Italian Man's Fake Silicone Arm at a COVID Vaccine Hub, Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-12-03. Dates, ages and announcements in this article refer to December 2021.

An Italian Man's Alleged Fake-Arm Vaccination Attempt in 2021

In early December 2021, a man walked into a COVID-19 vaccination hub in Biella, a town in Italy’s Piedmont region, and rolled up a sleeve that was not his own. Under his shirt he wore a realistic silicone forearm and shoulder, with his real arm tucked out of sight. His aim was simple: get the injection recorded, walk out with a vaccination certificate and never actually receive the vaccine. It did not work. The nurse preparing the shot noticed that the skin looked and felt wrong, and the attempt ended right there.

The story travelled around the world within hours, partly because it sounded like a comedy sketch. Behind the joke, though, sits a real picture of Italy in late 2021: strict certificate rules, a vaccine mandate for health workers and a small but determined group of people trying to find ways around both.

What happened at the Biella vaccination hub

According to Italian and international reports, the man sat down for his appointment and presented the fake limb as if it were his upper arm. A silicone prosthesis can look convincing from a distance, but a vaccinator works up close. When the nurse touched the arm to find the right spot on the shoulder muscle, she noticed two things: the colour did not match the rest of his body, and the surface had the cool, rubbery texture of silicone rather than skin.

She reportedly asked him to show his real arm. Staff then alerted local health officials, and the episode was passed to the authorities. Early reports described the man as about 50 years old; later coverage identified him by name and gave his age as 57, a common gap between first and later reporting in fast-moving stories.

Alberto Cirio, President of the Piedmont region, reacted strongly. “If it were not tragic, it would be comical,” he said, before adding that at a time of so many deaths and so much economic hardship, the act was unacceptable.

Why a vaccination certificate mattered so much in Italy

To understand why anyone would go to this much trouble, it helps to know how Italy handled the pandemic in 2021. The country had been one of the first in Europe to be hit hard, in early 2020, and the government leaned heavily on a COVID-19 certificate known as the Green Pass.

  • Health workers: from spring 2021, people working in health care, including dentists, were required to be vaccinated or risk suspension from their jobs.
  • The Green Pass: for much of 2021 the pass could be obtained through vaccination, recovery from COVID-19 or a recent negative test, and it was needed for many workplaces and indoor venues.
  • The “Super Green Pass”: from 6 December 2021, a reinforced version, available only to vaccinated or recently recovered people, was required for activities such as indoor dining, cinemas, theatres and sports events.

In other words, the timing was not random. The attempt in Biella came just days before the stricter rules took effect, when a negative test would no longer be enough for much of everyday social life.

Who the man turned out to be

Within days, Italian media identified him as Guido Russo, a dentist from the Biella area. As a health professional, he fell under the vaccine mandate for health workers, and reports said he had been suspended from practising because he was unvaccinated. That gave the certificate a very practical value for him: without it, he could not return to work.

Russo then gave his own account on Italian television. He said the silicone arm had been meant as a protest against compulsory vaccination rather than a genuine attempt to trick anyone. Around the same time, he received a real dose of the vaccine and told the programme he had done so “because the system obliged me to,” according to an Associated Press report. Whatever his intention, the nurse and health officials treated the episode as an attempt to obtain a certificate dishonestly, which is how it was reported to prosecutors.

Could a fake arm ever have worked?

Realistically, no. COVID-19 vaccines are given as an intramuscular injection, usually into the deltoid muscle at the top of the arm. To do that safely, the person giving the shot looks at the skin, often touches it to locate the muscle and checks for problems such as a recent injection site. A silicone arm would have to pass all of those checks at close range, in good light, in front of a trained professional.

The more common forms of certificate fraud in 2021 were far less theatrical. Police in several European countries, Italy included, reported investigations into people selling fake or borrowed certificates online, and into a small number of staff who recorded vaccinations that never happened. Those schemes were harder to spot than a rubber arm, which is one reason authorities took even this odd case seriously: it pointed to demand for a way around the rules.

Vaccine hesitancy behind the headline

It is easy to laugh at the story, and many people did. Still, the people who tried to avoid COVID-19 vaccines in 2021 were not all the same. Some were firmly opposed on principle, some were afraid of side effects, and some simply distrusted the authorities pushing the vaccines. Public health researchers generally found that listening to specific worries and answering them clearly worked better than ridicule.

For anyone with real questions about a vaccine, the sensible route is to talk to a doctor or pharmacist, who can explain the benefits and risks for a particular person. COVID-19 vaccines used in Europe were reviewed by the European Medicines Agency and monitored for side effects after approval, and that monitoring continues.

What happened next

At the time, reports said the man could face a charge of attempted fraud, and the case was referred to the justice system in Italy. We have not found reliable reporting on a final court outcome, so it would be wrong to describe him as convicted. What is clear is the immediate result: the trick failed on the spot, the nurse’s attention stopped it, and, according to the Associated Press, he received a genuine dose the following day.

The story became a small symbol of that winter: a time when pandemic rules shaped daily life so heavily that one man thought a silicone arm was worth the risk. The quiet hero of it is the vaccinator, nurse Filippa Bua, who simply did her job carefully.

Sources: AP via WUSF: An Italian dentist with a fake silicone arm gets a COVID vaccine for real (9 December 2021); Snopes: Italian dentist tried to circumvent vaccine mandate with fake arm; Bloomberg: Italian dentist presents fake arm for vaccine to get pass; AP via KSTP, 6 December 2021: Unvaccinated Italians face new restrictions (Super Green Pass); first reported to us by Greek City Times.

COMMENTS