Originally published 2022-05-26.

On 24 May 2022, speaking on the sidelines of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, billionaire investor and philanthropist George Soros warned that Russia's invasion of Ukraine "may have been the beginning of the third world war and our civilisation may not survive it." He argued that the best, and perhaps only, way to protect civilisation was to defeat Vladimir Putin as soon as possible.
The line made headlines around the world, but it was one part of a longer argument about a global contest between open and closed societies, with sharp criticism of China's Xi Jinping and of Germany's energy policy under Angela Merkel. Here is what Soros actually said, what was behind it, and how his predictions look with hindsight.
Open societies versus closed societies
The core of the speech was a theme Soros has returned to for decades. Borrowing the language of the philosopher Karl Popper, he described the world as divided between two opposing systems of government: open societies, where the state protects individual freedom, and closed societies, where individuals serve the rulers. In his view, repressive regimes were gaining ground and open societies were under pressure.
He placed much of the blame on technology. According to Euronews, he said artificial intelligence is especially good at creating tools of control that help repressive regimes, and that Covid-19 had helped normalise surveillance measures because they were useful against the virus. The invasion of Ukraine, he argued, did not come out of the blue but grew out of that wider struggle.
What Soros said about Putin and Ukraine
Soros said Putin had expected Russian troops to be welcomed as liberators in Ukraine and instead met fierce resistance from Ukrainians and found his own army demoralised. He referred to the destruction of Mariupol and the killings of civilians in Bucha, and said Putin could not be trusted, making a ceasefire unlikely.
His "third world war" remark was a warning, not a forecast with a date or a probability attached. He did not say that a wider war had begun in the military sense, but that the invasion could prove to be the opening of a broader conflict between the two systems of government he described. He tied this to another danger, arguing that the war had pushed climate action aside at a time when climate change was close to becoming irreversible.
Europe, Merkel and Russian gas
Soros had some praise for Europe. He said the European Union had responded to the invasion with more speed, unity and energy than at any point in its history. But he argued that the continent was still far too dependent on Russian fossil fuels, and that Putin could cut gas supplies to cause maximum pain.
He laid much of the responsibility on former German chancellor Angela Merkel. In his telling, her special gas deals with Russia and the decision to make China Germany's largest export market made Germany Europe's strongest economy for a time, but left it exposed. Germany's economy, he said, would need to be reoriented, which would take years. He credited her successor, Olaf Scholz, with breaking from that course over the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, defence spending and weapons for Ukraine.
Events later in 2022 partly bore this out. Russian gas flows to Europe fell sharply, the Nord Stream pipelines were damaged by underwater explosions in September 2022, and energy prices surged across the continent before Europe found alternative suppliers.
His warnings about Xi Jinping and China
Soros devoted a large part of the speech to China. He argued that Xi had let Putin take the lead in their partnership, and that Xi's zero-Covid policy, with its sweeping lockdowns, had sent the Chinese economy into "free fall". Combined with China's real estate crisis and disrupted supply chains, he warned, the damage could spread into the global economy and turn inflation into a worldwide depression.
He also claimed that Xi "harbours a guilty secret": that Chinese people had been given vaccines designed for the original Wuhan variant which, in his words, offered very little protection against newer variants. That claim needs context. Data from Hong Kong's 2022 Omicron wave showed that two doses of the Chinese-made CoronaVac vaccine gave older adults about 70% protection against severe disease or death, and three doses raised that to about 98%, matching the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine. Protection against infection was much weaker for both vaccines. The real problem in mainland China was low booster uptake among the elderly, not that the vaccine did nothing.
How his predictions look in hindsight
Some of Soros's warnings were borne out and others were not. On Xi, Soros suggested in the speech that internal dissent might stop him winning a third term. In fact, on 23 October 2022, the Communist Party's Central Committee elected Xi to an unprecedented third five-year term as general secretary.
On zero-Covid, he was right that the policy was unsustainable. After nationwide protests in late November 2022, China dropped most of its rules from 7 December 2022, becoming the last major country to abandon the strategy. On the global economy, inflation did surge in 2022 and central banks raised interest rates sharply, but the worldwide depression he feared did not happen.
As for a third world war, the war in Ukraine has continued for years with enormous losses, and fears of escalation between Russia and NATO have remained real, but it has not become a global war between the major powers.
Who George Soros is
Soros was born György Schwartz in Budapest in 1930 and survived the Nazi occupation of Hungary as a teenager, his Jewish family living under false Christian identity papers. He emigrated to Britain and later the United States, where he built the Quantum Fund into one of the most successful hedge funds in history. In 1992 he became known as "the man who broke the Bank of England" after betting more than $10 billion against the pound and reportedly earning over $1 billion.
He has given more than $32 billion to his Open Society Foundations, which fund democracy, human rights and education projects around the world. That work has made him a target. In his native Hungary, the government of Viktor Orbán has attacked him in billboard and "Stop Soros" campaigns that Jewish groups criticised as antisemitic, and the Central European University he founded moved most of its teaching from Budapest to Vienna after a law targeted it. Far-right conspiracy theories that cast him as a hidden "puppet master" have been widely condemned as antisemitic, and in 2018 a pipe bomb was sent to his home in New York.
How to read speeches like this
Davos speeches by prominent figures tend to be quoted in fragments, which can make them sound either more alarming or more certain than they were. The fair reading of Soros's 2022 remarks is that he presented a political argument: that the war was part of a struggle between democratic and authoritarian systems, and that the West should do everything it could to help Ukraine win. Whether or not you share his views, the most useful approach is to check the full text, separate the speaker's opinions from verifiable facts, and look at what actually happened next.
Sources: Daily Maverick: Full text of George Soros's Davos speech; Euronews: Soros blames AI and new tech; The Guardian: Ukraine invasion may be start of third world war, says Soros; AFP via Philstar: Xi secures historic third term; Wikipedia: CoronaVac; Wikipedia: Zero-COVID; Wikipedia: George Soros.

COMMENTS