The Dalai Lama on Paris, Prayer and the 'Brainwashing' of War

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The Dalai Lama on Prayer, Paris and War as “Brainwashing”

Days after the Paris attacks of November 2015, the Dalai Lama told an interviewer that praying for Paris was not enough. His reasoning was simple: people made this violence, so people have to undo it. The same idea runs through a longer essay on his official website, "The Reality of War", where he argues that most of us have been conditioned, even "brainwashed", into treating war as normal, heroic and acceptable.

Below is what he actually said, where it was published, what the essay argues and where it is often misquoted. We also look at the numbers behind his point about the cost of armies, and at what his message can mean for ordinary people who have no army to command.

What the Dalai Lama said after the Paris attacks

On the night of 13 November 2015, gunmen and suicide bombers struck the Bataclan concert hall, several cafés and restaurants, and the area outside the Stade de France. A total of 130 people were killed and more than 400 injured. The group calling itself Islamic State claimed responsibility the next day.

Speaking to the German broadcaster Deutsche Welle in India shortly afterwards, the Tibetan leader said: "We cannot solve this problem only through prayers." He went further, describing it as illogical that "humans have created this problem, and now we are asking God to solve it."

The remark spread quickly on social media, and it was often shortened to "stop praying for Paris". That is not quite what he meant. He did not tell anyone to stop praying. His point was that prayer cannot replace action. According to the UPI report on the interview, he called the attackers short-sighted, reminded listeners that only a small share of people support violent ideas, and linked today's violence to the twentieth century, when, in his words, more than 200 million people died in wars and conflicts. What is needed, he said, is a serious and systematic effort to build peace.

"The Reality of War": the brainwashing argument

The essay is short and blunt. Its starting point is that large military establishments are, by design, organisations for killing people, whatever their stated purpose. Because armies are legal and respected, the Dalai Lama writes, we rarely ask whether accepting war itself is a moral failure.

He sees the conditioning beginning early. Uniforms look smart, parades are exciting, children play at battles with toy guns, and films present combat as a test of courage. Over time this builds a picture of war as glamorous. His answer is direct: "War is neither glamorous nor attractive. It is monstrous."

The word "brainwashed" sounds harsh, but the claim behind it is modest and familiar to psychologists: people absorb the values of the culture around them without examining them. Much of what we feel about war comes from stories, games and ceremonies rather than from any direct contact with its results.

War as a fire that consumes people

The most memorable image in the essay is fire. Modern weapons, he notes, are mostly ways of burning, tearing and crushing human bodies, yet we talk about a new missile or aircraft as an impressive piece of engineering. We forget what it is built to do.

Fire also spreads. When one part of a front weakens, commanders send more troops, which in his image means feeding more living people into the flames. And each death or serious injury reaches far beyond the soldier. Parents, partners, children and friends carry the loss for decades. His complaint is not that we lack the facts, but that habit has dulled our reaction to them.

Why armies matter to dictators

A quieter but important argument in the essay concerns tyranny. A cruel ruler, however determined, cannot harm thousands of people alone. He needs an organised force that obeys orders and a society that accepts that force as normal. For the Dalai Lama, this makes a powerful standing army one of the conditions that allow dictatorship to exist, and he notes that military institutions have been among the worst violators of human rights, including the rights of their own soldiers.

This is also why he places the responsibility on ordinary people. Wars depend on millions of individual decisions to build, sell, fund, obey and applaud. Change those decisions and the machinery slows.

The cost of war, and Eisenhower's warning

The essay points to the huge sums governments spend on ever more complicated weapons that, ideally, will never be used, while the money, talent and energy could serve human needs. The figures support his concern. The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) estimated world military spending in 2015, the year of the Paris attacks, at nearly 1.7 trillion US dollars. The United States alone accounted for about 596 billion.

A similar warning came from an unexpected direction more than half a century earlier. In his farewell address on 17 January 1961, President Dwight D. Eisenhower, a former five-star general, cautioned Americans to guard against the "unwarranted influence" of what he named the military-industrial complex, and against the potential for a disastrous rise of misplaced power. The phrase is still quoted because it came from someone who knew the system from inside.

A caution is useful here. Online posts that share the Dalai Lama's message often add large claims of their own, for example that the entire war on terror is staged, or that secret "black budgets" run to many trillions of dollars. Those claims do not come from him, and they are not supported by reliable public evidence. His argument does not need them: the documented costs of war, in money and lives, are heavy enough.

What he does not say

It is easy to read the essay as absolute pacifism, but that would misrepresent it. The Dalai Lama writes that, in his view, some wars, such as the Second World War and the Korean War, were justified, and he admits that Cold War deterrence may have kept a kind of stability. His point is that we can usually only judge a war fairly in hindsight, that war is unpredictable once it begins, and that a balance of fear is not the same as real peace. Lasting peace, he argues, can only rest on genuine trust.

He is also not dismissing faith. As a Buddhist monk he prays and meditates every day. What he rejects is the idea that spiritual practice excuses us from practical work: education, dialogue, fair institutions and the slow effort of reducing hatred.

Putting the message into practice

Most readers will never vote on a defence budget or sit in a war cabinet, so what can they do with this? A few concrete ideas follow from the essay itself:

  • Notice the framing. When news, games or films make violence look thrilling, ask what is being left out: the injured, the families, the years of rebuilding.
  • Be careful with children's play and media. The essay specifically asks adults to stop glorifying war in front of children.
  • Refuse easy hatred. After an atrocity, blaming an entire religion or nation feeds the cycle the attackers want. The Dalai Lama's reminder that only a small minority support violence is a practical safeguard.
  • Support peace work that is concrete. Humanitarian aid, refugee support, reconciliation projects and education programmes are the "systematic approach" in action.
  • Pair reflection with action. Pray, meditate or reflect if that is part of your life, then do one practical thing, however small.

The Dalai Lama, born Lhamo Dhondup in 1935 and known by his monastic name Tenzin Gyatso, has lived in exile in India since 1959 and received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1989 for his non-violent campaign for Tibet. That history gives weight to his view that peace is built by people, step by step, and is not something to wait for.

You can read his full essay on war on the Dalai Lama's official website.

Sources: The Dalai Lama, "The Reality of War" (dalailama.com); UPI: Dalai Lama on Paris attacks, interview with Deutsche Welle (18 November 2015); Wikipedia: November 2015 Paris attacks; SIPRI: World military spending 2015; Wikipedia: Eisenhower's farewell address; Dalai Lama: brief biography. The topic was first covered on this site via a Collective Evolution post.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. I would love to read your articles but there is so much advertising in front of them you cannot see the words and it is very annoying to get them to disappear.

    ReplyDelete