Originally published 2021-11-02.
At about 8 p.m. on Halloween night, 31 October 2021, a 24-year-old man wearing a Joker costume attacked passengers on a Keio Line express train heading towards Shinjuku in western Tokyo. He stabbed a man, then splashed lighter fluid in a carriage and set it alight. Seventeen people were injured. The stabbed passenger, initially reported to be in critical condition, survived after about three months of treatment.
The attacker, Kyota Hattori, was arrested at the scene. On 31 July 2023 the Tachikawa branch of the Tokyo District Court sentenced him to 23 years in prison for attempted murder and arson. What follows explains what happened on the train, what came out at trial, and why the costume, though it dominated the headlines, explains less than it first seemed.
What happened on the Keio Line
The train was crowded with commuters and with people on their way to Halloween gatherings, many of them in costume. That is one reason the attacker attracted little attention before he struck: a man dressed as a comic-book villain did not look out of place that evening.
After the stabbing he spread lighter fluid and started a fire. Passengers fled through the carriages towards the front of the train. When it made an emergency stop at a station, many could not get through the doors quickly enough and squeezed out through the windows onto the platform. Footage of people climbing through windows while smoke filled the carriage was shared around the world within hours.
Another widely circulated video showed the attacker sitting calmly in an emptied carriage, legs crossed, smoking a cigarette, as police arrived. He did not resist arrest.
The attacker's motive, in his own words
Early reports quoted unnamed police sources saying Hattori admired the Joker and had grown angry after losing his job. At trial his explanation was bleaker. He told the court he had wanted to carry out a killing spree so that he would be sentenced to death, because he felt his own life had no worth.
He also said he had been inspired by an earlier attack on a Tokyo train. In August 2021 a man had gone on a random knife rampage aboard an Odakyu Electric Railway commuter train, stabbing passengers; that attacker later received 19 years in prison.
Prosecutors asked for 25 years, calling his motive "extremely selfish and deserving of strong condemnation." The defence asked for 12, arguing that he had not intended to kill everyone in the burning car. The judges settled on 23 years (AP via Khaosod English).
Why the Joker costume drew so much attention
The 2019 film Joker, directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, was a huge commercial success and the first R-rated film to pass $1 billion at the global box office. It tells the story of Arthur Fleck, an isolated, struggling man who turns to violence. Its first killings take place on a subway train, which made the comparison with the Tokyo attack almost irresistible for news outlets.
One detail in early coverage was wrong. The men Fleck shoots in the film are not street thugs but three drunk employees of Wayne Investments who harass and beat him. The setting is the same, but the scene is about a humiliated man lashing out at people he sees as powerful, which is part of why the film was argued over so fiercely.
Even before release, Joker was surrounded by worries about copycat violence. Some cinemas banned Joker costumes during its run, police in Los Angeles and New York increased their presence at screenings, and the US Army warned service members about possible threats. The FBI and Department of Homeland Security reportedly found no credible threats, and the screenings passed without reported violence.
The Aurora myth
Many articles about the Tokyo attack also mentioned the 2012 cinema shooting in Aurora, Colorado. On 20 July 2012 a gunman opened fire at a midnight screening of The Dark Knight Rises, killing 12 people and injuring 70. Early reports, attributed to federal officials, claimed he had dyed his hair red and called himself "the Joker."
That claim did not hold up. The local district attorney later said the gunman never called himself the Joker, and the Joker does not appear in The Dark Knight Rises; Heath Ledger played the character in the previous film, The Dark Knight (2008). Even so, the rumour stuck. When Joker was released in 2019, families of some Aurora victims wrote to Warner Bros. with their concerns, and the film was not shown at the Aurora cinema where the shooting happened.
Is there a link between films and real violence?
A costume is a visible, easy story, but it is not evidence that a film caused an attack. In the Tokyo case, the attacker's own testimony pointed to despair, a wish to be executed and imitation of a recent real-life attack in Japan, rather than to anything on screen. The Joker outfit appears to have been part of how he chose to present himself on a night when costumes were everywhere.
Researchers who study mass attacks generally caution against blaming films or games for violence. They tend to focus instead on personal crises, social isolation, access to means and copycat effects driven by heavy media coverage of earlier attacks. That last point is one reason many news organisations now try to avoid giving attackers the notoriety they may be seeking.
Japan's rare but recurring train and street attacks
Japan has very low rates of violent crime compared with most countries, and guns are tightly restricted. When attacks do happen, they are usually carried out with knives or fire, and they often target crowded public places. The Odakyu stabbing came less than three months before the Halloween attack.
In May 2019, a 51-year-old man attacked schoolchildren and adults waiting at a bus stop in Kawasaki, near Tokyo, killing an 11-year-old girl and a 39-year-old man and wounding around 18 others before taking his own life. Some reports at the time said two children were killed; in fact one of the two people who died was an adult.
After the 2021 train attacks, Japanese rail operators and the transport ministry reportedly looked at ways to improve safety, including more security cameras and better guidance for stopping trains and opening doors in an emergency, after passengers on the Keio train had to escape through windows.
What passengers can take from it
Attacks like this remain extremely rare, and rail travel in Japan is among the safest in the world. Still, the Keio incident is a reminder of a few simple habits: know where the emergency call buttons and exits are in a carriage, move away from danger towards other carriages when you can, and follow staff instructions once the train stops. Above all, the passengers who helped each other out of the windows that night show how much ordinary people can do for one another in the first minutes of an emergency.
Sources: Khaosod English / AP, 31 July 2023; NBC News, 31 October 2021; Wikipedia: Joker (2019 film); Wikipedia: 2012 Aurora, Colorado shooting; Wikipedia: Kawasaki stabbings.

COMMENTS