A Lemon-Battery Video and an Unverified Fire-Starting Claim

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-03-28.

A Lemon-Battery Video and an Unverified Fire-Starting Claim

A video posted online Sunday by North Survival shows an individual demonstrate how to make fire with a lemon.

“This is an awesome survival tip that you don’t want to miss,” he said.

Using six copper clips, six nails, a piece of wire and steel wool, the person claimed to use the lemon-based setup to heat steel wool and create a fire; this article does not establish that the setup provides dependable ignition.


How much power a lemon gives

In a lemon battery the energy comes from the metal electrodes, not the fruit: with zinc and copper, the zinc is oxidised as it dissolves into the acidic juice. A single zinc–copper lemon cell typically gives about 0.9 volts, and currents range up to about 1 milliamp depending on electrode size, which works out at less than a thousandth of a watt. That is too weak to light an incandescent torch bulb, and at least two cells are needed to run small devices such as LEDs. Lemon batteries are used mainly in teaching.

Sources: Wikipedia: Lemon battery

Source: Idealist4ever

Electricity is not the same as dependable ignition

A lemon battery is a useful way to explore a circuit, but the video's fire-starting claim needs independent measurement. Science World's classroom activity uses different metals and lemon juice to demonstrate a weak electrical source. Treat this clip as a question about evidence, not equipment to depend on in an outdoor emergency; a voltage reading alone would not establish reliable ignition.

Sources and further context: Science World: Lemon Battery

Power matters as well as voltage

A device can show a voltage while supplying too little current for the proposed load. That distinction is central to evaluating the ignition claim. The useful educational comparison concerns the measured circuit and its output under load, rather than assuming that any small battery-like setup can reliably start a fire.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1