
Asked in October 2015 whether machines would make human workers redundant, Stephen Hawking said the real question was not the robots but who would own them. Automation could give everyone a comfortable life, he argued, or leave most people poor, and which one we got would depend on politics, not technology.
The remark, made during an online question-and-answer session, became one of his most quoted statements outside physics. Here is what he said, the background to his other well-known warnings, and how economists see the issue.
What Hawking actually said
In October 2015 Hawking took part in a written "Ask Me Anything" (AMA) session in Reddit's r/science community. Readers submitted questions in advance and he answered a selection. One question asked about technological unemployment: whether machines would eventually take over so much work that most people would have none.
His answer began: "If machines produce everything we need, the outcome will depend on how things are distributed." He went on to describe two futures. In one, the wealth made by machines is shared, and everyone enjoys a life of leisure. In the other, he warned, "most people can end up miserably poor if the machine-owners successfully lobby against wealth redistribution." He added that, so far, events seemed to be moving towards the second outcome, with technology widening inequality.
It was a short answer, but it reframed the robot debate. Instead of asking whether automation is good or bad, Hawking asked who captures its benefits.
The other dangers he warned about
Hawking, who lived with motor neurone disease for more than five decades after being given two years to live in 1963, spent his later years speaking about long-term risks to humanity. Three of his warnings are often lumped together with the automation answer.
Aliens
Hawking thought intelligent life elsewhere was likely, but that we should be careful about announcing ourselves. In 2010 he compared a possible visit by advanced aliens to Columbus landing in the Americas, which did not turn out well for the people already living there.
Artificial intelligence
He argued that creating AI might be the biggest event in human history, and possibly the last if we did not learn to manage the risks. In January 2015 he was among the original signatories of a Future of Life Institute open letter calling for research to keep AI systems safe and beneficial. In July 2015 he joined more than 1,000 AI researchers and public figures, including Elon Musk, Steve Wozniak, Noam Chomsky and DeepMind co-founder Demis Hassabis, in a letter presented at an AI conference in Buenos Aires that warned of a military AI arms race and called for a ban on autonomous weapons.
The Higgs boson
In his preface to Starmus, a 2014 collection of essays and lectures, Hawking noted that the Higgs field might be only metastable at extremely high energies, which in principle could trigger catastrophic vacuum decay, a bubble of a different kind of space expanding at the speed of light. He wrote that "this could happen at any time and we wouldn't see it coming." Physicists stressed that this is a theoretical possibility, not a forecast. The Fermilab physicist Joseph Lykken said such a collapse, if it ever happened, was so remote that nobody needed to worry about it.
How the Reddit thread reacted
The comment section under Hawking's answer turned into a sprawling debate. Many readers agreed and pointed to reports showing wealth concentrating at the very top. Others cited science-fiction films such as Elysium and WALL-E, which imagine a rich elite living apart from everyone else, or discussed the political ideas of Noam Chomsky.
Not everyone was persuaded. One reader pushed back by citing articles in the Journal of Economic Perspectives, arguing that technology has never produced permanent mass unemployment. The thread also wandered into the value of voting, a universal basic income, decentralised "open source" economic systems, and the idea of a post-scarcity society run with the help of advanced AI.
What economists say about automation and jobs
The disagreement in that thread mirrors a real debate among economists, and both sides have evidence.
The sceptics point to history. From the Luddite weavers of early 19th-century England onwards, people have feared that machines would leave nothing for humans to do. Instead, new kinds of work kept appearing. Economists call the belief that there is a fixed amount of work to go around the "lump of labour" fallacy. John Maynard Keynes, who popularised the phrase technological unemployment in 1930, expected it to be a temporary adjustment rather than a permanent state.
Estimates of how many jobs are at risk vary enormously. A widely cited 2013 study by Carl Benedikt Frey and Michael Osborne at Oxford put 47 per cent of US jobs at high risk of automation. A 2016 OECD analysis, which looked at tasks within jobs rather than whole occupations, found an average of only 9 per cent of jobs at high risk across 21 countries.
On inequality, though, Hawking's concern has support. A 2015 study by Georg Graetz and Guy Michaels found that industrial robots raised wages for highly skilled workers while hurting low- and middle-skilled ones, and a 2018 Brookings study found that automation had held down wages by shrinking labour's share of the value produced, even where overall employment did not fall. In other words, the main risk may be less "no jobs" than "worse-paid jobs and bigger profits for owners", which is close to what Hawking described.
Universal basic income and other answers
Hawking supported redistributing machine-made wealth and also spoke in favour of a universal basic income: a regular payment to every citizen regardless of work. Supporters of the idea range from economists such as Erik Brynjolfsson and Guy Standing to tech figures such as Elon Musk. Critics question how it would be paid for and whether it would weaken the incentive to work; small pilot programmes in several countries have so far found little drop in work effort, but they are too limited to settle the question.
Other proposals include taxing capital or robots more heavily, shortening the working week, strengthening worker bargaining power, and investing in education so that people can move into roles machines handle badly, such as caring, creative and supervisory work.
Why the warning still matters
Hawking returned to the theme in a Guardian column in December 2016, writing that factory automation had already cut traditional manufacturing jobs and that AI could extend the losses deep into the middle classes. In a November 2017 interview he went further, suggesting AI might one day replace humans altogether.
He died at his home in Cambridge on 14 March 2018, aged 76. On the day of his death, his answer about machine owners was shared widely again online, and the arrival of powerful AI tools in the years since has only made it more relevant. His point was simple and hard to dismiss: what machines do to ordinary people's lives will depend on the choices societies make about who shares in what they produce.
Sources: Inverse, 14 March 2018; Live Science, 8 September 2014; Wikipedia: Stephen Hawking; Wikipedia: Open Letter on Artificial Intelligence; Wikipedia: Lethal autonomous weapon; Wikipedia: Technological unemployment. First shared via The Mind Unleashed.
Related:- Stephen Hawking and 1,000 Experts Sign Letter Warning Of Weaponized Robots
- These 3 Things Could Destroy The Human Civilization, Says Stephen Hawking
- Stephen Hawking Says We Should Really Be Scared Of Capitalism, Not Robots
- Stephen Hawking's Beautiful Advice For Those Who Suffer From Depression
- Stephen Hawking's Universe - The Story of Everything, Time Travel, Aliens
- Elon Musk Funds $1B Project To Prevent Artificial Intelligence From Destroying Mankind
- Self-Learning Robot Escapes Testing Ground and Goes Missing for 45 Minutes
- Philip K. Dick Android's People Zoo Remark Went Viral

COMMENTS