Originally published 2022-04-24.

When Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine sent families fleeing west in early 2022, Jan Gebert, a 42-year-old Jewish resident of Warsaw, did not wait to be asked. He opened his own flat to Ukrainians who needed somewhere to sleep. Speaking to CNN that April, he explained the decision through his family's past: his relatives lived through the Holocaust because other people were willing to shelter them, and he felt that debt had now come due.
His story is small in scale, one apartment in one city, but it touches some of the largest themes of modern European history: persecution, rescue, memory and what a person owes to strangers. Here is what happened, the history behind it, and why the comparison he draws is both moving and carefully limited.
A Warsaw apartment opened to people fleeing the war
Gebert's offer came in the first weeks of the war, when trains and buses were bringing exhausted women, children and older people across the border every day. He told CNN that the flat is modest and holds everything he owns, yet he felt he had no real choice. He was not sure whether the impulse came from faith or from tradition, only that he had to act.
The help did not stop with him. According to the same report, his elderly father also took refugees into his home, so two generations of one family became hosts at once.
In his words, the link to the past is direct:
"My family survived the war because someone helped them. They were refugees."
He went on to imagine what his family might look like today if more of his ancestors and cousins had been hidden in time: a large Jewish family in Warsaw, gathered around the same table. That picture explains his motive better than any slogan could. Helping now is a way of honouring the people who helped then, and of grieving the relatives nobody saved.
Why the Holocaust still shapes Polish Jewish families
Before the Second World War, Poland had one of the largest Jewish communities in the world, roughly 3.3 million people. Germany invaded in September 1939, and during the occupation about three million Polish Jews were murdered, around 90 per cent of the community. Across Europe, the Nazi regime and its collaborators killed about six million Jews.
For the families who did survive, the story is often one of hiding: in a neighbour's attic, on a farm, behind a false identity, or passed from one helper to the next. That is why survival and rescue are so closely tied together in Polish Jewish memory. Almost every survivor owed their life to someone else's courage, and almost every family also lost people who were turned away or betrayed.
Gebert's comment about the "great big family" he never had captures this double inheritance. Gratitude and loss sit side by side.
The rabbi's careful distinction: hosting is not the same as hiding
Poland's Chief Rabbi, Michael Schudrich, an American-born rabbi who has led the community since 2004, told CNN that he welcomed the response but cautioned against equating today's hosts with wartime rescuers. In his view:
"We're doing nothing compared to what these truly righteous people did during the war."
The history supports him. In occupied Poland, the German governor Hans Frank introduced the death penalty on 15 October 1941 not only for Jews who left the ghettos but also for anyone who knowingly hid them. Hiding a Jewish family could cost the rescuer, and often the rescuer's own relatives, their lives.
Yad Vashem, Israel's Holocaust remembrance centre, honours such people as Righteous Among the Nations. As of 1 January 2022, it had recognised 7,232 Poles, more than a quarter of all those honoured worldwide. The underground Council for Aid to Jews, known by the codename Żegota and founded in 1942, is estimated to have helped tens of thousands of people survive; Irena Sendler led its children's section.
Schudrich's point was not that modern help is unimportant. It was that the moral lesson runs in a specific direction. As he put it, "It's our time to do what we needed to have done for us 80 years ago." Rather than nursing bitterness that too few helped back then, he urged people to let that sadness push them toward doing more now.
How Poland responded in the spring of 2022
Gebert was part of a much wider wave. Poland, which shares a long border with Ukraine, became one of the main destinations for people escaping the war. Local authorities offered free housing, food and supplies, reception points opened across the country, and many ordinary citizens offered rooms in their own homes rather than leaving everything to the state.
The scale changed Polish cities almost overnight. By 1 April 2022, Ukrainians, including those who had arrived before the war, were estimated to make up between 15 and 30 per cent of the population of the largest cities. In Wrocław, their share reportedly rose from about 10 per cent to 23 per cent in a matter of weeks. By the end of that July, more than 1.2 million Ukrainian refugees had been recorded in Poland, and across Europe the total reached millions.
Private hosting made a real difference in those first weeks, when official shelters were overwhelmed. It also came with challenges that hosts learned about quickly: language barriers, trauma, and the question of what happens when a short stay turns into months.
The Jewish community in Poland today
A figure often repeated is that fewer than 10,000 Jews live in Poland today. The real number depends heavily on how Jewish identity is counted. At the 2021 national census, 17,156 people in Poland declared a Jewish identity, and community and academic estimates vary further, since many families hid or lost their heritage during the war and the communist decades that followed. Either way, the community is a small fraction of what it was before 1939, which is part of why individual acts like Gebert's draw attention.
That small community still carries an outsized memory. Many Polish Jews grew up hearing about the neighbour who brought bread to a hiding place, or the one who reported a family to the authorities. Both kinds of story shape how people respond when a new group of refugees appears at the door.
What this story offers anyone who wants to help
Most people will never be asked to risk their lives for a stranger. Stories like this one suggest a quieter test: whether we use the safety we have been given to make room for someone else. A few practical lessons follow from the experience of hosts in 2022:
- Work with established organisations. Refugee agencies and local charities can match hosts with guests, check safety on both sides and offer translation and legal help.
- Think beyond the first night. Shelter is urgent, but people also need schools, work, healthcare and paperwork. Help that lasts months is often more valuable than a dramatic gesture.
- Respect people's stories. Guests may not want to talk about what they have lost. Privacy and patience are part of hospitality.
- Donate thoughtfully. Money to reputable groups usually goes further than collections of goods that may not be needed.
Above all, Gebert's account shows how family memory can become a moral compass. The people who sheltered his relatives could not have known that, generations later, their courage would open a door in Warsaw to families fleeing another war. Kindness, once given, has a long reach.
Sources: Original reporting and quotes: CNN, 11 April 2022. Background: History of the Jews in Poland, Polish Righteous Among the Nations, Michael Schudrich and Ukrainian refugee crisis (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS