Finland's Basic Income Experiment: The $876 Myth and Real Results

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Finland’s Basic Income: The 2015 Plan and the 2017–2018 Experiment

No, Finland never started paying every citizen $876 a month. In late 2015 that figure travelled around the world as if it were settled policy, but what Finland actually did was narrower and, in its own way, more interesting: from January 2017 to December 2018 it ran a national experiment that gave 2,000 unemployed people a tax-free €560 a month, with no conditions attached, and then measured what happened.

Here is how the 2015 story grew, what the experiment really looked like, what the results showed, and what they mean for the wider basic income debate.

Where the $876 headline came from

In spring 2015 Finland elected a new government led by Juha Sipilä of the Centre Party. Its programme promised a basic income experiment, and the idea polled well: Finnish media and the social insurance institution Kela reported strong public support for the concept in general terms.

Kela was asked to lead a research consortium and work out how a trial could be designed. While that work was still at the brainstorming stage, international outlets latched on to a figure of around €800 a month, roughly $876 at the time, and reported it as a plan to pay everyone in the country. Sipilä was quoted in the British press as saying that, for him, “a basic income means simplifying the social security system.”

That quote is the key to the whole story. The Finnish interest was not mainly about handing out free money. It was about a benefits system so complicated that taking a short-term or part-time job could leave an unemployed person worse off once benefits were cut and paperwork piled up.

What the preliminary study actually considered

The consortium's preliminary report, published on 30 March 2016, looked at several models:

  • A full basic income large enough to replace almost all other benefits. Versions of €1,000 and €1,500 a month were modelled, and would have needed flat income tax rates of roughly 60 and 79 percent. The researchers judged this far too expensive.
  • A partial basic income that would replace most basic benefits but leave earnings-related ones in place.
  • A negative income tax, paid through the tax system, which was set aside because Finland did not yet have real-time income data.

With a budget of only €20 million, the government chose a partial model. The bill, dated 25 August 2016, proposed €560 a month, about the net level of the basic unemployment allowance, for a sample of 2,000 people over two years.

How the 2017–2018 experiment worked

The 2,000 participants were picked at random from people aged 25 to 58 who were receiving unemployment support from Kela in late 2016. Taking part was compulsory, which avoided the usual problem of only enthusiastic volunteers signing up. A comparison group of unemployed people who were not selected carried on under the normal rules.

The payment was €560 a month, tax-free, and it did not shrink if a participant found work, started a business or earned freelance income. There was no obligation to look for a job or report to an employment office to keep it. That made it a clean test of one specific question: does unconditional money make unemployed people more or less likely to work?

The trial was never meant to be universal. Pensioners, students, people in work and everyone above the income thresholds were outside it. In 2018 the government also declined to extend or widen the experiment, which some international coverage wrongly described as Finland “scrapping” basic income.

What the results showed

The final results were presented on 6 May 2020 by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health together with the research team.

Employment: the effect was small. Over the second year, recipients worked on average 78 days, about six days more than the control group. In the first year there was no measurable difference at all. Families with children showed somewhat better employment results, though the researchers called those subgroup findings uncertain. A complication was the “activation model,” a separate reform that tightened the rules for ordinary unemployment benefits from 2018; economist Kari Hämäläinen of the VATT Institute said its effects could not be separated from those of the basic income in year two.

Wellbeing: here the differences were clearer. Recipients reported more life satisfaction, less mental strain, depression, sadness and loneliness, a more positive view of their own cognitive abilities, more trust in other people and institutions, and more confidence about the future. They were also more likely to say they could manage financially.

Two cautions matter. The survey behind the wellbeing results had a response rate of just 23 percent, and interviews with 81 recipients showed very mixed experiences. For people already in difficult situations, one researcher noted, the basic income did not seem to solve their problems. Lead researcher Olli Kangas summed up the employment effects as small.

The Dauphin experiment and other trials

Supporters in 2015 often pointed to Dauphin, a Manitoba town of about 10,000 people, as proof that basic income works. The real story is more nuanced than “poverty was eradicated.”

Dauphin was the “saturation site” of Mincome, a Canadian experiment launched in 1974 and funded jointly by Manitoba and the federal government. Any resident could apply, and payments were reduced by 50 cents for every dollar earned, so it worked more like a guaranteed income top-up than a flat payment to all. The project was shut down in 1979 by newly elected Progressive Conservative governments, and no final report was ever issued.

Later analysis found modest effects on work: hours fell by about 1 percent for men, 3 percent for married women and 5 percent for unmarried women, partly as mothers stayed home with young children. Economist Evelyn Forget later found that hospital visits in Dauphin fell by 8.5 percent during the programme, with fewer accident-related and mental health visits, though her study could not prove that the income itself caused the change.

Since then, many cities and charities have run their own pilots, from Stockton, California, which gave 125 residents $500 a month starting in 2019, to large cash-transfer studies in Kenya. Few of them test a truly universal payment, and their results tend to echo Finland's: little sign that people stop working, and noticeable gains in security and mental wellbeing.

What Finland's trial means for the basic income debate

Finland's experiment did not end poverty, and it was never designed to. What it did show is useful for anyone weighing the idea:

  • The fear of mass idleness was not borne out. Unconditional money did not make unemployed people work less; if anything, they worked slightly more.
  • Money is not a job machine. A modest payment on its own did little to move long-term unemployed people into work. Training, health care and local job markets matter too.
  • Security has value of its own. Less stress, more trust and more confidence are real outcomes, even if they are harder to put a price on.
  • Design decides everything. A full universal income is very expensive; partial or targeted versions are cheaper but behave differently. When you see a dramatic headline, check which model is actually on the table.

The lesson from 2015 is also a media one. A brainstormed number became a “plan,” and the plan became a promise that never existed. The genuine experiment that followed is a better guide to what unconditional income can and cannot do.

Sources: Finnish Ministry of Social Affairs and Health: results of the basic income experiment (6 May 2020); Kela research consortium presentation on the experiment design (2016, PDF); Wikipedia: Mincome; Kela; original 2015 report via US Uncut.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 2
  1. Excellent idea, especially as robotics are set to increase in the workplace making full-emplyment a notion of the past. This policy will facilitate the possibility of people trying out new ideas, creating a culture of innovation.
    The article needs to explain if taxes on those with full-time emplyment would increase to take into account this basic income.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't believe this is true. Finland has committed only to building out the pilot, and depending on the pilot's outcome will evaluate whether to move forward. Please provide a primary source for the claim that they've decided to move forward regardless of the pilot's success.

    ReplyDelete