The Collier Quadruplets: Two Sets of Identical Twins Born Naturally

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published December 4, 2021.

The Collier Family Welcomed Quadruplets Reported as Two Sets of Twins

Madison and Justin Collier of Marietta, in Cobb County outside Atlanta, Georgia, welcomed quadruplets on 3 September 2021: two boys, Wilder Shepherd and Calloway Silas, and two girls, Iris Annabelle and Eliza June. The pregnancy happened without fertility drugs or IVF, and the family's medical team reportedly believes the babies form two pairs of identical twins, one pair of boys and one of girls. Born at about 28 weeks, the four spent roughly two months in neonatal intensive care at Northside Hospital before going home.

A routine scan that kept counting

The Colliers already had a daughter, Isla, who was four. Madison, then reported to be 33, went alone to what she expected to be an ordinary eight-week ultrasound. The doctor asked whether she had been taking fertility medication. She had not. When she heard there was more than one baby, she assumed twins, and was told it was not twins either: there were four.

The news was a genuine shock. Neither side of the family had a history of multiples, and the couple had conceived naturally. Madison later admitted she knew quadruplets existed but had never imagined it could happen to her family, saying "you just never think it would happen to you." Justin, 34, reportedly had to lie down on the floor at one point because he felt faint.

Isla took it in her stride. When she overheard the news, she asked: "Do we have a plan for four babies?" It was a fair question.

How rare are natural quadruplets?

News reports about the family quoted odds of about one in 700,000 for a natural quadruplet pregnancy. That number is not a measured statistic; it comes from Hellin's law, a 19th-century rule of thumb which says that if twins occur in about 1 in 89 births, triplets occur in about 1 in 89 squared and quadruplets in about 1 in 89 cubed. Eighty-nine cubed is just over 700,000. The rule gives a rough sense of scale but is not precise, and it says nothing about any individual's chances.

In practice, most higher-order multiples today follow fertility treatment. By 2011, about 78 per cent of triplet and higher-order births in the United States were linked to assisted reproduction, which is why doctors routinely ask the question Madison was asked. A spontaneous quadruplet pregnancy is unusual by any measure.

The second figure in circulation, one in 15 million for two sets of identical twins within a set of quadruplets, has no clear published basis and was not attributed to a named doctor. It is best read as a way of saying "extremely rare" rather than a real calculation.

What "two sets of identical twins" means

Identical, or monozygotic, twins come from a single fertilised egg that splits into two embryos, so the babies share the same DNA and are always the same sex. Fraternal twins come from two separate eggs and are no more alike than ordinary siblings.

In the Colliers' case, the reported picture is two fertilised eggs, each of which split. That would produce two identical boys and two identical girls, while the boys and girls are fraternal to each other. So the quadruplets are not all identical; they are two identical pairs born together. Only genetic testing can confirm zygosity with certainty, and the family's reports describe this as their medical team's belief.

The likeness was real enough that Madison found it hard to tell the matching pair apart at first. The family used pacifier clips and wristbands printed with the babies' names to keep track.

An early arrival and two months in the NICU

Carrying four babies puts great strain on the body. Madison reportedly looked full-term at only 22 weeks, and she described feeling all four move as an exciting, almost rollercoaster-like sensation. Even so, quadruplets almost never reach full term. Average gestation for quadruplets is around 30 to 31 weeks, compared with about 40 weeks for a single baby, and the Collier babies came at about 28 weeks.

Babies born that early usually need help with breathing, feeding and staying warm, which is why the four spent about two months in the neonatal intensive care unit at Northside Hospital. Madison has said that leaving the hospital without your newborns feels very different, a common experience for parents of premature babies. By the time the story was reported in the autumn of 2021, the babies and their mother were described as healthy and thriving.


Life at home with four newborns

The numbers in a quadruplet household quickly become comic. Madison estimated about 40 nappies a day, which works out to thousands every month. The family did not own a vehicle with room for five car seats, so for a while they needed two cars for every outing. Justin's office became the nursery, and a crowdfunding page helped with costs.

Justin's advice to other expecting parents was to prepare as much as possible and then simply hold on for the ride. Parents of multiples tend to agree that routines, shared feeding schedules and accepting help make the biggest difference.

How friends and family can help

  • Offer something specific. "I will bring dinner on Tuesday" is easier to accept than "let me know if you need anything".
  • Cover the consumables. Nappies, wipes and formula disappear fast with four babies.
  • Give parents time to sleep. An extra pair of hands for a night feed can be the most valuable gift of all.
  • Respect medical advice. Premature babies can be vulnerable to infections, so follow the family's rules on visits and hand washing.

Anyone facing a multiple pregnancy should rely on their own care team for guidance; the general figures here are not medical advice, so talk to a doctor about your situation.

Sources: WSB-TV Atlanta, October 2021: Metro woman gives birth to quadruplets; FOX 5 Atlanta, November 2021: Metro Atlanta mom gives birth to quadruplets; GodUpdates: Madison Collier and her natural quadruplets; Positive Outlooks; Wikipedia: Multiple birth. Photo and video: the Collier family, via news reports.

COMMENTS