Christian Karembeu's Great-Grandfather and the 1931 Human Zoos

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-11-01.

Christian Karembeu's Family History and Colonial Human Exhibitions

Christian Karembeu, the New Caledonian-born midfielder who won the 1998 World Cup and Euro 2000 with France, has said that his great-grandfather was put on show in Europe in 1931 as a supposed "cannibal". The man was one of roughly a hundred Kanak people from New Caledonia brought to Paris that year, and part of the group was later sent on to Tierpark Hagenbeck in Hamburg, the zoo that had made such "peoples shows" famous. In October 2021, speaking to the German TV magazine Panorama on NDR, Karembeu asked the zoo to tell that history openly.

His story is personal, but it also opens a door onto a much larger chapter of European history: the human zoos and ethnographic shows that drew millions of paying visitors between the 1870s and the 1930s. Here is what is known about his family's experience, how these exhibitions worked, and why the debate about them has not gone away.

Who Christian Karembeu is

Karembeu was born on 3 December 1970 in Lifou, one of the Loyalty Islands of New Caledonia, a French territory in the South Pacific whose Indigenous people are the Kanak. He played for Nantes, Sampdoria, Real Madrid, Middlesbrough, Olympiacos, Servette and Bastia, won the Champions League twice with Real Madrid (1998 and 2000) and earned 53 caps for France.

Even at the height of his career he was known for refusing to sing the Marseillaise, explaining that he could not do so because of France's colonial past and what it had meant for his people. The story of his great-grandfather is one of the reasons he has given for that stance. After retiring he moved into club management and has worked as sporting director at Olympiacos in Greece.

What happened to his great-grandfather in 1931

In 1931 Paris hosted the huge International Colonial Exposition in the Bois de Vincennes, which opened on 6 May and drew somewhere between seven and nine million visitors. France used it to celebrate its empire, and alongside pavilions and reconstructed buildings it brought people from the colonies to perform, make crafts and "live" in mock villages.

About a hundred Kanak men and women were recruited in New Caledonia for the trip. According to the accounts that have come down to us, they had been told they would represent their culture in France. In Paris they were instead shown at the Jardin d'Acclimatation, a park that had hosted ethnographic displays since the 1870s, where they were presented as cannibals and polygamists.

A smaller group, Karembeu's great-grandfather among them, was then passed on to Germany. In Hamburg they were billed as a cannibal people from the South Seas. Karembeu told Panorama that his ancestor was expected to growl and bare his teeth for the crowds. The often-repeated detail that the Kanaks were swapped for crocodiles from a German zoo appears in several accounts, including the Wikipedia biography of Karembeu, but it is hard to confirm in contemporary documents and is best treated as reported rather than proven.

The exhibition did not run its course. In the summer of 1931 a letter of protest reached the French colonial minister, and the group was quickly brought back to France and eventually home to New Caledonia.

What Karembeu asked of Hagenbeck, and how the zoo replied

Karembeu did not demand money or a symbolic gesture. He asked that Hagenbeck explain its role and tell the story as it actually happened, and said he would like to visit Hamburg and meet people from the park.

One of the most striking parts of his interview was what he said about his great-grandfather's own account. When the old man spoke of the journey later in life, he described it positively, saying he had been welcomed in France as a great chief. Karembeu suggested that this was a way of carrying the humiliation:

"He could not say, I was put on display."

The quote is Karembeu's, as reported by the German news agency dpa. Hagenbeck responded that it had been examining its history for some time with support from Hamburg's museums and the city's education authority, and that it would not give a final verdict while that work continued. It also repeated a long-standing argument: that the performers in its shows had contracts and were paid at rates comparable to circus and variety artists.

A short history of human zoos

The phrase "human zoo" covers a range of shows in Europe and North America from the mid-19th century to the 1950s, in which people from colonised or distant regions were exhibited to paying audiences, often in settings that mimicked their supposed natural surroundings.

Carl Hagenbeck, an animal dealer from Hamburg, is often credited with turning the idea into a business. In 1874 he put on a show of Sámi people with reindeer, and over the following years he toured groups of Nubians, Inuit and many others across Germany and Europe. These Völkerschauen ("peoples shows") were hugely popular, and the format was copied in Paris, London, Brussels, Chicago and elsewhere. Hagenbeck's own later account dates the shows from 1874–75 to 1931, which means the Kanak group was among the last.

A few other cases help show the range:

  • Bronx Zoo, 1906. Ota Benga, a Congolese man, was exhibited in the monkey house alongside an orangutan and labelled a "missing link". Protests by Black clergy in New York closed the exhibit within days.
  • Brussels World's Fair, 1958. A Congolese village held nearly 600 people, including about 200 children. The residents protested at how they were treated and the exhibit ended in mid-July; a baby died during the fair.
  • Augsburg Zoo, 2005. An "African village" with crafts and performances was staged in Germany. It drew wide criticism for repeating the old pattern of presenting Africans as exotic spectacle, even though the participants were paid and the organisers called it cultural.

Why "they were paid" does not settle the question

The argument that performers had contracts appears often in defences of the shows, and in some cases it is true that people signed agreements and received wages. But historians point out that a contract tells us little on its own about whether people understood what they were agreeing to, whether they could refuse, or whether they were free to leave.

The Kanak case shows the gap clearly. The recruits were reportedly promised one thing and given another; they were labelled cannibals, a claim used to sell tickets rather than to describe anyone; and they were moved between countries as a group. Many people in other shows fell ill in an unfamiliar climate, and some died far from home. Pay does not erase any of that.

The labels matter too. Calling the Kanak people "the last cannibals" was a marketing line built on racist ideas of the time. It should always be quoted as the organisers' claim, never repeated as a fact about the people on display.

How Europe is reckoning with this past

For decades human zoos were barely discussed in school history lessons. That began to change in France around the turn of the millennium. Didier Daeninckx's 1998 novel Cannibale told the story of the Kanaks shown "like animals in a zoo" at the 1931 exposition and helped bring the episode to a wide audience. Exhibitions, documentaries and research projects followed in France, Germany, Belgium and elsewhere.

In Germany, the debate is part of a wider reckoning with the colonial era, including the return of human remains and looted objects from museum collections. Karembeu's intervention gave that debate a recognisable face: a world champion asking a famous zoo, politely and publicly, to say what happened to his family.

If you want to look into family or local history connected to these shows, good starting points are museum archives, city records and academic projects on colonial exhibitions, which often hold posters, contracts and photographs.

Sources: WEB.DE / dpa, October 2021, on Karembeu's NDR Panorama interview; Wikipedia: Christian Karembeu; Wikipedia: Human zoo; Wikipedia: Paris Colonial Exposition; Wikipédia: Didier Daeninckx; first reported via News.in-24.

COMMENTS