Originally published 2022-04-25.
On 21 April 2022, the parliaments of Estonia and Latvia adopted statements declaring that Russia's actions in Ukraine amounted to genocide against the Ukrainian people. Estonia's Riigikogu passed its statement unanimously, and Latvia's Saeima approved a similar text on the same day. The Estonian statement pointed to atrocities in Bucha, Borodyanka, Hostomel, Irpin and Mariupol, and named killings, deportations, torture and rape among the acts it considered genocidal.
These were political declarations, not court rulings. They expressed how two of Russia's neighbours read the evidence emerging from occupied areas, eight weeks after the full-scale invasion began on 24 February 2022. Whether genocide in the legal sense has been committed is a question for international courts, and it is a far higher bar than proving war crimes.
What the two parliaments said
The Riigikogu heard from Olena Shuliak, who led a visiting Ukrainian parliamentary delegation, before voting. Its statement listed abuses against civilians, which Reuters summarised as murders, enforced disappearances, deportations, imprisonment, torture, rape, and desecration of corpses
.
Latvia's statement condemned the invasion as an attack on Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity. On the same day, the Saeima also amended its citizenship law so that people who give substantial support to states or groups responsible for war crimes, genocide or crimes against humanity could lose Latvian citizenship.
The votes came as the Baltic states and Moscow were expelling each other's diplomats. Estonia and Latvia had already sent home Russian staff, and Russia soon closed Latvian and Estonian consulates in St Petersburg and Pskov in response.
Why the Baltic states reacted so strongly
Estonia and Latvia share a border with Russia and, like Ukraine, were part of the Soviet Union until they regained independence in 1991. Their own histories include Soviet mass deportations of civilians to Siberia and other remote regions in the 1940s, which both countries remember as crimes against their nations. Seeing reports of Ukrainians being filtered and deported to Russia struck a raw nerve.
Unlike Ukraine, both countries joined NATO and the European Union in 2004. That gives them collective defence guarantees, but it has not removed fear of Russian pressure, particularly given their sizeable Russian-speaking minorities, which Moscow has long cited when criticising their governments.
What "genocide" means in international law
A common mistake, repeated in many news reports at the time, is to describe genocide simply as a type of war crime. In law it is a separate crime, defined in the 1948 Genocide Convention, and it can be committed in peacetime as well as in war.
Under Article II of the Convention, genocide means certain acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. The listed acts are killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, imposing living conditions meant to destroy the group, preventing births, and forcibly transferring the group's children to another group.
The hardest element to prove is intent. Courts look for evidence that the goal was to destroy the group as such, not only to win a war or terrorise a population. That is why lawyers often say war crimes and crimes against humanity are easier to establish than genocide, even when the underlying atrocities are equally terrible.
Leaders who used the word, and those who did not
US President Joe Biden first used the term on 12 April 2022, saying Putin appeared to be trying to erase the very idea of being Ukrainian, while adding that lawyers would decide internationally whether it met the legal test. His national security adviser Jake Sullivan was more cautious, saying the US had seen atrocities and war crimes but not yet the level of systematic killing that would amount to genocide.
French President Emmanuel Macron declined to use the word on 13 April, saying he wanted to be careful with terms and that escalating rhetoric would not help end the war, while still accusing the Russian army of war crimes. Zelensky criticised that stance. Ukraine's own parliament had adopted a genocide resolution on 14 April, and Poland's Sejm had passed a resolution condemning acts of genocide in March. Over the following months, one chamber of the legislatures in Canada, the Czech Republic and Ireland also used the term.
The word carries extra weight here because Putin himself had claimed, without credible evidence, that Ukraine was committing "genocide" against Russian speakers in the Donbas, and used that claim to justify the invasion.
What courts and investigators have done since
Ukraine went to the International Court of Justice on 26 February 2022, arguing that Russia had falsely invoked the Genocide Convention to justify an attack. On 16 March 2022 the court ordered Russia to suspend its military operations, an order Russia ignored. In a February 2024 judgment on jurisdiction, the court narrowed the case to Ukraine's request for a declaration that it had not committed genocide in the Donbas.
The International Criminal Court took a different route. On 17 March 2023 it issued arrest warrants for Putin and for Maria Lvova-Belova, Russia's children's rights commissioner, over the unlawful deportation and transfer of Ukrainian children. Those warrants concern war crimes, not genocide. Separately, a May 2022 report by dozens of legal and genocide experts, published by the New Lines Institute and the Raoul Wallenberg Centre, concluded there were reasonable grounds to believe Russia had incited genocide and that the forcible transfer of children could qualify as a genocidal act.
Why parliamentary declarations still matter
A resolution in Tallinn or Riga cannot convict anyone. What it can do is signal political will: to support investigations, preserve evidence, back sanctions and push for accountability once the fighting ends. For small states next door to Russia, it was also a statement about how they understand their own history and security.
For readers trying to make sense of the headlines, the useful distinction is between three things: what governments and parliaments say, what investigators document on the ground, and what courts eventually decide. All three matter, but only the last produces a legal finding.
Sources: The Insider, 21 April 2022; Wikipedia: Allegations of genocide of Ukrainians in the Russo-Ukrainian war; original reporting credited to Reuters, 21 April 2022 and Reuters, 12 April 2022.

COMMENTS