Amnesty's 2021 Plea to Reject the US Appeal Against Assange

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-11-22.

Amnesty's 2021 Position on Assange's Extradition

In October 2021, as the United States asked London's High Court to overturn a ruling that had blocked Julian Assange's extradition, Amnesty International publicly urged the judges to throw the appeal out. Its Secretary General, Agnès Callamard, called the US case against the WikiLeaks founder politically motivated and said the charges should be dropped altogether.

The appeal succeeded at the time. The story did not end there, though: after more than five years in a British prison, Assange agreed a plea deal with US prosecutors in June 2024 and flew home to Australia. Here is what Amnesty argued, why the case mattered to press-freedom groups, and how it finally concluded.

Who Julian Assange is and why the US wanted him

Assange, an Australian, founded WikiLeaks, which published secret documents leaked by insiders. Its best-known releases came in 2010, with material provided by US Army intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning: hundreds of thousands of classified military and diplomatic records about the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the "Collateral Murder" video, which showed a 2007 US helicopter attack in Baghdad in which civilians, including two Reuters journalists, were killed.

US prosecutors brought a computer-intrusion charge in 2019 and later added charges under the Espionage Act of 1917. By 2022 he faced 18 counts linked to the release of roughly half a million secret files, with a theoretical maximum of 175 years in prison, though the realistic sentence was hard to predict. The US argued the publications endangered informants and service members; Assange and WikiLeaks rejected that.

Assange had spent nearly seven years inside Ecuador's embassy in London after entering it in June 2012, until British police arrested him there on 11 April 2019. He was then held at HM Prison Belmarsh while the extradition fight played out.

The January 2021 ruling the US appealed

On 4 January 2021, District Judge Vanessa Baraitser refused to send Assange to the United States. Her reason was narrow: she found that his mental health and the conditions he was likely to face in US custody created a real risk of suicide, making extradition "oppressive" under British law. On the other arguments raised by his defence, including that the prosecution was political and threatened free expression, she ruled against him.

The US government appealed, offering diplomatic assurances about how Assange would be treated if extradited. That appeal is what Amnesty set out to oppose.

What Amnesty International argued

In a statement released on 25 October 2021, two days before the High Court hearing began, Callamard made three main points:

  • The US assurances could not be trusted. Washington had said Assange would not be held in a maximum-security prison or placed under the restrictive regime known as Special Administrative Measures, but it had also reserved the right to change course. Amnesty said this undermined the guarantees.
  • The case was political. Callamard pointed to news reports that CIA officials had discussed kidnapping or even killing Assange, and argued these deepened doubts about US good faith.
  • Press freedom was at stake. Amnesty noted that almost no one had been held to account for alleged US war crimes in Afghanistan and Iraq, while the publisher who exposed them faced decades behind bars.

Her conclusion was blunt: "This disingenuous appeal should be denied, the charges should be dropped, and Julian Assange should be released."

The reports about CIA plots

The claim about the CIA came from investigative reporting published in 2021. According to that reporting, senior CIA officials, angered by WikiLeaks' 2017 "Vault 7" publication of the agency's hacking tools, reportedly discussed options including abducting or assassinating Assange during the Trump administration. The plans were never carried out, and US officials did not confirm the account in detail. The reports remain allegations, but they were widely cited by Assange's lawyers and supporters as evidence that he could not expect fair treatment.

Why press-freedom groups cared

For Amnesty and many journalists' organisations, the central worry was precedent. Much of what Assange was accused of, receiving secret material from a source and publishing it, describes something investigative reporters do routinely. Using the Espionage Act against a publisher, critics argued, could chill reporting on national security everywhere, not just in the United States.

Supporters of the prosecution saw it differently, arguing that WikiLeaks published unredacted names and went beyond ordinary journalism. That disagreement, over where publishing ends and harmful disclosure begins, is the reason the case drew so much attention far beyond Assange himself.

Amnesty framed its objection in human rights terms rather than as a defence of everything WikiLeaks did. Its statement focused on two things: the charges themselves, which it saw as punishing publication, and the risk of ill-treatment in US custody, which it argued the American assurances did not remove. Together, it said, these made the extradition incompatible with the UK's human rights obligations.

What happened next

On 10 December 2021, the High Court sided with the United States. The judges accepted the new US assurances that Assange would not be held in harsh isolation in a federal supermax prison and would receive proper care, describing them as "solemn undertakings offered by one government to another." In January 2022 the court considered whether he could take points of law to the UK Supreme Court, and the legal battle continued for more than two years.

In 2024 Assange won permission to challenge parts of the earlier ruling, but before that appeal was heard he reached a deal with US prosecutors. He was granted bail and left Belmarsh on 24 June 2024, after 1,901 days there, according to WikiLeaks. In a court in Saipan, in the US Northern Mariana Islands, he pleaded guilty to a single Espionage Act charge of conspiring to obtain and disclose classified national defence information. He was sentenced to the time he had already served and landed in Australia on 26 June 2024.

Amnesty's 2021 appeal did not stop the extradition ruling, but the case ended without Assange ever being sent to the United States for trial.

Sources: Amnesty International UK, 25 October 2021: Julian Assange's politically motivated extradition must not go ahead; AFP via The Business Standard, 24 January 2022: UK court to rule on Assange extradition case; Express & Star (PA), 25 June 2024: Julian Assange leaves UK after reaching plea deal with US; Wikipedia: Julian Assange.

COMMENTS