Drinking Water to Lose Weight: One Man's Plan and What Science Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Drinking More Water to Lose Weight: One Man’s 10-Day Plan

Can drinking more water help you lose weight? Yes, a little, and mostly in indirect ways: water has no calories, it can replace sugary drinks, and a glass before meals may help some people eat less. What it cannot do is melt fat on its own. A fast drop of several pounds in the first week of any new routine is mostly water and gut contents, and it comes back just as quickly.

A good way to see both sides is the story of British blogger Steve Aitchison, who wrote about losing 8 pounds in a week after he started drinking about two litres of water a day. Below is his plan, what his own numbers really show, and what research says about water and weight.

The experiment that started it

Aitchison described himself as an ordinary, busy man rather than a fitness enthusiast. He walked about two miles a day, did not go to a gym, and had drifted up to around 212 pounds (15 st 2 lb), roughly a stone more than three years earlier. Past diets had worked for a while, but he admitted his weak spot was biscuits: half a packet of digestives dunked in tea could add up to around 700 calories in minutes.

He began drinking water on a schedule because he felt sluggish and bloated in the early mornings, not to lose weight. A week later his scale read 204 pounds. He then stopped the routine for a week and climbed back to 209. When he restarted, his weight fell again, eventually reaching 200 and, on one day, 198 pounds. He said he had not changed his diet.

It is a lively personal account, and the on-off-on test he ran on himself is actually its most revealing part, as we will see.

The daily drinking plan

His routine spread water evenly across the day. Here it is with imperial conversions added (1 US fluid ounce is about 29.6 ml):

WhenMillilitresUS fluid ounces (approx.)
On waking300 to 600 ml10 to 20 oz
One hour later, before breakfast250 to 500 ml8 to 17 oz
After each tea or coffee100 to 250 ml3 to 8 oz
About 20 minutes before each main meal250 to 500 ml8 to 17 oz
Two hours before bed300 to 600 ml10 to 20 oz
Daily totalabout 1,200 to 2,450 mlabout 40 to 83 oz

He suggested smaller people use the lower end of each range and larger people the upper end. For comparison, the UK's NHS advises most adults to aim for six to eight cups or glasses of fluid a day, more in hot weather, during long exercise, when pregnant or breastfeeding, or when ill. Tea, coffee and lower-fat milk count toward that, as does the water in food. So his plan is in a normal range, not an extreme one.

What the scale was really measuring

Losing 8 pounds of body fat in a week would require a deficit of roughly 28,000 calories, which is not possible while eating normally, biscuits included. So what happened?

  • Water and sodium balance. When fluid intake is low, the body holds on to water. Drinking steadily lets the kidneys excrete more, and some people do feel less puffy as a result.
  • Gut contents and timing. Changes in digestion, regularity and even the time of day you weigh yourself can move the scale by several pounds.
  • Small behaviour changes. Drinking water after every tea, and before meals, can quietly reduce snacking and portion sizes even when someone feels their diet is "the same".

His own test makes the point: weight went up by five pounds the week he stopped. Fat does not arrive that quickly either. The swings were mostly fluid, not fat. The longer, slower drift from 212 to around 200 pounds over several weeks is more likely to include some real fat loss, probably through eating a bit less.

That is also why health agencies stress pace. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention notes that people who lose weight gradually, about 1 to 2 pounds a week, are more likely to keep it off, and warns that unrealistic goals tend to end in discouragement.

Where water genuinely helps

Water is not a fat burner, but it is a useful tool:

  • Swapping drinks. Replacing a daily soda, sweetened coffee or juice with water can remove a few hundred calories a day without any feeling of dieting. The CDC lists this exact swap as a sensible short-term goal.
  • A glass before meals. A 2010 randomised trial in the journal Obesity gave middle-aged and older adults on a reduced-calorie diet about 500 ml of water before each main meal. Over 12 weeks they lost roughly 2 kg more than the comparison group. The effect was modest and may be smaller in younger people, but it supports the "drink before you eat" habit.
  • Telling thirst from hunger. Many people reach for a snack when they are mildly thirsty or simply bored. A glass of water first gives you a moment to decide.
  • Energy and focus. Even mild dehydration can make people feel tired or headachy, which in turn makes unplanned snacking more likely.

Claims that do not hold up

The original account included a few explanations that are popular online but not accurate:

"The brain treats water as food and kick-starts your metabolism." Water does not need digesting like food, and any rise in energy use after drinking cold water is small. It will not burn meaningful amounts of fat.

"If your kidneys are short of water, the liver stops burning fat." The liver and kidneys do work together in many ways, but there is no evidence that ordinary, mild under-drinking switches off fat metabolism in this way.

"Water flushes impurities from your skin." Severe dehydration affects skin, but in healthy people extra water has not been shown to erase wrinkles or "detox" the complexion.

"More is always better." Very large amounts in a short time can be dangerous. Healthy kidneys can clear roughly 0.8 to 1 litre an hour; drinking far beyond that, as some endurance athletes have done, can dilute blood sodium and cause water intoxication (hyponatremia), which can be life-threatening.

How to try it safely and make it last

  1. Spread it out. Sip across the day, as in the plan above, rather than downing litres at once.
  2. Expect more bathroom trips at first. This settles for most people within a week or two.
  3. Pair water with one food change. In this story, the biscuits were the obvious target. A water habit plus a smaller snack is where lasting results come from.
  4. Weigh yourself consistently. Same time, same conditions, and look at the weekly trend, not the daily number.
  5. Check first if you have a health condition. People with heart, kidney or liver problems, or those on medicines that affect fluid balance, should talk to a doctor before increasing their intake.

Drinking more water is one of the easiest healthy habits there is. Treat the first week's drop on the scale as a pleasant bonus, not as proof of fat loss, and the habit is far more likely to stay with you.

Sources: Original story and plan by Steve Aitchison, Lessons Learned In Life; CDC: Losing Weight; NHS: Water, drinks and your health; Wikipedia: Water intoxication.

Related:

COMMENTS