Did the Big Bang Never Happen? The 2015 Ali–Das Model Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Did the Big Bang Never Happen? A 2015 Model Explained

In early 2015, headlines claimed that a "new model suggests the Big Bang never happened". The model in question was a theoretical paper by physicists Ahmed Farag Ali and Saurya Das, published in Physics Letters B. It did not show that the universe never expanded from a hot, dense early state. What it proposed was narrower: that adding certain quantum corrections to Einstein's equations removes the Big Bang singularity, the moment of infinite density at which today's physics breaks down, so that the universe could have existed for an infinitely long time. The idea drew wide attention but remained one speculative proposal among many, and the standard Big Bang picture is still the framework cosmologists use.

What the Big Bang theory actually says

The Big Bang is often imagined as an explosion of a tiny point into empty space. That is not quite what the theory describes. It says that the whole universe was once far hotter and denser than today and has been expanding and cooling ever since, with space itself stretching rather than matter flying outward into a void.

Several independent lines of evidence support this picture:

  • Expansion. In 1929 Edwin Hubble showed that more distant galaxies are moving away from us faster, building on work by Georges Lemaître, who had proposed an expanding universe in 1927.
  • The cosmic microwave background. In 1964 Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson stumbled on a faint, almost uniform glow of microwaves filling the sky, the cooled leftover heat of the early universe.
  • Light elements. The theory predicts how much hydrogen, helium and deuterium formed in the first minutes, and measurements largely agree, with lithium-7 the main puzzle.
  • Large-scale structure. The way galaxies cluster across the sky matches computer simulations of structure growing from small early ripples.

Measurements of the expansion and the microwave background put the age of the universe at about 13.8 billion years. The name itself came from the astronomer Fred Hoyle, who used the phrase on BBC radio in 1949 while defending his rival steady-state theory.

The singularity problem

If you run Einstein's general relativity backwards, everything in the observable universe gets squeezed toward a point of infinite density and temperature. Most physicists do not take that literally. Infinite values are usually a sign that a theory has been pushed beyond the conditions it can handle, and here general relativity, which ignores quantum effects, is being applied where quantum effects must dominate.

Ali put the issue plainly to Phys.org at the time, as quoted by the site: "The Big Bang singularity is the most serious problem of general relativity because the laws of physics appear to break down there." The honest position, still true today, is that existing physics cannot describe the very first instant. A full answer probably needs a working theory of quantum gravity, and no such theory has been confirmed.

How the Ali–Das model works

The paper, titled "Cosmology from quantum potential", started from earlier work by Das on the Raychaudhuri equation, a piece of mathematics that describes how paths through spacetime converge. In classical physics those paths can meet at a single point, which is how singularities arise.

Ali and Das replaced the classical paths with quantum ones, borrowed from the Bohmian interpretation of quantum mechanics, in which particles follow definite trajectories guided by a "quantum potential". These quantum trajectories cannot cross, so they never converge to a point. Feeding the corrected equation into the standard equations for an expanding universe produced two extra terms:

  • one that behaves like a cosmological constant, the kind of term usually linked to dark energy, and whose estimated size the authors said matches the observed value;
  • one that behaves like radiation in the early universe and stops the density from becoming infinite, giving a universe with no singularity and an infinite age.

The model also did not predict a "Big Crunch", a future collapse of the universe back on itself. A companion paper co-written by Das suggested the quantum fluid involved might be made of gravitons, the hypothetical massless particles thought to carry gravity, which could in theory form a Bose-Einstein condensate. Gravitons themselves have never been detected.

Why it did not overturn the Big Bang

The coverage at the time often skipped several important points.

First, the model removes the singularity, not the expansion. In it, the universe still went through an extremely hot, dense early phase and has been expanding since. The cosmic microwave background, the light-element abundances and the receding galaxies are all still explained in the usual way. "No Big Bang" really meant "no infinite starting point".

Second, it was contested. Physicist E. I. Lashin published a comment arguing that the derivation of the corrected equations was flawed. Ali and Das replied that the critique misunderstood their method, but the exchange shows that the model was far from settled.

Third, it made few new predictions that observations could test. Matching the size of the cosmological constant was presented as a success, but a model needs to predict something the standard picture does not before it can displace it. Meanwhile, results from missions such as Planck continued to fit the standard model closely.

Finally, the paper used the Bohmian interpretation, a minority view of quantum mechanics. That is a legitimate choice, but it means the conclusions rest on assumptions many physicists do not share.

Other ideas about what came before

The Ali–Das model belongs to a long tradition of attempts to avoid a true beginning:

  • The steady-state theory, championed by Hoyle, said the universe has always looked roughly the same, with new matter constantly created. It lost support after the discovery of the microwave background.
  • Cyclic or oscillating models, discussed since the 1930s by Alexander Friedmann, Richard Tolman and others, imagine endless rounds of expansion and contraction.
  • Bounce models, including some from loop quantum gravity, suggest a previous contracting universe "bounced" into our expanding one instead of starting from a singularity.
  • Eternal inflation and multiverse ideas place our Big Bang inside a larger, possibly eternal, process.

Some speculative ideas go even further, such as proposals in which time runs in opposite directions on either side of the Big Bang. None of these has been confirmed by observation.

Where the question stands

The 2015 headlines made a technical paper sound like a revolution. The real story is still interesting: a serious attempt to use quantum effects to smooth away the most troublesome point in cosmology. Das summed up the authors' hopes in the same interview, saying, "It is satisfying to note that such straightforward corrections can potentially resolve so many issues at once."

The model has not replaced the standard picture, and whether the universe had a true beginning remains open. What is not in doubt is that it has been expanding and cooling for about 13.8 billion years. Solving the first instant will most likely require a tested theory of quantum gravity, and that is still one of the great unfinished tasks of physics.

Sources: Ali and Das, Cosmology from quantum potential (arXiv); Physics Letters B (ScienceDirect); Lisa Zyga, Phys.org; Ali and Das, reply to Lashin's comment; Wikipedia: Big Bang. Earlier coverage: ScienceAlert, Higher Perspective.

More from the archive:

COMMENTS