Turkish Soldiers and Frontex Officers at Evros: What Was Reported

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-12.

Report Described Shots Near German Border Officers at Evros

Shots fired near European Union border officers on the Greek-Turkish frontier made headlines twice in a year. In April 2020, according to Der Spiegel, a Turkish soldier fired a shot and then aimed an automatic weapon across the Evros River while German officers serving with Frontex were on the Greek bank. In March 2021, Greek and German media reported further gunfire from the Turkish side as Frontex patrols passed. No one was reported hurt in either case, but the episodes showed how tense the river border had become after the migration crisis of early 2020.

This explainer separates the two incidents, sets out what was confirmed, and explains why German police were patrolling a Greek border at all.

The April 2020 incident described by Der Spiegel

Der Spiegel based its report on an internal Frontex document. As summarised by Greek Reporter, the document said a Turkish soldier fired a shot at about 7:15 pm on Tuesday 28 April 2020, while German officers were on the Greek side of the river. One of the Germans took cover after hearing it. Looking through binoculars, the officers then saw a soldier on the Turkish side aiming an automatic weapon towards them. He reportedly made an obscene hand gesture and went back to his tent, while others shouted at the patrol to come over.

Shortly afterwards, according to the same account, six more Turkish soldiers appeared and pointed their weapons at the German and Greek officers. The patrol was not hit and there were no injuries. The German Interior Ministry confirmed that the incident had taken place.

Some retellings described the guards as being shot at directly. The reporting supports a warning shot followed by soldiers taking aim, which is serious, but different from a sustained exchange of fire.

The March 2021 shots near Tychero

Almost a year later, on 12 March 2021, Greek outlets citing Der Spiegel reported two more episodes, on 5 and 7 March, near the village of Tychero in the Evros region. Turkish soldiers fired into the air as a German Frontex patrol came into view, and on one occasion the Turkish national anthem was reportedly played over a loudspeaker. A Frontex official told Spiegel that “it was not an isolated incident.”

Frontex's then executive director, Fabrice Leggeri, reported the incidents to the European Commission in writing, and the agency introduced extra protection for its staff, including bulletproof vests. It was unclear whether the shooting reflected an order from above or the behaviour of individual units on the ground. Turkey's response was not included in those reports.

Why German officers were on the Evros at all

Frontex, the European Border and Coast Guard Agency, supports EU countries at their external borders. Member states lend it officers and equipment, and a country under pressure can request a rapid intervention. Greece did exactly that in March 2020. Roughly 100 Frontex officers were deployed along the Evros, about 20 of them German, according to the April 2020 reports. By March 2021 Frontex had around 80 border guards in the region, 15 of them from Germany.

Their role was to patrol and help register people crossing, under Greek command. They were not there to fight anyone, which is why a shot or a raised rifle aimed in their direction was treated as a diplomatic matter, not only a local one.

The 2020 border crisis behind the tension

The incidents followed the most serious confrontation on the Evros in years. On 28 February 2020, after 33 Turkish soldiers were killed in Syria's Idlib province, Turkey announced that it would no longer stop migrants and refugees heading for Europe. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said tens of thousands had already set off. Thousands of people gathered at the Kastanies-Pazarkule crossing and along the river.

Greece closed the border, sent riot police and the army, and used tear gas to push back attempts to break through the fence. EU leaders, including Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, visited the Evros on 3 March 2020 to show support for Athens. Greece and the EU accused Ankara of using desperate people as leverage in its disputes with Europe; Turkey argued that it hosted millions of Syrian refugees with too little help from the EU. The mass gathering at the border dispersed within weeks, but mistrust along the river remained.

Who crosses this border, and why it matters

Since the Syrian civil war drove millions into Turkey from 2011 onwards, the land and sea routes into Greece have been among the busiest entry points to the EU. People attempting the crossing have come not only from Syria but also from Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Iran and elsewhere. Many hoped to reach Germany or other northern European states to claim asylum. Thousands ended up waiting for long periods in crowded camps on the Greek islands.

The 2016 EU-Turkey statement was meant to reduce irregular crossings in exchange for EU funding for refugees in Turkey. When relations soured, the border became a pressure point. Greece has since extended and strengthened its fence along the Evros, a project its government described as historically important for national security.

Reading reports like these with care

Border incidents are easy to exaggerate and hard to verify. A few points help:

  • Check the date. The April 2020 story was recirculated in 2021 as if it were new, which made the situation sound like a fresh escalation.
  • Separate warning shots, shots in the air and aimed fire. All are serious, but they mean different things.
  • Look for official confirmation. In 2020, Germany's Interior Ministry confirmed the incident; in 2021, Frontex's own reporting to the Commission did the same.
  • Ask what each side says. Turkish authorities' account was missing from most reports, and readers should note that gap.

No one was hurt on the Evros in these incidents. The bigger story is the fragile relationship between Greece, Turkey and the EU, and the people caught on the riverbanks between them.

Sources: Original reporting by Der Spiegel; Greek Reporter: Turkish soldiers fire and take aim at German, Greek officers (May 2020); Greek Reporter: Turkish soldiers fire guns at Greece's Evros border (March 2021); Wikipedia: 2020 Greek–Turkish border crisis.

COMMENTS