First published March 6, 2021.

In March 2021 India's then Chief Justice, Sharad Arvind Bobde, faced calls to resign after asking a man accused of raping a schoolgirl whether he would marry her. The exchange took place on 1 March 2021 during a bail hearing at the Supreme Court. Women's rights groups said it signalled that marriage could be a way for an accused rapist to avoid jail; a week later Bobde said the court's words had been "completely misreported" and that it had never suggested a marriage.
Here is what happened in the courtroom, what the court actually ordered, why the remark caused such anger, and the wider legal questions it exposed about sexual violence and marriage in India.
The case before the court
The accused, Mohit Subhash Chavan, was a 23-year-old technician employed by a state power company in Maharashtra. A girl had accused him of repeatedly raping her while she was a minor. According to campaigners who later wrote about the case, the complaint also alleged stalking, threats to set her on fire and threats against her family, and said she had attempted suicide. These were allegations; the case had not gone to trial.
A trial court had granted Chavan anticipatory bail, a form of protection from arrest. The Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court cancelled it, and he appealed to the Supreme Court, where a bench headed by Bobde heard the plea.
What the Chief Justice said
During the hearing Bobde asked Chavan's lawyer, "Will you marry her?" According to reports of the exchange, he also indicated that the court could help if the accused wished to marry the girl, and that otherwise he risked losing his job and going to prison. The lawyer replied that his client had wanted to marry her earlier, but she had refused, and that he was now married to someone else.
Bobde also remarked that the accused should have thought about the consequences before seducing and raping the young girl. In the end the court gave Chavan four weeks of protection from arrest and allowed him to apply for regular bail in the normal way. It did not make any order about marriage.
Outrage and the call to resign
The remark spread quickly. Women's rights activists and progressive groups published an open letter demanding Bobde's resignation, and a petition reportedly collected thousands of signatures within days. Their argument was that even raising marriage in such a case implied that a survivor could be handed to the man accused of abusing her, and that it risked normalising violence within marriage.
The criticism was sharpened by a second comment made on the same day in a different case, in which a woman accused a man she had lived with of rape. Bobde asked whether sexual intercourse between a husband and wife could be called rape, however brutal the husband might be. For many critics, the two remarks together suggested a blind spot about consent.
Bobde's response
On 8 March 2021, International Women's Day, Bobde addressed the controversy from the bench. He said the Supreme Court has the highest respect for womanhood, that the proceedings had been "completely misreported", and that the court had only asked whether the accused intended to marry the girl, not told him to do so. India's Solicitor General, Tushar Mehta, backed him, saying the comments had been taken out of context. Bobde also pointed to a provision of the Indian Evidence Act that allows judges to ask any question in order to discover relevant facts.
Supporters accepted that a question is not an order. Critics replied that the question itself mattered, because it came from the country's most senior judge and would be heard by lower courts, police and families. Bobde retired as Chief Justice on 23 April 2021, as scheduled, and was succeeded by N. V. Ramana.
Why "marry the victim" is such a sensitive idea
The anger makes more sense against the wider background. In several countries, laws once allowed a rapist to escape prosecution if he married his victim. After long campaigns, Morocco removed such a provision in 2014, and Jordan and Lebanon followed in 2017. These laws were widely condemned because they pressured survivors, often girls, into marriages with their attackers to protect family "honour".
Indian law contains no such provision, and the Supreme Court itself ruled in 2015 that compromise or marriage cannot be used to settle a rape case, because the offence is against the woman's dignity and is not a private matter between two families. Yet activists say that informal pressure to "settle" through marriage still happens, especially in rural areas, which is why a judge appearing to entertain the idea alarmed them.
Marital rape in Indian law
Bobde's second remark touched one of India's most contested legal questions. Indian criminal law has long included an exception stating that sexual intercourse by a man with his wife, if she is an adult, is not rape. The exception was carried over when the Indian Penal Code was replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in 2024. Wives can bring cases under domestic violence and cruelty laws, but not a rape charge.
Campaigners have challenged the exception in court for years. In 2022 the Delhi High Court delivered a split verdict on it, and challenges have since been placed before the Supreme Court. Supporters of change argue that consent should not disappear with marriage; the government has argued that criminalising marital rape could be misused and that the matter is one for Parliament.
Violence against women in India and where to get help
The episode came at a time of intense public debate about violence against women in India. Official crime records each year list hundreds of thousands of crimes against women, including several thousand dowry-related deaths, and many cases are never reported. Survivors often describe being blamed or disbelieved when they go to the police. The same week as the Bobde controversy, India was also shocked by a case in Uttar Pradesh in which a father was accused of killing his 17-year-old daughter over her relationship.
Anyone in India facing sexual or domestic violence can call the national emergency number 112 or the women's helpline 181. Outside India, local police and specialist sexual assault services can help, and a doctor can provide medical care and support.
Sources: Scroll.in, 8 March 2021: SC did not ask rape accused to marry woman, says CJI Bobde; Wikipedia: Sharad Arvind Bobde; original reporting by The Guardian, 4 March 2021.

COMMENTS