Originally published 2022-06-18.

In June 2022 SpaceX fired at least five employees who had helped write and circulate an internal open letter criticising Elon Musk's public behaviour, according to reports by The New York Times and Reuters at the time. The letter said Musk's posts and conduct embarrassed staff and reflected on the company. Eighteen months later, the US National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) accused SpaceX of illegally firing eight people over the letter, and SpaceX answered by suing the agency.
The case drew attention partly because of the contrast with Musk's description of himself as a free speech absolutist. But the legal question was narrower and more concrete: whether workers who join together to raise concerns about their workplace are protected from being fired for it.
What the open letter said
The letter was posted on internal company channels in mid-June 2022 and was first reported by The Verge on 16 June. It was addressed to SpaceX's executives and argued that Musk's behaviour on social media and in public had become a problem for the people who worked for him. The authors described it as a frequent source of distraction and embarrassment for us, particularly in recent weeks
.
The central argument was about how closely Musk and the company are tied together. Because he is the chief executive and best-known face of SpaceX, the authors wrote, each of his tweets is effectively treated as a company statement. According to reports on the letter, it asked leadership to distance SpaceX publicly from Musk's personal posts, to hold all leaders to the same standards, and to define clearly how unacceptable behaviour would be handled.
The timing was not random. In May 2022 Business Insider reported that SpaceX had paid $250,000 in 2018 to settle a claim by a flight attendant who said Musk had exposed himself to her and propositioned her on a company jet in 2016. Musk denied the allegations and called them false. Employees who wrote the letter said his public response, and the jokes he posted afterwards, sat badly with the company's stated zero-tolerance policy on harassment.
How SpaceX responded
Within days, several people involved in the letter were dismissed. The company's president and chief operating officer, Gwynne Shotwell, explained the decision in an email to staff, which The New York Times reported. She wrote that the letter and the way signatures were gathered had made employees feel uncomfortable, intimidated and bullied, and/or angry
, because some felt pressured to sign something they did not agree with. She added that the company had important work to do and no need for what she called overreaching activism.
Reuters put the number fired at a minimum of five at the time. The exact total was not public until the labour board's complaint later named eight people.
The wider harassment concerns
The letter did not appear out of nowhere. In December 2021 a former SpaceX engineer, Ashley Kosak, published an essay describing repeated sexual harassment she said she experienced at the company and arguing that complaints were not handled properly. Shotwell reportedly responded with a company-wide email saying the company would look into the issues.
Similar concerns had been raised at Tesla, Musk's car company. Workers at its factory in Fremont, California, brought lawsuits alleging racism and sexual harassment, and some former employees have said they were let go after complaining. Those cases are separate from SpaceX and each has its own facts and outcomes, but they formed part of the background to the open letter.
The labour board's complaint
In early January 2024 the NLRB's regional director in Los Angeles issued a formal complaint against SpaceX. It alleged that the company illegally fired eight employees for engaging in protected concerted activity, the legal term for workers acting together about working conditions. It also said managers had questioned the letter's authors and made coercive statements, including suggesting that people who disagreed with Musk's behaviour should leave.
The day after the complaint was filed, SpaceX sued the NLRB in federal court in Texas, arguing that the agency's structure is unconstitutional, in part because of how its judges and board members can be removed. A federal judge ruled in February 2024 that the case belonged in California, and on 5 March 2024 a panel of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals declined SpaceX's request to keep it in Texas. The constitutional challenge, which several other companies joined with their own cases, continued in the courts after that.
Separately, the fired employees filed a complaint with California's Civil Rights Department alleging that SpaceX had failed to correct sexual harassment.
Free speech and workplace rights are not the same thing
Much of the online reaction framed the firings as hypocrisy: a man who calls himself a free speech absolutist dismissing staff who criticised him. That is a fair political point, but it can blur the law.
The First Amendment to the US Constitution limits what governments can do to restrict speech. It does not, in general, stop a private employer from firing someone for what they say. What protects workers in situations like this one is the National Labor Relations Act of 1935. Section 7 of that law gives employees the right to act together for "mutual aid or protection", and that right applies whether or not they belong to a union. Writing a joint letter to management about harassment policy and the conduct of a company leader is the kind of activity the NLRB argued falls under that protection.
For employees, the practical lessons are fairly simple. Concerns raised collectively and focused on working conditions generally have stronger legal protection than individual complaints about unrelated matters. Keeping copies of messages and dates helps if a dispute arises. And in the US, a charge with the NLRB generally has to be filed within six months of the action being challenged, so timing matters.
Why the case still matters
The SpaceX firings became a reference point in several larger debates: how far a founder's personal brand should shape a company's public voice, how workplaces respond to harassment allegations involving top executives, and whether the federal agency that enforces labour law is itself constitutional.
For SpaceX, the episode did little to slow the company's business. For the people who signed the letter, it became a test of whether rules written in the 1930s still protect workers who speak up together, even at one of the most valuable private companies in the world.
Sources: CNBC, 4 January 2024: SpaceX charged with illegally firing workers who spoke critically of Elon Musk; Bloomberg Law, March 2024: SpaceX bid to keep labor suit in Texas denied by 5th Circuit; Futurism, 17 June 2022: SpaceX fires employees who criticised Musk; Wikipedia: National Labor Relations Act of 1935. Original reporting by The Verge, The New York Times and Reuters.

COMMENTS