Frank the Labrador Reacted to a Portrait of His Late Companion

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Frank the Labrador approaches a portrait of Smiff, his late companion

Libby Davey commissioned a portrait of Smiff after the family dog died. When her black Labrador, Frank, approached the finished painting, she recorded a moment that seemed especially poignant to the household. The family understood his reaction as recognition of the companion he had lost a few months earlier.

The painting was made by an artist identified as Tina and hung on a wall in the family’s home. It was intended as a remembrance of Smiff, bringing his likeness into a familiar room. Frank’s interest in it gave that memorial an unexpected new chapter.



In the account of the video, Frank wags his tail, moves onto the sofa and approaches the painting. Those actions are the visible part of the story. What he understood about the image is harder to establish, even though the family’s interpretation is easy to understand.

For someone who knew both dogs, the encounter brought a living companion and a remembered one into the same frame. A brief recording cannot tell us exactly what Frank was thinking, but it can preserve why the moment mattered to the people around him.




Tina shared her response online:


"I done a painting for a lady who's dog recently died. this is his brother how amazing & sad."


Stories of dogs remaining close to places associated with lost companions have a long history. One account from an animal sanctuary in Georgia described a golden retriever spending time by the grave of a St Bernard. Such reports convey what observers found moving, while leaving the animal’s understanding open to interpretation.

Edinburgh’s Greyfriars Bobby is a better-known example. In the traditional story, the nineteenth-century terrier remained associated with his owner’s grave for fourteen years, until his own death. A statue commemorates him in the city. The story belongs to Edinburgh’s local memory; it is not a controlled observation showing that every dog responds to loss in the same way.


The dog-food company ProDog Raw offers this broad description of the bond between people and dogs. It is commentary on their shared history, rather than a study of Frank or his response to a portrait:


"Dogs' loyalty to humans stems from the shared past of the two species. After the domestication of the dog, he began to change alongside his human master. Consequently, these two mammals developed an understanding that no other pair share. Research into the bond between humans and dogs has found a number of behaviours that developed from and continue to enhance the loyalty between them."


[Based on reporting by: Positive Outlooks]


The portrait’s place in the household

A commissioned portrait begins with a choice about what to remember. The owner selects an animal whose presence shaped daily life, and the artist gives that memory a form that can remain in the home. Unlike a passing social-media clip, the painting is there to be encountered again.

Frank’s approach added another relationship to that object. To the family, Smiff had been both their dog and Frank’s companion. Seeing Frank near the likeness connected those experiences in a way that an ordinary photograph of the finished artwork would not.

Tina’s reaction also captures the mixture of affection and sadness surrounding the commission. The portrait marked a loss, yet the surviving dog’s movement gave the scene energy. That combination helps explain the video’s appeal without requiring a claim that the painting recreated Smiff’s presence for Frank.

Research on dogs after a companion’s death

Researchers have investigated how dogs’ behaviour changes after the death of another dog in the household. A 2022 study in Scientific Reports surveyed 426 Italian adults who had experienced such a loss. Owners reported changes in activities including eating, playing and sleeping, as well as increased fearfulness. The reported relationship between the dogs and the owner’s emotional state were relevant to the patterns observed.

The study relied on people’s reports; it did not directly measure what a dog understands about death. It also did not test recognition of painted portraits. Its findings provide a useful reason to take changes after a companion’s loss seriously while keeping the limits of the evidence in view.

Frank’s video and this research answer different questions. One records a particular family moment; the other looks for patterns across many households. Neither needs to carry the whole explanation of animal attachment on its own.

A portrait within a family’s memory

For Libby’s family, the painting was already a way of keeping Smiff close in memory. Frank’s interest became part of its story, alongside the artist’s work and the experiences the household had shared with both dogs.

A memorial can have that kind of growing history. It recalls the animal who died, but it also becomes connected with moments involving those who remain. Here, a portrait on a wall prompted a short recording that the family could return to, preserving an encounter as well as a likeness.

COMMENTS