Originally published 2021-06-10.

The New York Times had recently published an article by accident, which made the peculiar claim that watermelons had been discovered on Mars.
The story, which was deleted less than an hour later, read:
"Authorities say rise of fruit aliens is to blame for glut of outer space watermelons. The FBI declined to comment on reports of watermelons raining down, but confirmed that kiwis have been intercepted."
A snapshot of the story which has been archived shows that it was just a stub, including several non-sequiturs.
Part of it reads:
"This story is terribly boring."
After the article disappeared in less than an hour, it was replaced by a message saying: "published in error".
A spokesperson from the New York Times said of the story:
"Earlier today, a mock article intended for a testing system was published on our site in error. The article has since been removed."
It is important to note that there has not been any evidence of watermelons ever existing on Mars.
Nevertheless, there have been several missions that investigate the possibility of ancient life on the red planet, while the possibility of past or present microbial life remains a subject of investigation rather than an established finding.
[h/t: Futurism]
Why a correction matters more than a screenshot
A screenshot can preserve what appeared on a page while omitting why it appeared. Here, the publisher's explanation that a test item escaped into public view is essential context. When a startling article circulates, compare its original address, publication time and subsequent correction before sharing it; the existence of a page does not establish the truth of its claim.
Additional source: NASA: potential biosignatures and alternative explanations.
What the test page looked like
The page appeared on 8 June 2021 under the headline “Fields of Watermelons Found on Mars, Police Say”, with the byline “Joe Schmoe” and a web address in the newspaper’s Garden section. Futurism first spotted it, and a Times spokeswoman gave it the statement about a mock article intended for a testing system. After about an hour the page was replaced with the note that it had been published in error.
Sources: Futurism, 8 June 2021: The New York Times accidentally published an article about watermelons on Mars Mediaite, 8 June 2021: ‘Fields of Watermelons Found on Mars,’ reports New York Times in now-deleted article
A test article and a scientific discovery require different evidence
The publisher’s explanation identifies the watermelon story as testing material accidentally made public. That resolves the specific incident without needing speculation about what might live on Mars. Scientific reports about possible biosignatures use a different standard: a potentially relevant feature still needs investigation and alternative explanations. Keeping that distinction clear prevents an amusing publishing error from becoming mixed with unsupported certainty about microbial life beneath the Martian surface.

COMMENTS