Is Alcohol the Real Gateway Drug? What a 2012 Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A Study Pointed to Alcohol, Not Marijuana, as the ‘Gateway Drug’

For decades, cannabis has been labelled the "gateway drug," the substance that supposedly opens the door to cocaine, heroin and other harder drugs. A 2012 study from the University of Florida challenged that idea. Looking at more than 14,000 American high-school seniors, it found that alcohol, not marijuana, was usually the first substance teenagers tried, and that young people who drank were far more likely to go on to use other drugs. The short answer to the question many people ask is this: if any substance deserves the gateway label based on the order in which young people try drugs, the evidence points first to alcohol. The fuller answer is more interesting, because the gateway idea itself is shakier than either side often admits.

What the University of Florida study found

The research was led by Adam E. Barry, then an assistant professor of health education at the University of Florida, and published in the August 2012 issue of the Journal of School Health. It used data from Monitoring the Future, a long-running national survey of American students run by the University of Michigan's Institute for Social Research. The sample covered 14,577 high-school seniors at 120 public and private schools.

The key findings were:

  • Alcohol came first. Among students who had used substances, alcohol was most often the first one they tried, ahead of tobacco and marijuana.
  • Alcohol was the most common. About 72.2% of seniors reported drinking at some point in their lives, compared with 45% for tobacco and 43.3% for marijuana.
  • Drinkers used more of everything. Compared with students who had never drunk alcohol, those who had were many times more likely to have used cigarettes, marijuana and other illegal drugs, with some estimates up to 16 times higher.
  • A typical sequence. Use tended to move from the most socially accepted substances, alcohol and cigarettes, to marijuana and then to other illegal drugs.

To map that sequence the researchers used a statistical tool called a Guttman scale, which tests whether behaviours follow a consistent order, so that people who report a "later" behaviour have usually also reported the "earlier" ones. Summing up, Barry said the results "add further credence to the literature identifying alcohol as the gateway drug to other substance use."

Where the gateway theory came from

The gateway idea took shape in the 1970s and 1980s, when researchers such as Denise Kandel at Columbia University noticed that drug use among young people tended to follow stages: legal substances first, then marijuana, then other illegal drugs. Policy campaigns quickly simplified this into the claim that cannabis leads to heroin, a message that fitted older anti-marijuana messaging dating back to films like Reefer Madness in the 1930s.

But a pattern of order is not the same as cause. Almost everyone who uses heroin has also drunk milk and coffee earlier in life; that does not mean milk leads to heroin. The real question is whether using one substance changes the brain or a person's circumstances in a way that makes the next step more likely.

Correlation, causation and the "common liability" explanation

The US National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) summarises the evidence carefully. It acknowledges that marijuana use often comes before the use of other substances and is linked to a higher risk of later problems, including alcohol use disorders. It also points out that most people who use marijuana never go on to use harder drugs.

NIDA describes two kinds of explanation:

  • Biological priming. In animal studies, early exposure to THC, the main psychoactive compound in cannabis, can make the brain respond more strongly to other drugs later, an effect called cross-sensitisation. Crucially, NIDA notes that this is not unique to cannabis: alcohol and nicotine prime the brain in similar ways, and they too are usually used before harder drugs.
  • Common liability. People who are more vulnerable to drug use, because of genetics, stress, mental health or their social environment, tend to start with whatever is easiest to get, which is usually alcohol, tobacco or cannabis. Their later contact with people who use drugs then raises the chance of trying others.

Seen this way, the University of Florida finding fits well. Alcohol is legal for adults, widely available at home and heavily advertised, so it is the most likely first substance for teenagers. That makes early drinking an important warning sign, whether or not alcohol itself directly causes later drug use.

Other research that is often cited

Two other studies regularly appear in discussions of this topic, and both are worth reading with care.

"Cannabis is 114 times less deadly than alcohol"

This figure comes from a January 2015 paper in Scientific Reports by Dirk Lachenmeier and Jürgen Rehm. They used a method called the margin of exposure, which compares typical doses with doses that are lethal in animal studies. By that measure, alcohol came out as the riskiest substance studied, while cannabis had by far the widest safety margin. The authors stressed important limits: the method looks only at the risk of death from a dose, not at addiction, mental health effects, long-term damage, driving accidents or harm from mixing substances. It shows that a fatal cannabis overdose is extremely unlikely; it does not show that cannabis is harmless.

Cannabidiol and alcohol-related brain damage

A 2013 laboratory study from researchers at the University of Kentucky and the University of Maryland found that cannabidiol (CBD), a non-intoxicating compound in cannabis, reduced alcohol-induced damage to brain cells in rats when applied through the skin. It was an early animal experiment, not evidence of a treatment for people, and it should not be read as a reason to use cannabis to offset drinking.

Some coverage of the study described cannabis as a "therapeutic healing herb." Some cannabis-based medicines are approved for specific conditions, such as certain severe forms of childhood epilepsy, but cannabis as a whole is not a cure-all, and decisions about medical use should be made with a doctor.

Why it matters for prevention

The study's authors drew a practical conclusion: if alcohol is usually the first substance teenagers try, then school and public health programmes should give it primary attention. Delaying the age at which young people start drinking could also reduce the use of other substances. Barry also told the University of Florida that parents should adopt a strict, zero-tolerance approach to underage drinking at home.

For parents and teachers, a few points follow from the wider evidence:

  • Do not treat alcohol as the "safe" option. Early drinking is common, legal for adults and socially accepted, which is exactly why it deserves attention.
  • Look at the whole picture. Stress, mental health problems, family situations and peer groups shape risk more than any single substance.
  • Talk early and honestly. Young people respond better to accurate information than to scare stories, which tend to lose credibility when they turn out to be exaggerated.

If you or someone close to you is struggling with alcohol or drug use, talk to a doctor or a local support service.

Sources: University of Florida News: UF study shows long-term drug abuse starts with alcohol (July 10, 2012); Journal of School Health (2012): Barry et al.; NIDA: Is marijuana a gateway drug?; Lachenmeier & Rehm, Scientific Reports (2015): comparative risk assessment of alcohol, tobacco, cannabis and other drugs; Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior (2013): transdermal cannabidiol and alcohol-induced neurodegeneration; original report via AnonHQ.

Related:

COMMENTS