Being "an option" means you are someone's maybe. They enjoy your attention, answer when it suits them and keep you close enough to call, yet they never arrange their life around you. When the person you have made your priority treats you as a fallback, the hurt is real, and it usually arrives in layers: pain, then embarrassment, then doubt about your own worth, then grief for a future that was never going to happen.
The short answer to "what do I do about it?" is this: stop auditioning. You cannot earn priority from someone who has already decided you are optional. What you can do is recognise the pattern, let yourself feel what it costs, and then put your energy back where it is returned.
The ideas below began with a raw, first-person essay by the writer Paul Hudson, who described spending four years trying to become the right person for someone who kept him in reserve. His experience is common, and psychology has a fair amount to say about why it stings so badly and how people recover.
What it means to be an option instead of a priority
A priority is someone you plan for. You keep promises to them, you make room for them when it is inconvenient, and you tell them where they stand. An option is someone you keep available without committing to anything.
The difference rarely shows in one big moment. It shows in patterns:
- They reach out when they are bored, lonely or between relationships, and go quiet when life is busy.
- Plans are vague, last-minute or easily cancelled, while your own plans bend around theirs.
- You know far more about their feelings than they know about yours.
- Conversations about "what this is" are postponed, joked away or answered with "let's not label it".
- You feel calm only when you hear from them, and anxious the rest of the time.
Hudson put his finger on a particularly painful twist: realising you are not just an option but option B, the person kept in case the first choice falls through. That discovery reframes every past kindness, and it is why the feeling can be so disorienting.
Why it hurts so much
People often describe this kind of rejection as physical, and they are not exaggerating. In a well-known 2003 brain-imaging study, Naomi Eisenberger, Matthew Lieberman and Kipling Williams found that being left out of a simple online ball-tossing game activated the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, a region also involved in the distress of physical pain. Later work by Ethan Kross and colleagues reported overlapping activity when people looked at reminders of someone who had rejected them.
Researchers such as Geoff MacDonald and Mark Leary have suggested a reason: for a social species, being pushed out of the group was once dangerous, so the brain may borrow its existing alarm system for pain to warn us when belonging is threatened.
Love also raises the stakes. When you care deeply about someone, you let them see sides of you that most people never meet. Offering that and getting only partial interest back can feel like being turned down at the most exposed point of your life.
The embarrassment and the self-doubt
Alongside the hurt there is often a hot, private shame. You took a risk, said what you felt or acted as though there was something between you, and now it looks as if you misread the whole thing. Even if nobody is laughing, it can feel as though everyone is. Worse, the person you most wanted to impress has seen you at your most uncertain.
Then comes the question that does the most damage: "If I were good enough, wouldn't they choose me?" Mark Leary's sociometer theory offers a useful way to think about this. It proposes that self-esteem works partly as a gauge of how accepted we feel, so rejection pushes the needle down almost automatically. That drop is a signal, not a verdict.
It helps to separate two things. Feedback about your behaviour can be worth hearing. Someone's lack of commitment is something else: it tells you about their needs, their timing and their willingness, and very little about your value. Getting to that conclusion takes time, and the weeks in between are rarely pleasant, but most people do get there.
Grieving the future you imagined
One reason this experience lingers is that you are not only losing a person. You are losing a plan. Over months or years you may have built a picture of where the two of you were heading, and made choices to fit it: a job you took or turned down, a city you stayed in, other people you did not date.
When that picture disappears, the ground can feel unsteady, and starting again in a direction you have not tested is frightening. Treat it as grief, because that is what it is. Grief is not linear, and it does not need to be rushed.
There is some comfort in the research here. In Roy Baumeister and colleagues' studies of unrequited love in the early 1990s, more than nine in ten participants reported at least one powerful or moderate experience of it within five years. Interestingly, the people who had loved without being loved back often looked back on the episode more warmly than those who had done the rejecting, and many said it had taught them to be more careful about one-sided devotion.
When the way you see the world shifts
Love tends to tint everything. While you are acting for someone, ordinary tasks feel meaningful because they are part of a shared story. When that story collapses, the rest of your days can briefly lose their colour as well.
Hudson made an interesting point about this: having been hurt before, he went in with his eyes open, aware of the odds, and that awareness kept his wider world from falling apart. People who are completely blindsided tend to be hit harder. You do not need to become cynical to benefit from that lesson. Hoping for the best while noticing the evidence in front of you is simply a healthier way to love.
It is also worth knowing that the obsessive replaying is normal. In one 2010 brain-imaging study led by Helen Fisher, people who had recently been rejected said they spent more than 85 per cent of their waking hours thinking about the person who left. The intensity fades, but it fades faster when you stop feeding it.
Anger, and what to do with it
You are allowed to be angry. Being kept on standby is unfair, and pretending to be serene about it usually just pushes the feeling underground. Anger can even be useful: it is energy, and it tends to show up exactly when you need a push to change something.
The trick is to aim it well. Turned inward, it becomes self-blame. Turned on the other person, it keeps you emotionally tied to them through arguments, long messages and checking their social media. Neither helps you heal.
A better outlet is your own life. Put the energy into training for something, finishing a project, rebuilding friendships you neglected or learning a skill you postponed. Hudson's own advice was to build a life the other person would wish they were part of. Whether or not they ever notice, you end up with that life.
How to regroup and move forward
After the first wave of hurt, the temptation is to bury it under distractions. A few loud days are fine. But constant busyness only delays the real work, which is slowing down long enough to understand what happened. Some practical steps:
- Name the pattern honestly. Write down what actually happened, not what you hoped was happening. Seeing the facts on paper makes it harder to talk yourself back into the same situation.
- Reduce contact. Helen Fisher and colleagues suggest removing reminders such as photos and old messages and limiting contact with the person, at least for a while. Every "just checking in" restarts the cycle.
- Lean on people who show up. Friends and family who return your calls are a quiet reminder of what mutual care looks like.
- Do things that make you bigger. New places, new skills and new routines help rebuild a sense of self that is not organised around one person.
- Decide your standard. Make a simple rule for the future: you do not stay where your feelings are treated as optional. Clear, consistent effort is the minimum, not a bonus.
If the low mood will not lift, if sleep and appetite are badly affected, or if you are struggling to function, talk to a doctor or a qualified counsellor. Heartbreak is not an illness, but it can tip into something that deserves proper support.
Being someone's maybe says little about how lovable you are. The people who end up in steady, warm relationships are rarely the ones who never got hurt. More often they are the ones who learned to recognise half-hearted interest early and walked toward something better.
Sources: Based on a first-person essay by Paul Hudson for Elite Daily (shared via Idealist4ever); research summaries from Wikipedia: Social rejection and Unrequited love.
COMMENTS