Originally published 2022-05-22.

In May 2022, three months into Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Sir Richard Dearlove, the former head of Britain's foreign intelligence service MI6, predicted that Vladimir Putin would be out of power by 2023. He suggested Putin was seriously ill and would be quietly moved to a sanatorium, a way for Russia's elite to replace him without a formal coup. The prediction did not come true. Putin remained in office, won another presidential election in March 2024 and was sworn in for a fifth term in May 2024.
The episode is worth revisiting because it shows how claims about a leader's health travel, why they are so hard to verify, and why even very senior former officials can get them wrong.
Who Richard Dearlove is
Dearlove joined MI6, formally the Secret Intelligence Service, in 1966 and served in Nairobi, Prague, Paris, Geneva and Washington. He rose to director of operations and was Chief of the service, known as "C", from 1999 to 2004. After leaving he spent eleven years as Master of Pembroke College, Cambridge, and became a regular commentator on security and geopolitics, including on the One Decision podcast, where he made the Putin prediction.
His career also includes a well-known lesson in the limits of intelligence. He led MI6 during the build-up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq, and the 2016 Chilcot inquiry criticised him for passing unverified intelligence from an Iraqi source directly to Prime Minister Tony Blair. That source was later found to have been lying.
What he predicted in May 2022
Speaking on the podcast, as first reported by the Daily Mirror, Dearlove made three linked claims. First, that Putin's health was in serious decline. Second, that the war in Ukraine was a military fiasco, with sanctions about to bite and inflation set to soar. Third, that within around a year to 18 months, those pressures would cause the regime to break apart.
His central forecast was specific:
"I think he'll be gone by 2023 - but probably into the sanatorium, from which he will not emerge as the leader of Russia."
He said he believed Russian expert opinion, though not yet public opinion, was beginning to turn against the war. On health, he claimed Putin was constantly accompanied by doctors and that televised security council meetings were broken up so he could receive treatment. He admitted that it was not clear how serious or terminal the illness was.
Where the health rumours came from
Rumours about Putin's health have circulated for about two decades. Over the years he has been said to have thyroid cancer, blood cancer, abdominal cancer, Parkinson's disease and the after-effects of a stroke, and in October 2023 a Russian Telegram channel even claimed he had died and been replaced by a body double.
Most of these claims rest on what is known as Kremlinology: studying video of public appearances for signs of decline, such as a puffy face, a stiff walk or a hand gripping a table. In spring 2022 his long-distance meetings, with guests seated at the far end of a very long table, fuelled speculation that he was protecting a weak immune system. A different explanation was simply his extreme caution about Covid-19.
Some apparent "symptoms" have more mundane causes. A 2015 study in the BMJ noted that Putin, like several other Russian officials, tends to walk with his right arm held still. The researchers linked this "gunslinger's gait" to Soviet-era KGB weapons training, which taught officers to keep their right hand close to the chest, rather than to illness.
What officials said at the time
The Kremlin, through spokesman Dmitry Peskov and Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, repeatedly denied that Putin was ill. More tellingly, Western intelligence chiefs who were in office, rather than retired, did not back the rumours. CIA Director William Burns remarked that Putin was, if anything, "entirely too healthy", and the then head of MI6, Richard Moore, said there was no evidence of serious illness.
The Russian political scientist Valery Solovei made similar predictions. He forecast in 2017 and again in 2020 that Putin would step down for health reasons, and neither forecast came true.
What actually happened
Instead of being removed, Putin tightened his control. The Russian economy proved more resilient to sanctions than many Western analysts had expected, helped by energy exports to Asia and a shift to a war economy. The most serious internal challenge came in June 2023, when the Wagner mercenary group led by Yevgeny Prigozhin staged a brief armed mutiny and marched towards Moscow before standing down; Prigozhin was killed in a plane crash two months later.
In March 2024 Putin won a presidential election that was tightly controlled, with two anti-war candidates barred from standing. On 7 May 2024 he was sworn in at the Grand Kremlin Palace for a fifth term, which runs to 2030.
How to read predictions about authoritarian leaders
None of this means Dearlove's analysis of the war's costs was baseless; Russia's losses have been enormous. But his forecast mixed a real assessment of strain with unverified claims about one man's body, and attached a firm deadline. A few habits help when you read similar stories:
- Check who is speaking. A former official is offering opinion, not current intelligence. Serving officials are usually more cautious.
- Look for named, checkable evidence. Video "symptoms" and anonymous insiders are weak foundations for a medical diagnosis.
- Notice the deadline. Specific dates make a claim more newsworthy, and also easy to test later.
- Remember how closed systems work. Leaders of tightly controlled states hide weakness well, which cuts both ways: we cannot rule illness out, but we also cannot confirm it.
For a similar claim from the same month, see our piece on the anonymous FSB source who said Putin had two to three years to live.
Sources: Wikipedia: Richard Dearlove; Wikipedia: Health of Vladimir Putin; Al Jazeera, 7 May 2024: Putin sworn in for a record fifth term. Dearlove's comments were first reported by the Daily Mirror.

COMMENTS