First published June 10, 2021.

Photo: Gosiame Thamara Sithole and her partner Teboho Tsotetsi of Tembisa, Ekurhuleni, pictured before the reported birth. Photo by Thobile Mathonsi, African News Agency (ANA).
No, a woman in South Africa did not give birth to ten babies. In June 2021 a newspaper reported that Gosiame Thamara Sithole, 37, from Tembisa near Johannesburg, had delivered decuplets, a claimed world record. The story spread around the world within hours. Official investigations later found no evidence that the babies ever existed, and South Africa's Public Protector formally ruled the claim unsubstantiated in December 2022.
This page explains what was reported, what investigators found, and how a birth that never happened became global news.
What the original report claimed
On 8 June 2021, the Pretoria News published a story by its editor, Piet Rampedi, saying Sithole had given birth to ten babies at a hospital in Pretoria. Her partner, Teboho Tsotetsi, was quoted as saying: "It's seven boys and three girls. I am happy. I am emotional. I can't talk much."
According to that coverage, five babies were born naturally and five by caesarean section. The couple said they had conceived without fertility treatment, and Sithole was described as already being the mother of six-year-old twins. An earlier interview in the same paper had reported that scans first showed eight babies and that two more were found later.
The story quickly suggested a new Guinness World Record, and international outlets, including the BBC, picked it up. Some cited a local official who said he had been told of the births, while admitting he had not yet seen the babies himself. Guinness World Records said it was looking into the case.
Why the claim fell apart
Doubts appeared almost immediately. No hospital confirmed the delivery, no photographs of ten newborns appeared, and the family's statements changed. Later that month the Gauteng provincial government said it could find no record of the births in any public or private hospital in the province.
Over the following months, several investigations reached the same conclusion. In October 2021 Independent Media's own press ombudsman called the story a hoax and ordered the group to apologise. The company's chairman, Iqbal Survé, instead held a press briefing alleging that the babies had been trafficked and promising a documentary about a cover-up. No evidence for that theory has been produced.
In December 2022, Public Protector Kholeka Gcaleka published her report. She found no medical records, no eyewitness accounts and nothing else to show that Sithole had ever carried ten babies, and described the allegation as unsubstantiated. Rampedi resigned from the paper at the end of January 2023, while still insisting his story was true.
The real record: nine babies in Mali
The decuplet story broke only a month after a genuine and extraordinary birth. On 4 May 2021, Halima Cissé, a 25-year-old woman from Mali, delivered nine babies by caesarean section at the Ain Borja clinic in Casablanca, Morocco. The five girls and four boys were born at about 30 weeks, each weighing between 500 g and 1 kg.
Guinness World Records lists the Cissé nonuplets as the most children delivered at a single birth to survive, and they were the first known nonuplets in history to do so. Before them, the record belonged to the octuplets born in 2009 to Nadya Suleman in California. Unlike the Tembisa claim, the Mali birth was documented by doctors, a hospital and the Malian government, and the children have since celebrated birthdays in public.
Sithole herself was reportedly taken for assessment by social workers and officials, and the family gave conflicting accounts about where the babies were supposed to be. Through all of this, no birth certificates, hospital bills or medical staff connected to ten newborns were ever identified.
The closeness in time almost certainly helped the false story travel. Readers had just learned that nine babies could be born and survive, so ten did not sound impossible.
How large multiple births actually happen
Natural twins occur in a little over one in a hundred births worldwide, and triplets are far rarer. Births of six or more babies are extremely unusual and most often follow fertility treatment, which can release several eggs at once. Even with modern neonatal care, such pregnancies carry high risks of premature birth and complications for both mother and babies.
That is why doctors treat extreme multiple pregnancies as medical emergencies, and why any genuine case leaves a large paper trail: scans, specialists, neonatal intensive care beds and hospital records. The absence of all of these in the Tembisa case was the strongest sign that something was wrong. Anyone with questions about a multiple pregnancy should talk to a doctor.
How to spot a story like this before sharing it
- Look for independent confirmation. In this case dozens of outlets repeated one paper's report. Repetition is not verification.
- Check whether the institution speaks. A real record birth is announced or confirmed by a hospital or health ministry, as with the Mali nonuplets.
- Watch for missing evidence. No pictures, no named hospital and shifting details are warning signs.
- Be wary of record claims. "World record" in a headline invites sharing, which is exactly when to slow down.
The Tembisa story remains one of South African journalism's most debated episodes, both for how fast it spread and for how long its author defended it.
Sources: Wikipedia: Tembisa 10; Guinness World Records: most children delivered at a single birth to survive; Public Protector report on the Tembisa decuplets (Politicsweb); Pretoria News original report (June 2021); BBC News, June 2021. Photo: Thobile Mathonsi/African News Agency.

COMMENTS