South Dakota's Transgender Sports Ban: From 2021 Veto to 2022 Law

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-13.

South Dakota Senate Advanced a Transgender Sports Restriction in March 2021

In March 2021, South Dakota's legislature passed HB 1217, a bill to bar transgender girls and women from girls' and women's school and college sports. It did not become law that year. Governor Kristi Noem, who had praised the bill, sent it back with a partial veto, lawmakers failed to resolve the standoff, and the bill died. Noem then issued two executive orders instead. A year later, in February 2022, she signed a new law that made South Dakota the tenth US state to ban transgender girls from girls' teams at school and college level.

This page explains what happened in each step, why the governor changed course, the main arguments on both sides, what research says so far, and how the national picture has developed since.

What happened in March 2021

HB 1217 cleared the state House and then the Senate, which approved it by 20 votes to 15. The final legislative vote came on 8 March 2021, International Women's Day, and Noem marked it with a post saying she was excited to sign the bill soon.

In South Dakota, we're celebrating #InternationalWomensDay by defending women's sports! I'm excited to sign this bill very soon. https://t.co/OU15HOwp2r

— Governor Kristi Noem (@govkristinoem) March 8, 2021

(This post is no longer available on X.)

LGBTQ rights groups reacted immediately. The Human Rights Campaign, the largest LGBTQ advocacy group in the US, replied that the governor was using her power to exclude children.

Many news outlets reported that South Dakota had "passed" a ban. In fact, the governor's signature was still needed, and that is where the story changed.

Why the governor vetoed parts of the bill

About two weeks after the vote, Noem returned the bill with what is called a "style and form" veto, a tool normally used to fix technical wording. She struck two sections and asked lawmakers to limit the ban to elementary and high school sports, dropping college athletics.

Her reasons, according to the Associated Press, were legal and financial. She argued that covering college sports would invite lawsuits and could lead the NCAA to move tournaments away from South Dakota. Business groups had warned that lost tournaments could cost the state millions of dollars and up to 100 jobs.

Many legislators said she had gone beyond her constitutional authority. On 29 March 2021 the House rejected her changes and tried to treat them as a full veto to override, but fell short of the required two-thirds majority. The bill was dead.

The same day, Noem signed two executive orders. One required girls who wanted to play on girls' teams in public schools to show a birth certificate or affidavit stating they were born female. The other recommended, but did not require, that public universities adopt similar rules. Her summary of her position was short: "Only girls should play girls' sports." Conservatives who had sponsored the bill called the orders a weak substitute, while Democrats said the whole effort singled out a vulnerable group. The state high school activities association said at the time that no transgender students were playing girls' sports.

The 2022 law

Noem promised to bring the issue back, and she did. On 3 February 2022 she signed a new bill, written with her support, that bans transgender girls and women from teams that match their gender identity in K-12 schools and public universities. According to PBS NewsHour, it made South Dakota the tenth state with such a law, and it took effect on 1 July 2022. Noem said the law would ensure "fairness and a level playing field for female athletes."

Opponents, including The Trevor Project, a suicide-prevention group for LGBTQ young people, called the law another way of shutting transgender youth out of everyday school life.

The arguments on both sides

Supporters of these laws make three main points. First, that going through male puberty brings lasting physical advantages, such as greater height, larger muscles, bigger hearts and lungs and denser bones, which hormone treatment later in life does not fully reverse. Second, that this is unfair to girls and women competing for places, medals and scholarships. Third, that in contact or collision sports it could raise the risk of injury.

Opponents argue that very few transgender girls play school sports, that bans hurt children who simply want to be part of a team, and that the laws create pressure to check the bodies or documents of any girl who looks "too strong". Human Rights Campaign's Mississippi director, Rob Hill, told CNN in a debate over a similar bill that nobody transitions to win at sport and that such laws expose transgender youth to bullying and exclusion. In South Dakota, critics noted that very few transgender athletes had ever competed under the state's existing policy.

Many sports experts argue that the right answer depends on the age group and the level. Recreational play for young children, where puberty has not started, raises different questions from elite adult competition.

What the research says so far

The science is still developing, and studies are small. A summary of the research on transgender people in sports points to two 2021 reviews. One concluded that testosterone suppression only slightly reduces strength, muscle size and bone density in trans women. The other found significant drops in strength and lean mass after a year of hormone therapy, but levels still above those of other women even after three years. More recent analyses have reported mixed results on overall fitness.

Most of these studies measure non-athletes rather than trained competitors, so they cannot say exactly what happens in a particular sport. That uncertainty is one reason governing bodies have reached different conclusions.

How sports bodies have responded

World Athletics barred trans women who went through male puberty from female world-ranking events from March 2023. The International Olympic Committee moved from a 2021 framework that left rules to each sport towards a stricter approach in 2026, requiring a one-time genetic screening for the female category.

The national picture since 2021

Idaho had passed the first state law of this kind in 2020. Since then the number has grown fast, and by the mid-2020s more than half the states had some form of ban. In February 2025 President Trump signed an executive order directing federal agencies to enforce a ban on transgender girls and women in female sports, and the NCAA restricted its women's competitions to athletes assigned female at birth the following day.

The courts have been central throughout. Federal judges blocked the Idaho and West Virginia laws for years, and in July 2025 the US Supreme Court agreed to hear both cases, Little v. Hecox and West Virginia v. B.P.J., which could settle the constitutional question for the whole country. Whatever the outcome, the South Dakota episode is a useful reminder that a legislative vote is only one stage: the final law can look quite different from the bill first reported.

Sources: AP via WEAR, 29 March 2021: South Dakota governor kills transgender bill but orders ban; PBS NewsHour, February 2022: Noem signs transgender athlete ban; Wikipedia: Transgender people in sports. Embedded posts by Governor Kristi Noem and the Human Rights Campaign on X; earlier coverage via UNILAD.

COMMENTS