Amnesty Urges Israel to Scrap Eviction of Negev Bedouin Village

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-23.

Amnesty Urges Israel to Scrap Eviction of Negev Bedouin Village

In May 2022 Amnesty International called on Israel to cancel eviction and demolition orders against Ras Jrabah, a small Bedouin village in the Negev desert (known in Arabic as the Naqab). About 500 people live there. The authorities planned to clear the land for the growth of the nearby town of Dimona and to move the residents to a separate Bedouin locality, and a group of villagers was about to challenge the plan in court.

The case was small in numbers but it touched a long-running issue: the status of Bedouin citizens of Israel who live in villages the state has never formally recognised. Here is what was at stake, what each side argued and why the dispute keeps coming back.

What Amnesty asked for

Amnesty's statement urged the Israeli authorities to drop every eviction and demolition order against Ras Jrabah and to grant legal recognition to all the unrecognised Bedouin villages in the Negev. According to the organisation, 127 residents had joined a legal challenge against the eviction, with a hearing expected shortly after the statement was published.

Saleh Higazi, Amnesty's deputy director for the Middle East and North Africa, framed the case in the strongest terms, saying: “This eviction plan is steeped in the cruelty of apartheid.” He argued that the families risked losing the only homes they had known and being moved to a poorer location kept apart from Jewish Israeli neighbourhoods.

Amnesty also described displacement as a key tool of control over Palestinians across Israel and the occupied territories, and criticised Israeli courts for, in its view, endorsing discriminatory policies. Those are Amnesty's assessments, and they echo a major report the group had released a few months earlier.

Who lives in Ras Jrabah

Ras Jrabah sits on the edge of Dimona, a development town founded in 1955 about 30 kilometres south-east of Beersheba. Today Dimona has around 40,000 residents, mostly Jewish Israelis, and it is best known abroad for the nuclear research centre in the desert to its south-east.

The village's residents are Bedouin Arabs who hold Israeli citizenship. Because the state does not recognise Ras Jrabah as a legal community, its homes are considered unauthorised and it is not connected to the services that recognised towns receive. For the people living there, the issue is not abstract. One resident told Amnesty: “We can't move to a different place. Our whole lives are based here, in this location.” Villagers described feeling anxious about the court process and preparing as best they could.

The unrecognised villages of the Negev

Ras Jrabah is one of dozens of similar communities. Estimates vary depending on how a “village” is counted, but advocacy groups such as the Association of Forty have listed around 35 to 60 unrecognised Bedouin villages in the Negev, home to tens of thousands of people. Some studies put the share of Negev Bedouin living in such villages at close to half.

Being unrecognised has concrete consequences:

  • No connection to the national electricity grid or mains water, or only limited and informal connections.
  • No regular rubbish collection, sewage system or paved roads.
  • No local council, so residents cannot elect their own municipal representatives.
  • Homes and structures built without permits that can be issued demolition orders at any time.

How the land dispute began

The roots go back more than a century. Under Ottoman and British rule, most Bedouin families did not register their land, partly to avoid taxes and conscription, and relied instead on customary ownership. After the 1948 war, in which most of the Negev's Bedouin population fled or was expelled, only around 11,000 to 12,000 remained inside Israel. Many were moved into a restricted zone east of Beersheba under military rule until 1966.

Israel later classified most of the Negev as state land. Courts have generally rejected Bedouin ownership claims that lack registration documents, and thousands of land claims remain unresolved. From the late 1960s the state built seven planned Bedouin townships, including Rahat, the largest, and encouraged families to move into them. Many residents say those towns were planned without adequate jobs or land for traditional livelihoods, and they remain among the poorest localities in the country.

What the Israeli authorities argue

Israeli officials have generally presented cases like Ras Jrabah as a matter of planning and land law rather than ethnicity. The state's position is that the land belongs to the state, that the structures were built without permits, and that residents are offered plots and housing in recognised Bedouin localities with services. Officials also point to development budgets aimed at Bedouin towns.

Israel's government rejected Amnesty's February 2022 report, which accused the country of maintaining a system of apartheid over Palestinians, calling it false and biased. Other human rights groups, including Human Rights Watch and the Israeli organisation B'Tselem, had reached similar conclusions to Amnesty in their own reports, while many Israeli and international critics dispute the apartheid framework entirely.

Earlier government efforts, such as the Prawer Plan approved in 2011, proposed moving tens of thousands of Negev Bedouin into recognised towns in exchange for compensation. The plan drew large protests and was shelved in 2013, but the questions it raised have never been settled.

Why “forced transfer” is a legal term, not just a phrase

When Amnesty speaks of forcible transfer, it is drawing on international human rights law. The UN has long held that evictions must be a last resort, carried out only after genuine consultation, with adequate alternative housing and access to legal remedies. Moving people mainly along ethnic lines, or in a way that leaves them worse off, can breach a state's obligations under treaties such as the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.

In practice, the arguments over Ras Jrabah came down to a few questions that apply to many Negev villages:

  • Did residents have a real say in where they would be moved, and on what terms?
  • Would the new location offer equal services, jobs and space, or simply concentrate poverty?
  • Could the expansion of Dimona have been planned to include the existing village instead of replacing it?

What to watch for next

We were not able to confirm the final outcome of the 2022 court proceedings in Ras Jrabah, so readers following the case should check recent reporting from Israeli courts, Amnesty International or local organisations such as Adalah and the Negev Coexistence Forum. Rulings in these cases can take years, and partial agreements are common.

The larger issue will remain whatever happens in a single courtroom. Tens of thousands of Bedouin citizens still live in places the state does not recognise, and each new development plan in the Negev raises the same question: whether growth can be shared with the people already living on the land rather than built on top of them.

Sources: Amnesty International (May 2022); Wikipedia: Unrecognized Bedouin villages in Israel; Wikipedia: Dimona.

COMMENTS