Erdoğan Vows to “Bury the Contemporary Byzantines”: Speech Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-08.

Erdoğan Vows to “Bury the Contemporary Byzantines”

On 29 May 2022, at a rally in Istanbul marking the 569th anniversary of the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan told the crowd: “We’ll bury the contemporary Byzantines. We say No to Aegean and the Mediterranean.” The remark was widely read in Greece as aimed at Greeks and the Greek government, and it came at a low point in relations between the two neighbours, days after Erdoğan said he would no longer deal with Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis.

Here is what was said, the history behind the language, and why the speech drew criticism.

The rally and the speech

The event was held at Istanbul’s old Atatürk Airport, which the government planned to turn into a large public park. It featured a Janissary marching band, an air force display and performers in Ottoman military costume. The Greek news site Keep Talking Greece reported a crowd of around half a million, including civil servants, students and party members brought in on free public transport; that figure has not been independently confirmed.

Erdoğan tied the anniversary to his “2053 vision”, a target date for a strong and united Turkey that falls on the 600th anniversary of the conquest. He said that, just as Turkey’s ancestors had buried Byzantium, he hoped the country would consign to history the “contemporary Byzantines” he accused of plotting against it. He also listed places where he said Turkey was telling others to stop, including Libya, Syria, Iraq, the Mediterranean and the Aegean, and he described Constantinople’s capture in religious terms: “Constantinople was the favourite city of the Prophet Muhammad and that is why it was conquered.”

Who are the “Byzantines”?

The Byzantine Empire was the continuation of the Eastern Roman Empire, ruled from Constantinople for more than a thousand years. Its people called themselves Romans, spoke Greek and were overwhelmingly Orthodox Christian. The city fell to Ottoman forces under Sultan Mehmed II on 29 May 1453, and the date is still marked as a national commemoration in Turkey.

In Turkish nationalist rhetoric, “Byzantine” is often used as a coded reference to Greeks and to the Greek Orthodox community. That is why Greek commentators heard the phrase as a threat aimed at modern Greece and at Christians of Greek origin who once lived across what is now Turkey, rather than as a historical reference.

The quarrel with Mitsotakis

The speech followed a sharp break between the two leaders. In mid-May 2022 Mitsotakis became the first Greek prime minister to address a joint meeting of the US Congress, where he warned against creating new sources of instability in NATO’s south-eastern flank, a remark widely read as a reference to Turkey’s requests for US fighter jets.

Erdoğan reacted angrily. He said Mitsotakis no longer existed for him and that he would not meet him again, accusing him of breaking an understanding not to bring third countries into their disputes. On the day of the rally he repeated that Mitsotakis was no longer his interlocutor.

In the same period Erdoğan criticised the US military presence in Greece, which had been expanded under an updated defence cooperation agreement, and accused Greece of sheltering members of the Gülen movement, which Ankara calls “FETÖ” and blames for the 2016 coup attempt. He also pointed to Greece’s debt, putting it at €400 billion owed to European countries. Greece’s public debt was indeed very large after the eurozone crisis, much of it held by European bailout funds, but the figure was offered as a jibe rather than as part of any policy argument.

Why the remarks caused alarm

Words about “burying” a people carry heavy weight in this region. The Ottoman Empire carried out the genocides of Greeks, Armenians and Assyrians in the early twentieth century, and Turkey still does not recognise those genocides. Hundreds of thousands of Greek Orthodox Christians of Anatolia and Pontus were killed or driven out, and the Greek community of Istanbul itself later shrank to a few thousand.

Turkey also invaded Cyprus in July 1974 and has occupied the northern part of the island ever since; UN Security Council Resolution 550 condemned the occupation as illegal. In 2022 it was also carrying out military operations in northern Iraq and threatening a new incursion into northern Syria.

Against that background, a head of state promising before a huge crowd to bury the “contemporary Byzantines” and rejecting Greek claims in the Aegean and the Mediterranean was seen in Athens as more than campaign theatre.

The wider Greek–Turkish dispute

The two NATO allies disagree on several connected issues: the extent of territorial waters and airspace in the Aegean, rights to the continental shelf and seabed energy resources in the eastern Mediterranean, the military status of Greek islands near the Turkish coast, and the division of Cyprus. Turkey’s maritime deals with Libya in 2019 and 2022, which Athens says ignore the maritime rights of Greek islands such as Crete, were answered by a Greek agreement with Egypt.

Tensions eased somewhat after the deadly earthquakes in Turkey in February 2023, when Greek rescuers were among the first to arrive. In December 2023 the two governments signed a declaration on friendly relations and good neighbourliness. Observers caution that the core disputes, above all Cyprus, remain unresolved.

Reading the speech in context

Erdoğan often uses Ottoman imagery to rally domestic support, especially ahead of elections; Turkey went to the polls in May 2023. That helps explain the tone, but it does not make the language harmless. Rhetoric that casts a neighbouring people as an enemy to be buried feeds nationalism on both sides and makes diplomacy harder. The most useful way to read the speech is as a snapshot of how far relations had fallen in the spring of 2022, and of how history is still used as a political weapon in the region.

Sources: Keep Talking Greece: Erdogan “We bury contemporary Byzantines”; Wikipedia: Greece–Turkey relations.

COMMENTS