Originally published 2021-11-01.
This article discusses suicide. If you are struggling, you can call Samaritans free on 116 123 in the UK at any time, or 988 in the United States. Contact details for more countries are at the end.
Mared Foulkes was a 21-year-old pharmacy student at Cardiff University, from Anglesey in north Wales. In 2021 she received an automated email suggesting she had failed a resit and could not continue her degree. In reality she had passed, with 62%. The email had shown the 39% from her first attempt rather than her resit result. Later that day she died at the Britannia Bridge over the Menai Strait. An inquest held in the autumn of 2021 concluded that she had taken her own life.
Her death raised hard questions about how universities communicate life-changing news to students, especially during the isolation of the pandemic. This is what the inquest heard, what it did and did not find, and what students, families and institutions can take from it.
What the inquest heard
According to reports of the hearing, Mared had been studying for the pharmacy degree largely on her own because of Covid-19 restrictions, without the usual daily contact with classmates and tutors. On the morning she died she received her examination results by email. One message indicated that she had not successfully completed the year.
That information was wrong. A mix-up meant she was sent the mark from her original exam rather than the resit she had since taken and passed comfortably. She was at home with her family that day and told them she was going out to buy ingredients for a meal. She did not come back. A passer-by found her later.
Her mother later described how impersonal the message had been, describing it as "an automatic email - there was nothing personal - no phone call, nothing." She said her daughter was devoted to her course and to her work in a pharmacy, and that the email would have made her feel all her plans had ended in a single sentence.
What the coroner concluded
The coroner found that Mared had intended to end her life and recorded a conclusion of suicide. The hearing was told she had not seen a GP about low mood and had not left a note.
The inquest also heard that she had contacted the university's student support service in 2019. At that time she appeared distressed and said she had been self-harming, but she did not report having suicidal thoughts. Nothing indicated to staff then that she was at immediate risk.
It is important to read these findings carefully. An inquest establishes who died, when, where and how. The incorrect email was clearly part of the events of that day, and the family's distress at the way it was sent is entirely understandable. But suicide is rarely the result of a single cause. It usually involves a combination of long-running pressures and a sudden crisis, which is why prevention depends on many layers of support rather than one fix.
Why the way results are delivered matters
Universities handle thousands of marks each term, and automated systems are a practical way to release them. The risk is that the same template goes to a student who has narrowly missed a pass and one whose whole degree appears to be over, with no human in the loop to notice that something is badly wrong, or that the student receiving it might be fragile.
Several straightforward safeguards are widely recommended in higher education and would reduce that risk:
- Human checks before any fail or "cannot progress" outcome is released, including a quick comparison of first attempts and resits.
- Clear next steps in the message itself: what the result means, whether it can be appealed or checked, and who to contact today.
- Support contacts on every results email, including out-of-hours mental health lines.
- Personal contact for the most serious outcomes, such as a call or meeting from a tutor rather than an automatic notice.
- Thinking about timing, so that bad news does not arrive when no staff are available to answer questions.
Bereaved families in the UK have campaigned for universities to have a clearer legal duty of care towards students. Whatever view one takes on that debate, cases like this one show how a single administrative error can reach a person at the worst possible moment.
Studying alone through the pandemic
The years 2020 and 2021 were especially hard for students. Lectures moved online, placements were disrupted, and many young people spent months away from the friendships and informal check-ins that normally help them cope with pressure. Pharmacy is a demanding vocational degree, where progression rules are strict and failing a year can feel like the loss of a whole career path.
In that setting, a student may have nobody nearby to say "that can't be right, let's ring the department." That missing conversation is one of the quieter costs of remote study, and it is worth remembering now that blended and online learning are here to stay.
What students and families can do
- Treat a shocking result as something to check. Marks can be wrong, mixed up or provisional. Contact the department, your personal tutor or the student union advice service before drawing conclusions.
- Know the options. Most universities have resits, appeals, extenuating-circumstances processes and course transfers. A failed module is very rarely the end of a career.
- Families can ask open questions. On results day, a simple "how did it go, and how are you feeling about it?" gives space to talk.
- Take signs of distress seriously. Withdrawal, hopelessness, talk of being a burden, or self-harm are reasons to reach out and to encourage the person to talk to a doctor or a support service.
If you need support
If you are having thoughts of suicide, or are worried about someone, you do not have to deal with it alone. Talk to someone you trust, speak to a doctor, or contact a helpline:
- UK: Samaritans, free on 116 123, day or night, every day of the year.
- United States: the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, by calling or texting 988.
- Elsewhere: contact your local emergency number or your national crisis line, or speak to a doctor.
Mared's family described a young woman who loved her work and had her future planned. Remembering her means paying attention to the small, human details, a phone call, a second check, a kind word, that can make all the difference when difficult news arrives.
Sources: reporting of the 2021 inquest by the Daily Mail and other UK media; Samaritans; 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.

COMMENTS