Originally published 2016-08-05.

Can period pain really be as bad as a heart attack? The comparison went viral in 2016, and it is worth knowing exactly where it came from. It was not the finding of a study. It came from John Guillebaud, a professor of reproductive health at University College London, who told the news site Quartz that some of his patients had described their cramps as "almost as bad as having a heart attack". That is a powerful description of how severe menstrual pain can be, but it is a patient's comparison, not a measurement.
What is true, and backed by research, is that period pain is extremely common, that for some people it is severe enough to stop normal life, and that women's pain is too often brushed aside. This article explains the science of cramps, the warning signs of an underlying condition, the evidence on how pain is treated in hospitals, and what actually helps.
Where the heart-attack comparison came from
Quartz published Guillebaud's remarks on 15 February 2016 in a piece asking why so little research goes into treating menstrual pain. Within days, The Telegraph, The Independent and many smaller sites ran versions of the story, and the headline gradually hardened from "patients describe" into "research confirms" and "doctors say".
The fact-checking site Snopes later traced the chain. It found that the quote was genuine but rested on patient anecdotes, and that it could not locate the research some outlets claimed existed. In other words, one doctor relayed what patients had told him, and the internet turned it into a scientific verdict.
Pain is also hard to compare between people or conditions. There is no objective "pain meter", and heart attacks themselves vary enormously: some cause crushing chest pain, while others, more often in women, show up as breathlessness, nausea, jaw or back pain, or unusual tiredness. The useful message behind the viral headline is simpler: severe period pain is real and deserves to be taken seriously.
Why periods hurt
The medical name for painful periods is dysmenorrhoea (dysmenorrhea in US spelling). Estimates vary widely because studies define it differently, but most put it among the most common gynaecological complaints, affecting a majority of teenagers and young women to some degree. For a smaller group, somewhere around 5 to 15 percent, the pain is bad enough to disrupt school, work or daily activities.
In primary dysmenorrhoea, there is no underlying disease. Before and during a period, the lining of the womb releases chemicals called prostaglandins. These make the muscle of the womb contract more often and more forcefully, which briefly squeezes its own blood supply. That temporary shortage of oxygen is thought to cause the cramping. Prostaglandins can also explain the nausea, diarrhoea, bloating and headaches that many people get at the same time. This kind of pain usually starts in the teenage years, soon after periods begin, and often eases with age.
When period pain is a sign of something else
Secondary dysmenorrhoea is pain caused by another condition. The NHS lists several possible causes:
- Endometriosis, where tissue similar to the womb lining grows in other places, such as on the ovaries or bowel.
- Adenomyosis, where that tissue grows into the muscle wall of the womb.
- Fibroids, non-cancerous growths in or around the womb.
- Pelvic inflammatory disease, an infection of the womb, fallopian tubes and ovaries that usually needs antibiotics.
- A copper coil (IUD), which can make periods more painful, especially in the first few months.
Clues that pain may have another cause include pain that starts later in life after years of easier periods, pain between periods or lasting well beyond the first days of bleeding, and pain that does not improve with ordinary painkillers or hormonal contraception. Endometriosis in particular is known for long delays before diagnosis, partly because severe period pain is so often treated as normal.
Is women's pain taken less seriously?
The frustration behind the viral story was not only about cramps. Many women report being told their pain is exaggerated, emotional or "just a period". Research suggests the problem is real.
A frequently cited example is a 2008 study in Academic Emergency Medicine. Researchers followed 981 adults who came to an urban US emergency department with acute abdominal pain. Women waited a median of 65 minutes for pain relief, compared with 49 minutes for men. Women were also less likely to receive strong opioid painkillers, even after the researchers adjusted for age, race, triage category and how severe patients rated their pain. The authors concluded that gender bias was a possible explanation.
One study in one hospital cannot prove a universal rule, but it fits a wider pattern that researchers and patient groups have described for years, from slower diagnosis of heart disease in women to long waits for endometriosis care. It is a good reason to describe pain clearly and to ask for a second opinion when something feels wrong.
What helps with period pain
For ordinary cramps, the NHS suggests a few simple measures that many people find useful:
- Heat. A hot water bottle wrapped in a towel, a heat pad or a warm bath. Studies suggest heat can work about as well as some painkillers, with no side effects.
- Gentle movement. Walking, swimming, cycling or yoga. Regular exercise across the month may also reduce cramping over time.
- Massage of the lower tummy and back.
- Over-the-counter painkillers. Anti-inflammatory medicines such as ibuprofen work on prostaglandins and tend to be more effective for cramps than paracetamol, but they are not suitable for everyone, so check with a pharmacist or doctor.
- Hormonal contraception, which a doctor may suggest because it can make periods lighter and less painful.
- Cutting down on alcohol and not smoking may also help.
When to see a doctor
Talk to a doctor if period pain stops you doing everyday things, if periods become more painful, heavier or irregular, or if you have pain during sex, bleeding between periods, or changes in bowel or bladder habits. Pelvic pain that is suddenly severe, or much worse than usual and not eased by painkillers, needs urgent medical advice. This article cannot diagnose anyone; a doctor can examine you, arrange tests and discuss treatment options.
How partners and families can help
There is an old piece of household wisdom for husbands that still stands: skip the eye-rolling, bring home the painkillers and the heat pad, and take the children for the evening. It sounds like a joke, but the advice holds up.
Believing someone when they say they are in pain costs nothing. Practical help, such as making a hot drink, handling dinner or school runs, or simply not treating a bad day as drama, makes a real difference. Parents of teenagers can help by treating severe period pain as a health issue worth discussing with a doctor rather than something to tough out. And workplaces and schools that allow flexibility on the worst days help people manage without losing pay or learning.
Period pain is not literally a heart attack. It does not need to be, to deserve attention, good treatment and a little kindness.
Sources: Snopes: Are menstrual cramps as painful as a heart attack?; Chen et al., Academic Emergency Medicine, 2008: Gender disparity in analgesic treatment of ED patients with acute abdominal pain; NHS: Period pain; Dysmenorrhea (Wikipedia). Originally adapted from I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS