Pentagon Lets Transgender Troops Serve Openly After Biden Order

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-04.

Biden's January 2021 Change to Transgender Military-Service Policy

On 31 March 2021 the US Department of Defense published new rules that allowed transgender people to enlist and serve openly in the American armed forces. The rules carried out an executive order President Joe Biden had signed on 25 January 2021, just days into his term, and they replaced the restrictive policy introduced under Donald Trump. They took effect on 30 April 2021.

That is the short answer to what happened in spring 2021. The longer story matters, because this policy has changed hands repeatedly. Open service was first allowed in 2016, restricted from 2019, restored in 2021 and then reversed again in 2025. Anyone reading about transgender military service needs to know which of these periods a news report describes.

What the 2021 rules changed

Biden's order, Executive Order 14004, stated plainly that "gender identity should not be a bar to military service." It told the Pentagon and the Department of Homeland Security, which runs the Coast Guard, to write rules that matched that principle. The Pentagon's answer, announced at the end of March, did several things at once:

  • Open enlistment. Transgender recruits who met the normal physical, medical and mental-health standards could join and serve in their self-identified gender.
  • No discharge for gender identity. Serving members could not be pushed out, or refused re-enlistment, simply for being transgender.
  • Medical care. Troops gained access to transition-related treatment judged medically necessary and permitted by law, along with a formal process for changing the gender marker in their records.
  • A look back. The services were told to review the records of people who had been discharged or turned away under the previous policy.

The standards themselves did not soften. A transgender applicant still had to pass the same fitness tests, medical screening and job requirements as everyone else. The change was about who could apply, not about how hard the military is to get into.

What officials and service members said

Pentagon press secretary John Kirby framed the decision as a matter of recruiting and readiness. Speaking for Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, he told reporters that the secretary believes "the all-volunteer force thrives when it is composed of diverse Americans who can meet the high standards for military service."

Among the people most directly affected was Air Force Lt. Col. Bree Fram, an astronautical engineer who was then vice president of SPART*A, an advocacy group for transgender service members. She welcomed the move and stressed the health-care side of it, telling NBC News that "military personnel reach maximum effectiveness when they have access to all medically necessary care." Fram later became one of the most senior openly transgender officers in the US military.

Stephanie Miller, the Pentagon's director of military accession policy, said the cost of treatment would be modest and would not noticeably affect the department's medical budget.

How many transgender troops are there?

Nobody has an exact count, because the military does not ask every member about gender identity. Estimates vary widely depending on who is counted and how:

  • A 2016 study by the RAND Corporation, commissioned by the Pentagon, estimated about 2,450 transgender people in the active force and about 1,510 in the reserves.
  • Advocacy and academic groups, including the Palm Center and the Williams Institute, put the figure at around 15,000 in 2014, using broader survey methods.
  • Officials cited by NBC News in 2021 used a figure of about 14,700, based on 2019 data, while noting that estimates differ.
  • According to the same report, roughly 2,200 service members had a formal diagnosis of gender dysphoria at the time.

Whatever the true number, transgender troops are a small share of a force of well over a million people, which is one reason cost and readiness estimates came out low.

What the evidence said about readiness

The main argument for the Trump-era restrictions was that transgender service could harm readiness, unit cohesion or budgets. The research available in 2021 did not support that fear.

The 2016 RAND study estimated that allowing transition-related care would cost between $2.4 million and $8.4 million a year, a tiny fraction of military health spending. It projected that readiness would fall by about 0.0015% of available labour-years, and it found that unit cohesion would be minimally affected. Looking at foreign militaries that already allowed open service, such as the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and Israel, RAND found no evidence of harm to operational effectiveness.

In 2018, the chiefs of all the US military services also told Congress that they had seen no problems with discipline, morale or unit readiness from transgender troops serving. That testimony came while the restrictions were still being prepared, which made it especially notable.

One common misunderstanding is that the 2021 policy automatically paid for surgery. It did not promise any particular procedure. The rules covered care that doctors judged medically necessary and that the law allowed, decided case by case.

A policy that kept changing

The back-and-forth is easier to follow as a timeline:

  • June 2016: Defense Secretary Ash Carter ended the ban on open transgender service and set a date for new recruits to be accepted.
  • July 2017: President Trump announced on Twitter that transgender people would not be allowed to serve in any capacity. A presidential memorandum followed in August, and courts blocked it for a time.
  • January 2019: The Supreme Court lifted two of those injunctions, clearing the way for restrictions.
  • 12 April 2019: New rules took effect that largely barred people with a history or diagnosis of gender dysphoria from enlisting, with limited exceptions for those already serving.
  • 25 January 2021: Biden signed Executive Order 14004.
  • 31 March 2021: The Pentagon published the new rules, effective 30 April 2021.
  • 27 January 2025: After returning to office, Trump signed Executive Order 14183, which declared transgender identity incompatible with military service. Enlistment was paused in February and a full ban followed.
  • 6 May 2025: The Supreme Court allowed the ban to take effect while legal challenges, including Shilling v. United States, continued in the lower courts.

So the 2021 rules described in this article were in force for just under four years. Readers looking for current eligibility should check the latest Pentagon guidance rather than relying on any report from 2021.

How this compares with the history of gay service

Debates over transgender troops echo the long fight over lesbian, gay and bisexual service members. Before 1993, homosexuality was grounds for exclusion. The "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" policy, which ran from 1993, let gay people serve only if they kept their orientation hidden; those who were open about it could be discharged. Congress voted to repeal the policy in December 2010, and the repeal took effect in September 2011, after which gay, lesbian and bisexual Americans could serve openly.

The two issues are different in one practical way. Sexual orientation does not usually involve medical care, while gender transition sometimes does, which is why cost, deployability and health care have been central to the transgender debate in a way they never were for "Don't Ask, Don't Tell".

Why the 2021 decision still matters

Even though it was later reversed, the 2021 policy left a record that both sides still cite. For supporters, it showed that open service could run for several years without the disruption critics predicted. For opponents, the reversal in 2025 showed that the question remains political rather than settled.

For transgender service members themselves, the practical lesson has been uncertainty: careers built under one set of rules have repeatedly been exposed to the next administration's decisions. Anyone affected by these changes, or considering enlistment, is best served by speaking with a military recruiter, a legal aid organisation or a service member advocacy group about the rules in force today.

Sources: NBC News: Biden administration scraps Trump's restrictions on transgender troops; Wikipedia: Transgender personnel in the United States military; Wikipedia: Don't ask, don't tell; PBS NewsHour, 6 May 2025: Supreme Court allows Trump's transgender military ban to take effect for now.

COMMENTS