Originally published 2021-12-06.
People usually fall for conspiracy theories because the theories meet a need, not because the evidence is strong. Psychology graduate and educator David Hundsness put it in four plain reasons: they fill a gap in information, they make a frightening event feel predictable, they keep a person in step with their group, and, most of all, they make the believer feel special. Academic research lands in a very similar place.
Below is a walk through each of those reasons, what psychologists have actually measured, and what tends to help when someone you care about has gone down the rabbit hole.
Who David Hundsness is and why his explanation spread
Hundsness holds a BA in Psychology from the University of California and posts short explainers on TikTok under the name @petearthling. In late 2021 he released a three-part series asking a simple question: if believing in a fringe theory means being argued with and mocked, why would anyone choose it over the comfortable majority view?
His answer is that the believer must be getting something in return. That framing is useful because it moves the conversation away from intelligence. Plenty of clever, educated people hold conspiracy beliefs. The more interesting question is what the belief does for them.
The series was picked up by Upworthy, which brought it to a much larger audience during a period when theories about Covid-19, vaccines, the 2020 US election and even the Moon landings were circulating heavily online.
The four reasons, in plain terms
1. Filling a gap in knowledge
When official information is thin, slow or confusing, a conspiracy theory offers a complete story straight away. Early in the pandemic, for example, scientists were honest that much was unknown. A theory that claimed to explain everything could feel more satisfying than "we are still studying it".
2. Making a threat feel less random
Random danger is hard to live with. Hundsness argues that a conspiracy theory helps a person predict where a threat is coming from, so that it "doesn't feel so random". Blaming a hidden group can feel oddly safer than accepting that a virus, an accident or an economic shock simply happened.
3. Following the in-group
People take cues from those they trust. If a political party, church, online community or circle of friends adopts a theory, members are more likely to adopt it too, and doubting it can feel like disloyalty.
4. Ego: feeling like one of the few who know
This is the reason Hundsness stresses most. Believers can see themselves as part of a small group of independent thinkers with "superior knowledge" while everyone else is fooled. He gives two examples: someone who felt overlooked at school or work, and a professional, such as a doctor, who gains attention and praise by backing a fringe position. In both cases the belief delivers recognition that was missing before. He goes as far as calling that ego boost the one common root of all conspiracy theories.
What the research says
Hundsness's list overlaps closely with the scientific literature, though researchers are more cautious about naming a single root cause.
In a widely cited 2017 review in Current Directions in Psychological Science, Karen Douglas, Robbie Sutton and Aleksandra Cichocka grouped the motives into three families:
- Epistemic: the need to understand what is going on and to have certainty (his first reason).
- Existential: the need to feel safe and in control (his second reason).
- Social: the need to feel good about yourself and your group (his third and fourth reasons).
The same review made a striking point: there is little evidence that believing in conspiracy theories actually satisfies those needs. The theories seem to be appealing rather than satisfying. Later work summarised on Wikipedia's overview of the field notes that exposure to conspiracy content can even reduce people's sense of control and make them less likely to act to improve their situation.
Other findings fill in the picture:
- Belief in one conspiracy theory predicts belief in others, even ones that contradict each other. The common thread seems to be the idea of a cover-up rather than any specific claim.
- Thinking shortcuts play a part, including proportionality bias (the sense that a big event must have a big cause) and confirmation bias (noticing what fits and ignoring what does not).
- Feelings of alienation, dissatisfaction and powerlessness are among the most consistent traits linked with conspiracy belief, according to a 2019 review by Goreis and Voracek.
- Most researchers do not treat conspiracy belief as a mental illness. It grows out of ordinary human tendencies such as pattern-seeking, gossip and group loyalty.
So the "ego" explanation is best seen as one strong motive among several, rather than the only one.
Common myths about conspiracy believers
Myth: only uneducated people believe them. Education helps a little, especially training in analytical thinking, but well-educated people, including some doctors and scientists, have promoted fringe theories. Motive matters as much as knowledge.
Myth: facts always backfire. The famous "backfire effect", where correcting someone makes them believe harder, has proved hard to replicate. A 2020 review by Swire-Thompson and colleagues found it rare. Corrections usually do move people a little, even if not all the way.
Myth: conspiracies never happen. Real conspiracies have been exposed, which is partly why the idea is so persuasive. The difference is that genuine ones are usually uncovered through documents, investigations and courts, not through the absence of evidence.
How to talk to someone who believes a conspiracy theory
Hundsness's advice is that people need to be able to change their minds without losing face. In his words, it takes "time and a lot of gentle repetition". Research supports that approach and adds a few practical steps:
- Skip the ridicule. Mockery pushes people back toward the group that welcomes them. Researchers Stephan Lewandowsky and John Cook recommend empathy and trusted messengers.
- Pick one claim. When a conversation spirals into many accusations, return to a single specific claim and ask what evidence would support or challenge it. Agree on a source or a test first.
- Let the right person speak. A friend, relative or respected member of their own community will be heard more easily than an outsider.
- Do not say "I told you so". If someone moves away from a belief, let it happen quietly.
- Prebunk where you can. Explaining common manipulation techniques before someone meets a false claim makes them more resistant to it.
There is also encouraging evidence that patient, tailored conversation works. In a 2024 study published in Science, Thomas Costello, Gordon Pennycook and David Rand had 2,190 Americans discuss a conspiracy theory they believed with an AI chatbot that answered their specific arguments with evidence. Belief in the chosen theory fell by about 20% on average. The lesson for humans is the same: specific, respectful answers to a person's actual reasons do more than general lectures.
The takeaway
Conspiracy theories survive because they offer certainty, safety, belonging and a feeling of being special. Seeing those needs clearly makes it easier to respond with patience instead of anger. The four-part explanation is a teaching framework rather than a diagnosis of every believer, but it is a good starting point for understanding a friend, a relative or even your own occasional doubts.
Sources: Upworthy: David Hundsness on why people fall for conspiracy theories (original video and header image); Douglas, Sutton and Cichocka (2017), The psychology of conspiracy theories; Wikipedia: Conspiracy theory (psychology and interventions); MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy: Costello, Pennycook and Rand chatbot study.

COMMENTS