Originally published 2022-06-17.

On 24 May 2020, the mining company Rio Tinto set off explosives at Juukan Gorge in the Pilbara region of Western Australia and destroyed two ancient rock shelters, known as Juukan 1 and Juukan 2. Archaeologists had shown that people lived in and used the shelters for around 46,000 years, making them some of the most important Aboriginal heritage sites in the country. The blast was legal, carried out under a permission granted in 2013, and it was done to expand the Brockman 4 iron-ore mine.
The destruction caused a national outcry, a parliamentary inquiry, the departure of Rio Tinto's chief executive and chairman, and a fierce debate about Australian heritage law that is still running. This is what was lost, how it was allowed to happen, and what has changed since.
Where Juukan Gorge is and who it belongs to
Juukan Gorge lies in the Hamersley Range, roughly 60 kilometres north-west of the mining town of Tom Price. It sits on the country of the Puutu Kunti Kurrama and Pinikura peoples, usually shortened to PKKP, who are the recognised native title holders of the area. The gorge takes its name from a Puutu Kunti Kurrama man known as Juukan, also called Tommy Ashburton.
For the PKKP the shelters were not just a scientific site. They were places connected to ancestors, ceremony and stories, part of a living cultural landscape rather than a museum. That is why traditional owners describe the loss as a wound to their community, not simply a loss to archaeology.
What archaeologists found in the shelters
The shelters had been studied for years, but the key work came in 2014, a year after the mining consent had already been issued. An excavation led by archaeologist Michael Slack recovered thousands of artefacts and pushed back the known age of human occupation in the area dramatically. Among the finds reported by the ABC:
- A sharpened kangaroo bone about 28,000 years old, worked into a pointed tool. It is described as the oldest known bone tool in Australia.
- Grinding and pounding stones believed to be among the earliest grindstone technology found in Western Australia.
- A length of plaited human hair about 4,000 years old, possibly part of a hair belt. DNA testing linked it to the direct ancestors of today's PKKP people, a rare physical link between living families and their deep past.
- Stone tools and animal bones showing how people adapted as the climate and local wildlife changed, including through the last Ice Age.
Juukan 2 is described as the only inland site in Australia with evidence of continuous human occupation for more than 46,000 years. Slack later said it was of the highest archaeological significance in the country.
How the destruction was legally approved
The legal route was Section 18 of Western Australia's Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972. Under that section, a landowner or company could ask the state's Aboriginal affairs minister for consent to use land in a way that would damage or destroy an Aboriginal site. In 2013 the minister granted Rio Tinto that consent for the Brockman 4 expansion, knowing it would affect the two shelters.
Three features of the old law drew most of the criticism:
- The consent could not be reopened when significant new information came to light, so the 2014 discoveries changed nothing legally.
- The company could appeal a refusal, but traditional owners had no equivalent right to appeal a consent.
- The advisory committee that reviewed applications was not required to include Aboriginal members.
In a statement after the blast, Rio Tinto said that "ministerial consent was granted to allow Rio Tinto to conduct activity at the Brockman 4 mine" affecting the shelters, and that it had changed its plans elsewhere to avoid heritage impacts where practicable.
The days before the blast
According to Wikipedia's account of the inquiry evidence, the PKKP asked for an urgent halt five days before the explosions. The blasting went ahead anyway. Burchell Hayes, a PKKP director, told the ABC that the group only discovered the shelters were about to be affected by chance, after asking to visit the site for NAIDOC Week, and that blasting took place about 11 metres from the shelters.
Speaking to Ngaarda Radio, Hayes described the loss as deeply emotional for people with a direct ancestral connection to the place: "It's really, really hard to swallow that — it's no longer there." Rio Tinto later admitted that it had not told the traditional owners about alternative mine plans that would have left the shelters intact.
Fallout: resignations and the inquiry
The public reaction, including from investors, was swift. Rio Tinto apologised and executives lost bonuses, but that was not enough. On 11 September 2020 chief executive Jean-Sébastien Jacques and two other senior executives announced they would step down, and chairman Simon Thompson followed in March 2021.
A federal parliamentary committee received more than 140 submissions and held public hearings. Its interim report, published on 9 December 2020, was titled Never Again. It recommended that Rio Tinto compensate the traditional owners, pay for rehabilitation, return all artefacts removed from the site and review its agreements with them, and it criticised both state and federal governments. Committee chair Warren Entsch said: "Never again can we allow the destruction, the devastation and the vandalism of cultural sites." The final report, A Way Forward, followed on 18 October 2021.
What has changed since 2020
Western Australia passed a new Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Act in 2021, due to replace the 1972 law from 1 July 2023. Farmers and landholders complained that it was confusing and costly, and within weeks of starting the state government announced it would repeal it. An amended version of the old 1972 Act took effect instead on 15 November 2023. It keeps the Section 18 process but adds an Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Committee with a majority of Aboriginal members to advise on decisions, and gives traditional owners more say.
At the site itself, Rio Tinto and the PKKP have worked on remediation. Work on a full-size replica of the shelters, funded by Rio Tinto and built from concrete blocks shaped using historical photographs, oral history and imprints of the rock face, was reported in 2025. Traditional owners have said publicly that the anger and grief remain.
Why Juukan Gorge still matters
Juukan Gorge became a turning point because it exposed a gap that many people had not realised existed: a legal permit could outweigh tens of thousands of years of history and the wishes of the people whose heritage it was. It has since become shorthand in Australian business and politics for what happens when consent is treated as a box to tick rather than an ongoing relationship. For anyone following mining, heritage or Indigenous rights anywhere in the world, it is a case worth knowing.
Sources: ABC News, 26 May 2020; Al Jazeera, 10 December 2020; Wikipedia: Juukan Gorge. Burchell Hayes interview: Ngaarda Media radio, 2020. Earlier coverage: IFLScience. Photos: Juukan Gorge rock shelters, as circulated in 2020 news coverage.

COMMENTS