Why a $258 Billion Dogecoin Lawsuit Against Musk Was Dismissed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-17.

Investor Sues Musk, Tesla and SpaceX for $258 Billion Over Dogecoin

In June 2022 a Dogecoin investor named Keith Johnson sued Elon Musk, Tesla and SpaceX in federal court in Manhattan, asking for $258 billion. He accused them of running a racketeering scheme that pushed up the price of the meme cryptocurrency and left ordinary buyers with heavy losses. The headline figure made the case famous overnight, but it never came close to a payout: a federal judge dismissed the lawsuit in August 2024, and the investors later abandoned their appeal.

Here is what the complaint claimed, why the number was so large, and what the outcome tells anyone thinking about meme coins.

What the lawsuit alleged

The case, Johnson v. Musk, was filed on 16 June 2022 in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York. Johnson described himself as an American who had been defrauded by what the complaint called the defendants' "Dogecoin Crypto Pyramid Scheme". He argued that Musk, together with his two companies, formed an illegal enterprise that talked up the coin to inflate its value.

According to Fortune's report on the filing, the complaint said the defendants presented Dogecoin as a real investment when it has no value at all. Johnson wanted the case to become a class action on behalf of everyone who had lost money trading Dogecoin since April 2019.

Where the $258 billion figure came from

The total was built from two parts. Johnson claimed $86 billion in damages and then asked for that amount to be tripled under US racketeering law, which allows treble damages. Fortune's breakdown listed the extra $172 billion on top of the base claim, giving $258 billion in all.

Beyond money, the complaint asked the court to bar Musk and his companies from promoting Dogecoin and to declare that trading the coin counts as gambling under federal and New York law.

It helps to remember what a complaint is. It sets out what a plaintiff wants a court to accept; it is not a finding of wrongdoing. Large headline numbers are common in such filings and say little about a case's chances.

Musk, tweets and the Dogecoin price

Dogecoin was created in December 2013 by software engineers Billy Markus and Jackson Palmer as a joke about crypto speculation, with the Shiba Inu dog from the "Doge" meme as its mascot. Unlike Bitcoin, it has no hard cap on supply: about five billion new coins are added every year.

Musk became its best-known fan. A tweet reading "One Word: Doge" in December 2020 was followed by a jump of about 20%, and another post in April 2021 coincided with a rise of more than 100%. Dogecoin's market capitalisation peaked above $85 billion in early May 2021. Then, during Musk's appearance as host of Saturday Night Live on 8 May 2021, the price fell by almost 30%.

By the time the lawsuit was filed, the coin was trading at about five cents, down roughly two thirds for the year and far below its high of around 74 cents. Musk and his companies did not respond to requests for comment when the case was first reported.

How the case ended

The complaint was later amended and expanded, adding claims that Musk had engaged in insider trading and market manipulation, including an April 2023 episode when Twitter, which Musk by then owned, briefly replaced its bird logo with the Doge image and the coin's price rose.

On 29 August 2024, US District Judge Alvin Hellerstein dismissed the case. As reported at the time, the judge found that Musk's posts about Dogecoin were the kind of aspirational talk and puffery that no reasonable investor would treat as a factual promise, and that the plaintiffs had not shown that Musk's trading was fraudulent. The investors filed an appeal but reportedly withdrew it in November 2024, which ended the litigation without any damages being awarded.

Is Dogecoin a pyramid scheme?

The word "pyramid scheme" has a specific meaning: a business that pays earlier members mainly from money brought in by new recruits, rather than from a real product. Courts did not find that Dogecoin fitted that description in this case. Dogecoin is an open-source cryptocurrency with no company behind it that promises returns.

Racketeering claims face a similarly high bar. Under the US RICO law, a plaintiff has to show an organised pattern of criminal activity, not just enthusiastic promotion followed by a falling price. That is one reason ambitious crypto lawsuits against celebrities often fail at the first stage. That does not make it a safe investment. Its value depends almost entirely on demand, attention and sentiment, and celebrity posts can move the price sharply in either direction. Regulators in several countries have repeatedly warned that crypto assets can lose most or all of their value quickly.

What investors can take from the case

  • Lawsuit figures are not verdicts. A $258 billion claim made headlines, but the court awarded nothing.
  • Celebrity enthusiasm is not a guarantee. Courts tend to treat jokes and hype on social media as opinion rather than investment advice.
  • Volatility cuts both ways. The same attention that lifted Dogecoin in 2021 helped drive its fall.
  • Only risk what you can afford to lose. If you are unsure, speak to a regulated financial adviser before buying any crypto asset.

The links below are referral offers from this site's owner for well-known crypto services. They are shared as information, not investment advice, and some of these services have since changed or withdrawn their offers in certain countries.

    Ways to buy Bitcoin and other #crypto like Ethereum ( ETH) , Cardano ( ADA) , BNB and more:
  • Join Binance, the biggest exchange in the world, buy, earn and spend crypto with their Visa Debit Card
  • Join Crypto.Com , Use our referral link to sign up for Crypto.com and we both get $25 USD 🙂 You can earn interest and use their Visa Debit Card.
  • Sign up with our referral link and earn up to 100 Euros in free BORG to kickstart your crypto portfolio with SwissBorg with your first transfer of 50 Euros!
  • Join Nexo, a great app to earn passive income, and earn $10.

Sources: Fortune / Bloomberg, Elon Musk, SpaceX and Tesla sued for $258 billion over alleged Dogecoin pyramid scheme (16 June 2022); Wikipedia, Dogecoin.

COMMENTS