Apple Cider Vinegar for Eczema: What the Research Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-03-28.

Apple Cider Vinegar for Eczema? What a Study Found

Apple cider vinegar is one of the most shared home remedies for eczema, but the best test so far does not support it. In a 2019 study from the University of Virginia, people with atopic dermatitis soaked a forearm in dilute vinegar every day for two weeks. Their skin barrier did not get better than with plain tap water, and most participants reported stinging or discomfort.

If you came here hoping for a cheap, natural fix, that is disappointing news. It is still useful, though, because it points you toward what does work and away from something that can make sore skin sorer. Below we look at what eczema actually is, where the vinegar idea came from, what the research found, and which approaches dermatologists rely on.

What eczema is, and why it keeps coming back

"Eczema" is an umbrella word for several conditions that leave skin red, dry, itchy and inflamed. The most common form is atopic dermatitis. It is very widespread: estimates suggest that around one person in five has it at some point, with 15 to 30 percent of children and 2 to 10 percent of adults affected in wealthier countries.

Where the rash appears tends to change with age. Babies often get it on the face and cheeks and across the limbs. Older children usually see it in the creases of the elbows and knees and around the neck. In adults, the hands and feet are common trouble spots.

The root problem is a skin barrier that does not hold water in or keep irritants out as well as it should. Genes play a large part. Roughly 30 percent of people with atopic dermatitis carry changes in the filaggrin gene, which helps build the outer layer of skin. The immune system is also more reactive, and skin bacteria such as Staphylococcus aureus settle more easily on damaged patches. Triggers then push the skin into a flare: dry winter air, wool and some synthetic fabrics, harsh soaps, frequent hand-washing, dust mites, smoke and stress.

Because the tendency is built in, eczema is usually managed rather than cured. Many children grow out of it, but for others it comes and goes for years. That long, frustrating pattern is exactly why home remedies spread so quickly.

Where the apple cider vinegar idea comes from

The theory behind vinegar sounds reasonable at first. Healthy skin is slightly acidic, and that acidity helps the outer layer stay intact and keeps some bacteria in check. Eczema skin often has a higher, less acidic pH. Vinegar is an acid with mild antibacterial properties, so people reasoned that dabbing it on might restore the balance.

Older versions of this page, like many around the web, went much further. They credited cider vinegar with a long list of benefits for the skin and the immune system. Most of those claims do not survive a look at what is actually in the bottle:

  • "Rich in vitamins, minerals and fibre." Apple cider vinegar is about 94 percent water and 5 percent acetic acid. It contains no fibre at all, and every vitamin and mineral in it is present at 2 percent of the daily value or less. Potassium tops the list at around 2 percent.
  • "Flushes out the toxins that cause eczema." Eczema is not caused by toxins, and nothing in vinegar removes them. The condition comes from barrier weakness, immune activity and triggers.
  • "Kills the bacteria behind eczema." Bacteria can worsen flares, but they are not the cause. Weak acids also do not reliably clear S. aureus from inflamed skin.
  • "Contains beta-carotene that renews skin cells." There is no meaningful amount of beta-carotene in vinegar, and nothing to suggest a topical splash speeds up skin renewal.

So the one plausible idea left is the pH effect. That is what researchers set out to test.

What the 2019 study actually found

The study, published in Pediatric Dermatology in July 2019, was small but carefully designed. It enrolled 22 people aged 12 and over: 11 with atopic dermatitis and 11 with healthy skin. Each person soaked one forearm in a dilute apple cider vinegar solution (0.5 percent acetic acid) and the other in tap water. They did this for 10 minutes a day for 14 days, so every participant served as their own comparison.

The researchers measured two things. One was transepidermal water loss, a standard way to check how well the skin barrier holds in moisture. The other was skin pH.

  • Short term: right after a vinegar soak, the skin did become more acidic. In people with eczema, that effect faded within about 15 minutes. Water loss also rose briefly after soaking before settling back.
  • After two weeks: the vinegar-soaked arm showed no improvement in barrier function compared with the water-soaked arm. The effect on pH in the eczema group was similar to plain water.
  • Side effects: 73 percent of participants reported mild discomfort, such as stinging or irritation, which eased once they stopped.

The authors concluded that dilute acetic acid soaks gave no benefit and caused substantial adverse effects. As the National Eczema Association noted in its summary, the study was a pilot. It was small, used one brand of vinegar at one strength, and only tested forearms. Still, it is the most direct evidence available, and it points the wrong way for the remedy.

Why vinegar can make things worse

Eczema skin is often cracked, scratched raw or weeping. Putting an acid on it can sting, and the higher the concentration, the greater the risk. Undiluted or poorly diluted vinegar has caused chemical burns when applied to the skin, and it is especially hazardous near the eyes.

The recipe that circulated widely, and that this page once shared, mixed equal parts vinegar and water and dabbed it on with cotton balls. That is roughly ten times stronger than the 0.5 percent solution used in the study, where most participants already felt discomfort. The suggestion to keep going "until you see improvement" is also risky, because it encourages people to push through irritation instead of stopping.

Shop-bought cider vinegars also vary. The acid level differs between brands, "raw" or unfiltered products can contain live yeasts and bacteria, and some batches have been found to contain mould. None of that is ideal on broken skin.

If you already bought a bottle of organic, raw apple cider vinegar, it is better used in the kitchen. A spoonful in a salad dressing is perfectly safe for most people. If you are curious about trying any acidic soak on your skin, ask your doctor or dermatologist first, especially for a child.

What helps eczema, according to the evidence

There is no single cure, but a few approaches are well supported. These are the ones dermatologists build treatment plans around:

  • Moisturising every day. Regular emollients are the foundation of eczema care, even when the skin looks clear. Creams, ointments, gels and lotions all appear to work about equally well, so the best one is the one you will actually use. Applying them right after a bath helps lock in water.
  • Gentle washing. Short, lukewarm baths or showers and fragrance-free soap substitutes put less strain on the skin barrier than hot water and foaming cleansers.
  • Prescription anti-inflammatory creams. Topical corticosteroids remain the main treatment for flares. Used as directed, once a day is usually as effective as more frequent use, and twice-weekly use on problem areas can help prevent flares coming back. Non-steroid creams such as tacrolimus and pimecrolimus are another option.
  • Treatments for severe eczema. When creams are not enough, specialists can offer phototherapy, tablets, or newer injected medicines such as dupilumab.
  • Knowing your triggers. Soft cotton or silk clothing, a humidifier in dry weather, and keeping nails short to limit damage from scratching all help in small ways.

Some people with moderate or severe eczema who also have frequent skin infections are advised to take very dilute bleach baths. That is a specific treatment for a specific situation, and it should only be done on a doctor's instructions.

Common worries about steroid creams

A big reason people reach for vinegar is fear of side effects from prescribed creams. Those worries are understandable, and the honest answer is that strong steroids used too long or in the wrong place can thin the skin. But the risk is low when the right strength is used for the right length of time, and research suggests that intermittent use to prevent flares does not cause thinning.

Under-treating eczema has its own cost. Skin left inflamed itches more, gets scratched more, and is more likely to become infected. Sleep, school and work suffer. If a cream worries you, don't stop it on your own. Talk to a doctor about the dose, the strength or the alternatives.

The short answer

Apple cider vinegar is cheap and natural, and its acid does briefly lower skin pH. But the main study that tested it on eczema found no lasting benefit to the skin barrier and plenty of stinging. Most of the other claims made for it are not supported by what vinegar contains.

The steps that do help are less exciting: moisturise generously, wash gently, avoid known triggers and use prescribed treatments properly. If your eczema is not under control, a doctor or dermatologist can help you find a plan that works.

Sources: National Eczema Association: apple cider vinegar soaks and the skin barrier (2019); Wikipedia: Atopic dermatitis; Wikipedia: Apple cider vinegar. Earlier versions of this home remedy circulated via Healthy Definition and Why Don't You Try This.

Related:

COMMENTS