Stephen Hawking's Three Warnings for Human Civilization

Three Things Stephen Hawking Warned Could End Human Civilization

Stephen Hawking named three dangers that, in his view, could end human civilisation: artificial intelligence that outgrows human control, our own aggression in an age of nuclear weapons, and contact with a technologically superior alien civilisation. He raised them in interviews and talks between 2010 and 2015, and he usually paired each warning with a way forward, from careful AI research to more empathy and, in the long run, settling beyond Earth.

Hawking, the Cambridge physicist best known for his work on black holes, died at home in Cambridge on 14 March 2018, aged 76. His warnings are still widely quoted, often loosely. This guide sets out what he actually said, where he said it, and what has been added by others.

Threat one: artificial intelligence

Hawking's best-known warning came in a BBC interview in December 2014, around the launch of a new Intel-designed speech system that used predictive text from the start-up SwiftKey. Ironically, that system was itself a form of AI. Asked about the technology, he said:

"I think the development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race."

His reasoning was about speed. A machine able to improve its own design could, he argued, take off and redesign itself ever faster, while humans are limited by slow biological evolution and could be left behind.

He was not against AI. In January 2015 he joined Elon Musk, Google's research director Peter Norvig, Berkeley professor Stuart Russell and more than 150 others in signing an open letter from the Future of Life Institute. It praised AI's potential to help eradicate disease and poverty and called for research to keep systems robust, beneficial and under human control. Hawking later said that creating AI could be the biggest event in human history, and he summed up the danger in one line:

"The real risk with AI isn't malice, but competence."

In other words, the worry is not evil robots from the cinema but very capable systems pursuing goals that do not match ours.

Threat two: human aggression

In February 2015 Hawking gave a visitor a tour of London's Science Museum as part of a VisitBritain "Guest of Honour" competition. When she asked which human shortcoming he would most like to change, he answered:

"The human failing I would most like to correct is aggression."

He explained that aggression may have helped our ancestors survive, when it won food, territory or a mate, but that in a world of nuclear weapons it could destroy everyone. A major nuclear war, he warned, could end civilisation and perhaps the human race. His proposed remedy was empathy, which he said brings people together. He also called human space exploration a kind of life insurance for the species.

Threat three: hostile aliens

Hawking thought it very likely that life exists elsewhere, given the size of the universe, but he argued that we should not go looking for a meeting. In his 2010 documentary series for the Discovery Channel he compared a visit by advanced aliens to Christopher Columbus landing in the Americas, an encounter that turned out badly for the people who already lived there. A civilisation able to cross between stars, he suggested, might be nomadic, looking to conquer and use whatever planets it reached.

His position was more nuanced than "aliens will attack". In July 2015 he helped launch the Breakthrough Initiatives, a well-funded search for signs of extraterrestrial life. His caution was about announcing ourselves and replying, not about listening.

The other risks Hawking worried about

The three threats above were not his whole list. At different times Hawking also warned about:

Climate change. He said runaway warming could one day make Earth more like Venus.
Nuclear war and environmental collapse together. He thought it almost inevitable that one or the other would cripple Earth within the next thousand years.
Engineered viruses and asteroid strikes, along with risks no one has thought of yet.

His long-term answer was the same each time. If humanity spreads to other worlds, a disaster on one planet need not mean extinction. That is why he supported human spaceflight so strongly.

What Hawking did not say

Many blog posts that spread these warnings in 2015 mixed his views with speculation of their own. Three points are worth separating:

Film references. Suggestions that The Terminator, The Matrix or Men in Black were secret messages are commentary by bloggers, not by Hawking.
Government plots. He never claimed that alien films are a government effort to prepare the public for real aliens.
Rising crime. The claim that violent crime statistics were climbing was wrong for the United States at the time. Violent crime there peaked in 1991 and fell broadly over the following two decades, although there were later rises from 2014 to 2016.

It is also a myth that he thought global warming was a minor issue next to AI. He spoke about climate change often and treated it as one of the most serious problems facing humanity.

How his warnings look today

When Hawking spoke about AI in 2014, the topic was still niche. Within a decade, advanced language and image systems became everyday tools, and AI safety moved from philosophy seminars to government agendas and international summits. Leading researchers now debate many of the same questions he raised: how to keep powerful systems aligned with human goals, and who gets to control them.

His other warnings still apply too. Nuclear arsenals remain large, conflicts between nuclear-armed states have not gone away, and climate change is now measured rather than predicted. Meanwhile, the search for alien signals continues, and the debate about whether we should ever reply remains open.

Hawking was a physicist, not a computer scientist, a diplomat or an astrobiologist, so his views on these subjects were informed opinion rather than expert findings. Still, his central message has aged well: the greatest dangers we face are largely of our own making, and so are the solutions. Which of these risks worries you most? Tell us in the comments.

Sources: Original article by Sophie for Learning Mind; The Globe and Mail: Even Stephen Hawking fears the rise of machines (December 2014); Wikipedia: Open letter on artificial intelligence (2015); Live Science: Human aggression could destroy us all (February 2015); Wikipedia: Stephen Hawking; Wikipedia: Crime in the United States.

Related: