
Is true love a feeling or a choice? Writer Seth Adam Smith argues that it is both, but that the choice is what lasts. In a 2014 essay on his blog, later shared widely as “Forget About Feelings, Real Love Is a Deliberate Choice,” he explains why he plans to keep loving his wife, Kim, through whatever life throws at them. His answer: attraction may arrive by chance, but staying in love is something two people decide, again and again.
Here is what his essay says, the family story at its heart, what relationship research adds, and where the idea needs a sensible limit.
The planner and the spontaneous groom
Smith and Kim had known each other since high school but only started dating years later. Within a few weeks they were sure they wanted to marry. Smith, by his own description the impulsive one, floated the idea of a quick Las Vegas wedding. Kim wanted to plan properly.
When he complained that they were opposites, one a planner and one spontaneous, Kim insisted, completely seriously, that she could be spontaneous too, as long as he warned her in advance so she could put it in her planner. Smith tells the story as a joke at both their expense, but it became the seed of his argument. Planning to love someone, he realised, is not a contradiction of romance. It is one of the most meaningful parts of it.
He leans on a saying he had heard, that real love is “an unconditional commitment to an imperfect person.” Once the excitement of the wedding fades, he writes, each partner discovers that the other has insecurities, bad habits and struggles as real as their own. That is the moment when love has to become a decision.
What his grandparents showed him
The most moving part of the essay is about Smith’s grandparents. In her fifties, his grandmother was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, a disease in which the immune system damages the protective coating of nerves, disrupting signals between the brain and the body. Within a few years she could no longer walk.
His grandfather, then the local police chief, retired early to look after her. He helped her move around the house, took her to medical appointments, managed her medication and helped with bathing and other intimate daily care. Smith recalls his grandfather admitting that he had never imagined marriage would involve such tasks, before adding: “But I do it and I don’t mind it – because I love her.”
For Smith, this is what love looks like with its sleeves rolled up: unglamorous, tiring and far deeper than a wedding-day feeling. Caring, forgiving, supporting each other’s goals and getting through grief together are, in his view, the real substance of a long marriage.
Feelings versus decisions: what psychologists say
Smith is writing from experience, not research, but his central idea lines up with well-known work in psychology.
- Sternberg’s triangle. In his 1986 triangular theory of love, psychologist Robert Sternberg described three components: intimacy (closeness), passion (attraction and desire) and commitment. He split commitment into a short-term decision that you love someone and a long-term decision to maintain that love. Love built on all three he called “consummate”; love based on intimacy and commitment after passion has cooled he called “companionate,” and it is common in long marriages.
- Passion changes over time. Researchers on romantic relationships widely observe that the intense, all-consuming phase of new love usually softens within a few years. That is normal, not a sign that something is wrong, and couples who expect it are less likely to panic when it happens.
- Daily choices add up. Studies of couples, including John Gottman’s long-running research, emphasise small, repeated behaviours: turning towards a partner’s bids for attention, repairing after arguments and expressing appreciation. Those are exactly the deliberate acts Smith describes.
Smith also quotes a popular line, often shared online without a clear author, that begins: “No one falls in love by choice, it is by chance.” Its point is that falling in love may happen to you, but staying in love takes work, and falling out of love is often the result of choices made along the way.
Where the idea has limits
“Love is a choice” is powerful, but it can be misread. Choosing commitment does not mean accepting abuse, control or repeated betrayal. Smith’s essay is about two people who both keep choosing each other; when only one person is making that choice, willpower alone cannot hold a relationship together.
It is also worth separating the parts of the story that are personal from the parts that apply to everyone. Not every couple will face a long illness, and not every relationship that ends is a failure of effort. If a relationship leaves you afraid, isolated or constantly diminished, the loving choice may be to seek help, talk to someone you trust or leave safely. Support services and counsellors exist for exactly these situations.
Putting the choice into practice
If the idea resonates, a few habits turn it from a slogan into something real:
- Decide on purpose. In hard moments, ask “what would choosing love look like right now?” Sometimes it is an apology; sometimes it is a boundary.
- Notice everyday care. Driving to an appointment, cooking when the other is exhausted or listening without fixing are acts of commitment, even if they never feel romantic.
- Talk about expectations. Like Smith and Kim, many couples pair a planner with someone more spontaneous. Discussing how each of you shows love avoids a lot of misunderstanding.
- Get help early. Couples counselling works best before resentment hardens, not as a last resort.
Smith closes his essay by promising to keep loving his wife whatever storms come, and by encouraging readers to expect love to be hard work. His comfort is that it is also the most rewarding work most people will ever do.
Sources: Seth Adam Smith, “Forget About Feelings, Real Love Is a Deliberate Choice” (2014); Triangular theory of love (Wikipedia). Originally shared via Idealist4ever.
For another personal perspective in letter form, read John Steinbeck On Falling In Love: A 1958 Letter.
More from the archive:
- What Happens in Your Mind When You Meet Your Crush: An Animated Short
- IN-Q’s The Only Reason We’re Alive: A Poem About Love
- Ten Romantic Sketches by Zac Retz
- 8 crazy symptoms of being in love
- True Love VS. Toxic Love: 14 Core Differences
- Why Modern Relationships Are Falling Apart So Easily Today
- 10 Signs That Your Relationship Will Last
- 18 Signs That You're In A Happy Relationship
- 20 Signs That You Have Found The Love Of Your Life
- Twenty Reflections on Building Meaningful Relationships
- What Happens When People Realize How Their Loved Ones Rate Them
- Korean Artist Puuung Captures What Real Love Looks Like
- Why Readers, Scientifically, Are The Best People To Fall In Love With
- 10 Signs Of True Love
- The Pain Of Being In Love With Someone You Can Never Be With
- Social Science Says Lasting Relationships Come Down To 2 Basic Traits
- Signs That Your Relationship Can Last

COMMENTS