursts and Alien Light Sails: The 2017 Loeb Hypothesis

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Could Fast Radio Bursts Come From Alien Technology? A 2017 Hypothesis
A radio dish under the night sky. Image: Getty

Could fast radio bursts be leaking beams from alien spacecraft? In 2017 two Harvard astrophysicists, Manasvi Lingam and Avi Loeb, published a paper arguing that this was at least physically possible. They did not claim to have found aliens. Since then, astronomers have traced at least some fast radio bursts to a natural source: magnetars, the ultra-magnetic remnants of dead stars. The alien-light-sail idea has not been ruled out for every burst, but it is no longer needed to explain the phenomenon, and most researchers consider natural explanations far more likely.

Here is what fast radio bursts are, what the 2017 hypothesis proposed, and what has been learned since.

What fast radio bursts are

A fast radio burst, or FRB, is a flash of radio waves that lasts from a fraction of a millisecond to a few seconds, yet can release as much energy as the Sun emits over days. The first one was spotted in 2007, when Duncan Lorimer and his student David Narkevic searched archived data from the Parkes radio telescope in Australia and found a burst recorded on 24 July 2001. It became known as the Lorimer burst.

For several years only a handful were known, and some astronomers wondered if they were instrumental glitches. That doubt faded as more telescopes caught them. Today FRBs are understood to be common: astronomer Victoria Kaspi has estimated that as many as 10,000 may flash across the whole sky every day. Most come from far outside our galaxy, and the way their signals are smeared out by intervening gas lets astronomers estimate how far they have travelled.

Repeaters and one-off bursts

Most bursts seem to happen only once, but some repeat. FRB 121102, first seen in 2012, was found to repeat in 2016 and was pinned to a small dwarf galaxy about three billion light-years away in 2017. Repeating bursts arrive irregularly rather than in a neat code, which is one reason the early idea that they might be deliberate messages lost appeal.

The 2017 light-sail hypothesis

Lingam and Loeb's paper, "Fast Radio Bursts from Extragalactic Light Sails", appeared in The Astrophysical Journal Letters in 2017. They asked a simple question: if an advanced civilisation used powerful radio beams to push spacecraft fitted with light sails, would the leaking beams look like FRBs from Earth?

Could Fast Radio Bursts Come From Alien Technology? A 2017 Hypothesis
Artist's impression of a light sail pushed by a radio beam from a planet. Image: M. Weiss/CfA

Their calculations suggested the numbers could fit. A light sail rides on the pressure of electromagnetic radiation, much as a sailboat rides the wind. Both energy and engineering limits pointed to a transmitter about the size of a large rocky planet, and, as press coverage explained, it would need water cooling on a vast scale to avoid melting itself. The beam's optimal frequency for pushing such a sail turned out to be close to the frequencies at which FRBs are observed. The authors also estimated a sail mass of around a million tonnes; in press interviews Lingam said such a craft would be big enough to carry living passengers between stars or even galaxies.

The hypothesis also offered an explanation for why we would see only brief flashes. The transmitter, its planet, star and galaxy all move, so a beam tracking a sail would sweep past Earth only momentarily.

How Loeb framed the idea

Loeb was careful to call the work speculative. At the time he noted that no convincing natural source had been identified with confidence, so an artificial one was worth testing rather than dismissing. His summary of the attitude became the most quoted line from the coverage: "Science isn't a matter of belief, it's a matter of evidence."

The paper itself was cautious, also using the observed rate of FRBs to set upper limits on how many could plausibly come from civilisations. Critics welcomed the open-mindedness but pointed out that a planet-sized transmitter is an extraordinary assumption, and that astrophysics had plenty of violent natural events yet to be explored. Loeb has since become well known for other provocative proposals, including the suggestion that the interstellar object 'Oumuamua might be artificial, which most astronomers also regard as unlikely.

The magnetar breakthrough of 2020

The biggest clue arrived on 28 April 2020. The CHIME radio telescope in Canada, along with other instruments, recorded an extremely bright radio burst, known as FRB 200428, from SGR 1935+2154, a magnetar inside our own Milky Way. Magnetars are neutron stars with magnetic fields billions of times stronger than anything on Earth, and this one was also flaring in X-rays at the time.

The burst, described in papers in Nature in November 2020, was roughly a thousand times more intense than any radio burst previously seen from a magnetar, and it looked like a weaker cousin of the bursts from distant galaxies. Estimates of its distance range from about 14,000 to 30,000 light-years, which is close by cosmic standards. For the first time astronomers had caught an FRB-like event from a known, natural object.

That did not solve everything. In 2022 researchers linked a repeating burst, FRB 20200120E, to an old globular star cluster in the nearby galaxy M81, an unexpected home for a young magnetar. There may be more than one kind of source, and the details of how magnetars produce such bright radio flashes are still debated. But magnetars are now the leading explanation.

So could any FRBs be alien?

Strictly speaking, science cannot rule out that some bursts have an artificial origin. In practice, the case for aliens has weakened. Bursts are extremely common, they come from many kinds of galaxies, and at least one class has a confirmed natural engine. An explanation that needs countless planet-sized transmitters scattered across the universe is much harder to justify than one that relies on objects we know exist.

The 2017 paper still has value. It showed how to test an unusual idea with physics rather than wishful thinking, and it encouraged astronomers to consider what technological signals might look like. Searches for such "technosignatures" continue alongside conventional FRB research.

What to watch next

Radio telescopes such as CHIME, Australia's ASKAP and new arrays coming online are detecting and localising bursts in growing numbers. Pinpointing exactly which galaxy, and which part of it, each burst comes from is the key to testing theories. FRBs are also proving useful as tools: because their signals are delayed by the gas they pass through, they help astronomers weigh the thin matter between galaxies, sometimes called the universe's "missing" ordinary matter.

When you see a headline asking whether a strange signal is from aliens, it is worth remembering the pattern here. A bold hypothesis was published, discussed and then tested against new data, and nature turned out to have a remarkable explanation of its own.

Sources: Lingam & Loeb (2017), Fast Radio Bursts from Extragalactic Light Sails, arXiv:1701.01109; Wikipedia: Fast radio burst; Sci.News: Fast radio burst detected from magnetar in Milky Way (November 2020). Original report: The Independent via Yahoo. Images: Getty; M. Weiss/CfA.

Related:

COMMENTS