
American author John Steinbeck, winner of the 1940 Pulitzer Prize for his novel “The Grapes of Wrath,” is seen in this undated photograph. (AP Photo)
In November 1958, John Steinbeck answered a letter from his 14-year-old son Thom, who had written home from boarding school to say he had fallen in love with a girl named Susan. Steinbeck’s reply is short, warm and practical. He tells Thom that being in love is one of the best things that can happen to anyone, explains that there are two very different kinds of love, and offers simple advice: be glad of it, try to deserve it, say how you feel with kindness, accept that it may not be returned, and do not rush. He ends with the line that made the letter famous: “Nothing good gets away.”
The letter appears in Steinbeck: A Life in Letters, the 1975 collection that tells the novelist’s story through his own correspondence with family, friends, editors and public figures. Here is what he said, why it still speaks to readers, and what it can teach anyone advising a young person in love.
Who wrote it, and to whom
By 1958 John Steinbeck (1902–1968) was one of America’s best-known writers. The Grapes of Wrath had won the Pulitzer Prize in 1940, and Of Mice and Men, Cannery Row and East of Eden were widely read. That same year, Monterey renamed its Ocean View Avenue “Cannery Row” in honour of his novel. The Nobel Prize in Literature would follow in 1962.
His private life was less tidy. Thom, born in New York in August 1944, was the elder of two sons from Steinbeck’s second marriage, to the singer and composer Gwyn Conger. After the couple divorced, the boys spent long stretches at East Coast boarding schools. In 1950 Steinbeck married Elaine Anderson Scott, the stepmother mentioned in the letter, and the marriage lasted until his death. Thom himself later became a journalist, photographer, screenwriter and novelist, and died in 2016.
So the letter is not a public essay. It is a father, often at a distance from his son, answering an urgent personal question as honestly as he can. That is a large part of its charm.
What Steinbeck told his son
The letter is dated 10 November 1958 and written from New York. Steinbeck notes that the family had received Thom’s news that morning, and that Elaine would write her own reply. Then he works through his thoughts in a loose, numbered way.
Love is a good thing; do not let anyone shrink it
His first point is simple encouragement. If Thom really is in love, that is close to the best thing that can happen to a person, and he should not let anyone treat it as trivial or silly. For a teenager who might expect to be teased, that opening matters.
There are two kinds of love
Next comes the heart of the letter. Steinbeck describes a selfish, grasping kind of love that feeds a person’s sense of importance and ends up making them weak and small. Against it he sets a generous love that brings out kindness, consideration and respect. By respect he means more than good manners: he means seeing the other person as unique and valuable. The first kind diminishes you, he says; the second can release strength, courage and even wisdom you did not know you had.
Trust what you feel
Thom had evidently insisted that this was not “puppy love”. Steinbeck takes him at his word: “If you feel so deeply — of course it isn’t puppy love.” He adds that Thom knows his own feelings better than anyone, and that the real question is what to do about them.
How to act on it
His practical advice is to be thankful for the feeling and to try to live up to the person you love. There is no harm in telling someone you love them, he writes, but some people are shy, and the way you say it should take that into account. He accepts that feelings are sometimes not returned, and insists this does not make them less real or less good. He also admits, with a light touch, that he knows the feeling himself and is glad Thom has it.
Do not hurry
After a friendly note that Susan would be welcome to visit, and that Elaine would make the arrangements because she understands love too, he closes with reassurance about the fear of losing her. If it is right, it will happen; the main thing is not to rush. The letter is signed simply “Fa”.
Why the letter still resonates
Steinbeck’s note became widely shared online in early 2012, when publications including The Atlantic and The Huffington Post republished it. Readers responded to several things at once.
It takes a teenager seriously. Adults often wave away young love as a phase. Steinbeck does the opposite: he treats Thom’s feelings as valid and his question as a sensible one.
It separates feeling from behaviour. He does not tell Thom what to feel. He talks about what to do, which is the part a parent can actually help with.
Its definition of love is moral, not romantic. The test he offers is whether love makes you kinder and braver or more possessive and self-important. That test works for friendships, marriages and families as well as first crushes.
It makes room for rejection. Many people need to hear that unreturned love is not wasted or shameful. Steinbeck says so plainly, without pretending it will not hurt.
It ends with patience. The famous closing line is not a promise that every relationship will work out. Read in context, it is a reminder that what is right for you tends not to depend on rushing, pressuring or clinging.
Lessons for anyone advising a young person in love
Parents, teachers and older siblings can borrow a lot from this letter.
- Start with gladness. Steinbeck tells his son to rejoice in the feeling and be grateful for it, which sets a positive tone before any caution.
- Ask what help is wanted. He notices that his son is not asking what he feels but what to do, and answers that question.
- Give a test, not a rulebook. Ask whether the relationship makes them more generous and confident, or more anxious and controlling.
- Normalise not being loved back. Say early that rejection is survivable and does not cheapen the feeling.
- Share the job. Steinbeck openly hands some questions to Elaine. Young people benefit from more than one trusted adult.
- Encourage patience without dismissing urgency. Feelings at fourteen are intense; slowing down is easier to accept when it comes with respect.
Reading more of Steinbeck’s letters
Steinbeck: A Life in Letters was edited by Elaine Steinbeck and Robert Wallsten and published by Viking in 1975, seven years after the author’s death. Read in order, the letters form a kind of autobiography: struggling early years in California, the success and controversy of The Grapes of Wrath, war reporting, family upheavals and later life in New York. Readers who enjoy this letter will find the same mix of plain speech, humour and moral seriousness throughout. Other good companions are Journal of a Novel, his letters to his editor written while drafting East of Eden, and Travels with Charley, his account of a road trip across America with his poodle.
Few famous writers left such clear advice on love, and fewer still wrote it for an audience of one. That may be exactly why it has lasted.
Sources: Wikipedia: John Steinbeck; Wikipedia: Thomas Steinbeck; The Atlantic (2012); HuffPost UK (2012); Featured image (AP Photo, resized).
Related:
- As I Began to Love Myself: A Poem With Uncertain Attribution
- An Animated Comedy About Meeting Your Crush
- IN-Q's Spoken-Word Reflection on Love
- Ten Romantic Sketches by Zac Retz
- 8 crazy symptoms of being in love
- True Love VS. Toxic Love: 14 Core Differences
- Why Modern Relationships Are Falling Apart So Easily Today
- 10 Signs That Your Relationship Will Last
- 18 Signs That You're In A Happy Relationship
- 20 Signs That You Have Found The Love Of Your Life
- Twenty Reflections on Building Meaningful Relationships
- How Loved Ones Describe Success in a Campaign Video
- Puuung's Illustrations of Love in Everyday Moments
- Why Readers, Scientifically, Are The Best People To Fall In Love With
- 10 Signs Of True Love
- The Pain Of Being In Love With Someone You Can Never Be With
- Social Science Says Lasting Relationships Come Down To 2 Basic Traits
- Signs That Your Relationship Can Last

COMMENTS