Originally published 2022-04-24.

In April 2022, within two days of each other, two wealthy former Russian gas executives were found dead alongside their wives and daughters. Vladislav Avayev, a 51-year-old former vice-president of Gazprombank, was found on 18 April in his Moscow apartment with his wife and 13-year-old daughter. On 19 April, Sergey Protosenya, a 55-year-old former deputy chairman of the gas producer Novatek, was found at a rented villa in Lloret de Mar on Spain's Catalan coast, with his wife and 18-year-old daughter dead inside. In both cases, investigators said the scene pointed to a murder-suicide.
Coming weeks after Russia's invasion of Ukraine and a wave of Western sanctions, the deaths quickly fed suspicion that something else was going on. Here is what was reported, what investigators said, and what remains unknown.
The Avayev deaths in Moscow
Avayev had worked in the Kremlin administration before moving into banking, eventually becoming a vice-president of Gazprombank, the lender closely tied to the state gas giant Gazprom. According to Newsweek's account of Russian reports, his 26-year-old daughter Anastasia found the bodies after she could not reach the family.
Russian media reported that Avayev was found with a pistol in his hand, and the authorities treated the case as a murder-suicide. A former Gazprombank colleague, Igor Volobuyev, who left Russia after the invasion, later told the investigative outlet The Insider that he suspected the scene had been staged, possibly because Avayev knew something sensitive. That remained his opinion; no evidence was published to support it.
The Protosenya deaths in Spain
Protosenya had spent nearly two decades at Novatek, Russia's largest private producer of liquefied natural gas, working there from 1997 to 2015. Catalan regional police, the Mossos d'Esquadra, said his wife Natalya and daughter Maria had been stabbed, and that he was found hanged at the property. They said they suspected he had killed his family and then himself. The family was reportedly on an Easter holiday.
The alarm was raised by his son Fedor, who was in France and could not reach his parents. He rejected the official theory outright. "My father is not a killer," he told the Daily Mail, adding that his father loved his mother and sister and could never have harmed them.
Some details reported in the Spanish press added to the doubts. The Catalan paper El Punt Avui reported that no fingerprints had been found on the weapons and no blood on Protosenya's body. These points were reported rather than officially confirmed, and Spanish investigators did not publicly endorse any alternative explanation.
How Novatek responded
Protosenya's former employer issued a statement praising him as a devoted family man and a strong professional who had helped build the company. It said media speculation about his death was "not related to reality" and called on Spanish law enforcement to carry out a thorough and objective investigation.
Why the timing raised questions
The deaths did not happen in isolation. Several men connected to Russia's energy industry died in unusual circumstances in 2022, including:
- Leonid Shulman, a Gazprom transport executive, found dead in January near St Petersburg, with a note beside him.
- Alexander Tyulakov, a Gazprom deputy director, found dead in February in a garage at his St Petersburg home.
- Vasily Melnikov, head of a medical supply firm, found dead with his wife and two sons in Nizhny Novgorod in March.
- Alexander Subbotin, a Lukoil board member, who died in May in the Moscow area in disputed circumstances.
- Ravil Maganov, chairman of Lukoil, who fell from a window of a Moscow hospital in September.
Commentators also pointed to the political climate. In a speech on 16 March 2022, Vladimir Putin attacked wealthy Russians who, in his words, lived mentally in the West rather than with their own people. "I do not judge those with villas in Miami or the French Riviera," he said, before calling for what he described as a self-purification of society. Some analysts noted that business elites were among the few groups with any leverage over the Kremlin, which made their loyalty a sensitive issue.
What is known, and what is not
It is easy to see a pattern in a cluster of deaths, and much harder to prove one. A few points help keep the picture honest:
- The official findings: Russian and Spanish investigators both treated their cases as murder-suicides. Neither publicly reported evidence of an outside killer.
- The doubts: Family members and former colleagues disputed those conclusions, and some scene details reported by journalists did not sit comfortably with them.
- The missing link: No investigation has publicly connected the Avayev and Protosenya deaths to each other or to the Russian state. Suggestions that they were staged remain speculation.
- The wider context: Wealthy executives can also face enormous personal and financial pressure, and sanctions in 2022 added to it. That does not explain any single case, but it is one reason investigators did not assume foul play.
Behind the speculation are four people who had no part in any business or political story: two wives and two daughters, one of them only 13. In Lloret de Mar, residents held a minute's silence for the women at a rally against gender violence.
Reading stories like this carefully
Cases that touch on Russia, money and war attract strong theories online. A sensible approach is to separate three things: what police and courts have said, what family members and named sources claim, and what commentators infer. All three are worth hearing, but only the first is a finding.
If you are struggling with thoughts of harming yourself or others, please reach out to a local crisis line or emergency services, or talk to a doctor or someone you trust.
Sources: Newsweek: Russian oligarchs' murder-suicides (April 2022); Fortune: Son of dead Russian oligarch says father was not a killer (26 April 2022); Wikipedia: Suspicious Russia-related deaths since 2022; Wikipedia: Sergey Protosenya.

COMMENTS