Originally published 2022-06-09.
On 9 June 2022 a court in the Russian-backed "Donetsk People's Republic" (DPR) sentenced two British men, Aiden Aslin and Shaun Pinner, and a Moroccan man, Brahim Saadoun, to death. All three had been fighting with Ukraine's armed forces and were captured during the siege of Mariupol. The sentences were never carried out: the three were freed on 21 September 2022 in a prisoner exchange brokered with help from Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

Aiden Aslin, Shaun Pinner and Brahim Saadoun in the courtroom in Donetsk, June 2022. Image circulated on Telegram.
Who the three men were
Aiden Aslin was born in January 1994 in Newark, Nottinghamshire, and worked as a carer before travelling to Syria in 2015 to fight Islamic State alongside the Kurdish YPG. In 2018 he moved to Ukraine, settled in Mykolaiv and enlisted in the 36th Separate Marine Brigade, a regular unit of the Ukrainian navy. He was 28 when he was sentenced.
Shaun Pinner, then 48, was also a British national who had made his home in Ukraine and was serving with Ukrainian marines when the full-scale invasion began. Brahim Saadoun was a young Moroccan who had reportedly come to Ukraine to study and later joined its armed forces; his relatives insisted he was a regular soldier, not a hired fighter.
Mariupol was encircled from the first days of the invasion on 24 February 2022. Aslin surrendered with his unit on 12 April 2022, and Pinner was reportedly captured in the city in the same period. Within days, pro-Kremlin media were broadcasting interviews with them while they were in custody, which human rights lawyers such as Geoffrey Robertson said breached the Geneva Conventions' rules against exposing prisoners to public curiosity.
The trial in Donetsk
At the end of April the DPR's prosecutor-general labelled the men "mercenaries". Charges were announced on 6 June, and the case went before the DPR's so-called Supreme Court, under Judge Aleksandr Nikulin, on 7 June. The proceedings lasted only a few days. On 9 June all three were convicted and sentenced to death.
According to the Russian state news agency RIA Novosti, the men had pleaded guilty to charges that included acting as mercenaries, terrorism, being part of a criminal group, and attempting to seize power by force. Those charges matter because of how international law works: a lawful soldier cannot be punished simply for fighting, but a mercenary is not guaranteed prisoner-of-war status. Calling the men mercenaries was the legal device that allowed the court to treat them as criminals rather than as captured soldiers.
It remains unclear how much independent legal help the men had, and the court itself is not recognised by Ukraine, the United Kingdom or the United Nations. The DPR leader, Denis Pushilin, said on 12 June that he saw no grounds for a pardon. A defence appeal was lodged in early July.
Why the sentences were called illegal
The Third Geneva Convention of 1949 protects members of a state's armed forces who are captured in war. Such prisoners enjoy what lawyers call combatant immunity: they may be tried for war crimes, but not for the simple act of taking part in hostilities. Aslin and Pinner were enlisted members of Ukraine's marines, wore uniform, and served in a formal chain of command, which places them squarely within the convention's definition of a prisoner of war.
The mercenary label does not fit easily either. Under the definition used in international humanitarian law, a mercenary is someone who is neither a national nor a resident of a party to the conflict and who fights mainly for private gain. Both British men had lived in Ukraine for years before the invasion, a point their families and supporters repeatedly stressed.
The United Nations human rights office said that trials of prisoners of war that fail to meet basic fair-trial guarantees amount to a war crime.
How London reacted
The British government's response was immediate and unusually blunt. Then Foreign Secretary Liz Truss called the men prisoners of war and said: "This is a sham judgment with absolutely no legitimacy." Government spokespeople stressed that captured soldiers are entitled to combatant immunity and should not be prosecuted for fighting, and said the UK would keep working with Kyiv to free any British nationals held as prisoners.
Robert Jenrick, the Conservative MP for Newark and Aslin's local member of parliament, described the proceedings as a Soviet-style show trial and urged the Foreign Office to summon the Russian ambassador. He argued that both men had been living in Ukraine and serving in its forces long before the invasion and therefore could not be called mercenaries.
The case also put a spotlight on British policy toward volunteers. In the first days of the war Truss had said she would support people who chose to go and fight. The government soon moved away from that, repeating its advice against travelling to Ukraine and warning that volunteers could break UK law. Aslin and Pinner, however, were not new volunteers: both were already serving soldiers.
The prisoner swap that freed them
For three months the families had little information beyond occasional calls in which the men said they were being pressed to hurry their governments. Then, on 21 September 2022, Saudi Arabia announced that ten foreign prisoners had been released after mediation by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. Five were British: Aslin, Pinner, Dylan Healy, John Harding and Andrew Hill. The others were Brahim Saadoun, two Americans, a Croatian and a Swede.
The foreigners were part of the largest exchange of the war up to that point. Ukraine recovered 215 of its soldiers, including several commanders who had led the defence of Mariupol. In return Russia received 55 troops and the pro-Kremlin Ukrainian politician Viktor Medvedchuk, who had been facing treason charges in Ukraine. Turkey also helped broker the deal. The British men landed at Heathrow on 22 September and were reunited with their families.
After his release Aslin said he had been beaten and mistreated in captivity. He later spoke publicly about his experience, reportedly returned to military service, and in 2025 was granted Ukrainian citizenship.
What the case shows about prisoners in this war
The Aslin, Pinner and Saadoun case became an early test of how Russia and its proxies would treat foreigners serving in Ukraine's forces. Three patterns stand out. First, the "mercenary" label was used to strip captured soldiers of the protections they would otherwise have. Second, the trials were held by authorities that most of the world does not recognise, which made normal diplomatic and consular channels almost useless. Third, the outcome was decided not by any appeal court but by political bargaining, with third countries acting as go-betweens.
For readers following prisoner-of-war cases today, the lesson is to separate three stages that headlines often blur: the announcement of a charge or sentence, the international response, and what actually happens to the prisoner later. In this case a death sentence made headlines around the world, yet all three men walked free a little over three months later.
Quick answers
Were Aiden Aslin and Shaun Pinner executed?
No. Both were released alive in the September 2022 exchange and returned to the UK.
Which court sentenced them?
The self-declared "Supreme Court" of the Donetsk People's Republic, a body set up by Russian-backed authorities in occupied eastern Ukraine.
Is it legal to put prisoners of war on trial for fighting?
No. Under the Geneva Conventions captured soldiers may be tried only for war crimes, not for lawful participation in combat.
Sources: The Guardian, 9 June 2022; Al Jazeera, 22 September 2022; Wikipedia: Aiden Aslin; Wikipedia: Prisoner of war. Photo: image from the Donetsk courtroom shared on Telegram.

COMMENTS