Colonia Dignidad: Inside Paul Schäfer's Secret Colony in Chile

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Colonia Dignidad: Paul Schäfer’s Secret Colony in Chile

Colonia Dignidad was a closed German settlement in the foothills of the Andes in central Chile, founded in 1961 by the lay preacher Paul Schäfer. Behind its image as a hard-working farming community, Schäfer sexually abused children for decades, kept residents under total control and, after the 1973 military coup, let General Pinochet's secret police use the grounds to imprison and torture opponents. Schäfer was finally convicted in 2006 and died in a Chilean prison in 2010. The place still exists under the name Villa Baviera.

The colony is often described online as a “Nazi cult.” That label needs care. Its founders were members of a German evangelical group, not a band of fleeing Nazi officials, and some of the most famous Nazi rumours about it were never proven. What was proven is grim enough. Here is the history, separated from the myths.

Who Paul Schäfer was

Paul Schaefer
Afp/AFP/Getty Images

Paul Schäfer was born on 4 December 1921 in the Bonn area. As a child he lost his right eye in an accident with a fork and wore a glass eye for the rest of his life, though he later liked to claim it was a war wound. During the Second World War he was drafted as a medic; because of his poor sight he served in the rear, including at a field hospital in occupied France, rather than at the front.

After the war he worked with young people in church and youth settings in West Germany. Again and again he was dismissed, accused of cult-like behaviour and of abusing boys, but for years nobody went to the police. In 1954 he founded his own evangelical free church, the Private Social Mission, with branches in Siegburg and elsewhere, and attracted a devoted following of families.

In 1959 prosecutors in Siegburg charged him with sexually abusing two boys and issued an arrest warrant. Schäfer fled. After travelling through several countries, he accepted an invitation from a Chilean diplomat who knew nothing of the charges and emigrated to Chile in January 1961. Around 70 followers went with him, along with children, some taken without their parents' consent.

Building a state within a state

After The War
Keystone-france/Gamma-Keystone/Getty Images

The group bought a ranch in the Parral area of Chile's Maule Region, about 350 km south of Santiago, on the north bank of the Perquilauquén River. It began with roughly 3,000 hectares and grew to about 13,700 hectares, around 53 square miles. (Older articles claimed “220 miles of land,” which mixes up units and is not accurate.)

The settlement was registered as a charitable and educational society, the Sociedad Benefactora y Educacional Dignidad. Its members cleared land, farmed and built workshops, a school, a hospital, a restaurant, an airstrip and power plants. Fences, watchtowers and guard dogs surrounded the property, and residents were not allowed to leave.

Colonia Dignidad
Afp/AFP/Getty Images Claudio Reyes/AFP/Getty Images

At its peak the colony had about 300 to 350 residents, mostly Germans along with some Chileans, including around 100 children. To the outside world it looked orderly and generous. The hospital offered free treatment to local people and the colony's businesses provided jobs, which won it goodwill and powerful friends in Chile.

Life inside: control and abuse

Employment Opportunities
Claudio Reyes/AFP/Getty Images

Inside, Schäfer controlled almost every detail of daily life. Men and women lived and worked separately, families were split up and children were raised in group houses away from their parents. Marriage and contact between the sexes needed his permission. Residents worked long hours without pay, confessed their “sins” to him and were punished with beatings, drugs and electric shocks.

Children Begin To Disappear
Bouroncle/AFP/Getty Images

Schäfer chose boys to live near him and abused them systematically for decades. Children from poor families in the surrounding area were also brought in through the colony's school and boarding programmes, and some were abused too. The first known escapee to describe the abuse was Wolfgang Müller in 1966; another former member, Heinz Kuhn, backed up his account in 1967. Both were largely ignored, and the colony's political connections protected it.

Visitors' impressions varied widely. Some outsiders, including a Chilean psychiatrist quoted by The New York Times, defended the community as old-fashioned and pious and dismissed the accusations as lies. Former residents told a very different story once they were finally free to speak.

A torture centre for Pinochet's secret police

A Dark Interior
Afp/AFP/Getty Images

Colonia Dignidad was founded twelve years before Augusto Pinochet seized power in September 1973, but after the coup the two became close allies. The colony let DINA, the regime's secret police, use parts of the property to detain and interrogate political prisoners. DINA's chief, General Manuel Contreras, was a frequent visitor.

A United Nations working group raised the colony's role as early as 1976, and Amnesty International reported on it in 1977. In 1991 Chile's National Commission for Truth and Reconciliation, known as the Rettig Commission, confirmed that DINA had held prisoners there and that some colony members took part in torture. Survivors described electric shocks, attacks by dogs and interrogations in underground rooms, with loud music playing to cover the noise.

Investigators believe that dozens of prisoners, perhaps as many as 100, were killed at the colony and that their remains were later dug up and destroyed to hide the evidence. In 2005 police found the largest private weapons cache ever discovered in Chile on the property, including machine guns, rocket launchers and grenades.

Nazi rumours: what is proven and what is not

Nazi Hideout
Keystone-france/Gamma-Keystone/Getty Images

Because the colony was German, secretive and allied with a right-wing dictatorship, it attracted rumours that it sheltered wanted Nazi war criminals. The most famous claim is that Josef Mengele, the Auschwitz doctor, stayed there. The CIA and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal both suggested this, but no proof was ever found; in 2001 the German government said there was no evidence either way. Mengele is known to have lived in Paraguay and Brazil, where he died in 1979.

Walter Rauff, the SS officer involved in developing the mobile gas vans, did live openly in Chile after the war and died there in 1984. Some accounts link him to the colony, but his involvement has not been established in court. It is therefore more accurate to call Colonia Dignidad a sect with authoritarian, German nationalist leadership and a close alliance with the Pinochet regime than a “Nazi colony” in the literal sense.

Justice at last: flight, arrest and verdicts

Support From The Pinochet Regime
Afp/AFP/Getty Images

Chile returned to democracy in 1990. The colony lost its legal status as a charity in 1991, but it took several more years and the testimony of local families before prosecutors moved against Schäfer himself. A warrant for child sexual abuse was issued in 1996, and in 1997 he vanished.

Schaefer's Arrest
Str/AFP/Getty Images

He was found in March 2005 in Tortuguitas, near Buenos Aires in Argentina, and handed over to Chile. In May 2006 a Chilean court sentenced him to 20 years in prison on 25 counts of sexually abusing minors between 1993 and 1997 and ordered him to pay damages to the victims. Further convictions followed for the murder of a political prisoner, Miguel Ángel Becerra Hidalgo, for torturing former residents and for illegal possession of weapons. Schäfer died of heart failure in a Santiago prison hospital on 24 April 2010, aged 88.

Other cases remain painful. American mathematician Boris Weisfeiler disappeared while hiking near the colony in January 1985 and is presumed to have been taken there; in 2016 a judge closed the case on statute-of-limitation grounds. The colony's doctor Hartmut Hopp, sentenced in Chile for complicity in abuse, fled to Germany in 2011, where prosecutors later dropped their investigation.

Villa Baviera today and Germany's responsibility

The Colonia Remains
Claudio Reyes/AFP/Getty Images

The settlement was renamed Villa Baviera (Bavarian Village) in 1991. Some former members still live there, now free to come and go, and the site has operated as a tourist resort with a hotel and restaurant, which survivors and human rights groups have criticised.

Germany has had to face its own failures. For years West German diplomats ignored escapees who asked for help. In 2016 Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier acknowledged that the embassy had looked away, and in 2017 the Bundestag formally recognised Germany's responsibility and called for a memorial, an investigation and support for victims. In 2025 Chile announced plans to expropriate part of the land for a memorial site, a step that remained politically contested in 2026.

The story has reached a wide audience through the 2015 feature film Colonia, the Chilean-German series Dignity and the documentary series released on Netflix as A Sinister Sect: Colonia Dignidad. For survivors, the central questions are still the same: full disclosure of what happened, the location of the disappeared and recognition for those who grew up inside.

Sources: Wikipedia: Colonia Dignidad · Wikipedia: Paul Schäfer · Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung: Colonia Dignidad · Photos: AFP, Keystone-France and Getty Images · First reported via AllDay

COMMENTS