Why a Tanker Seemed to Float in the Sky off Banff, Scotland

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A Distant Ship Appears to Float Above the Sea

In late February 2021 a man travelling through Banff, a small coastal town in Aberdeenshire on the north-east coast of Scotland, filmed a large red tanker that seemed to hover above the sea. The ship was not flying, of course. A band of low cloud and haze had made the sea and the sky look the same pale blue, so the true horizon disappeared and the hull appeared to sit in mid-air.

Within days, a second "floating ship" photo appeared from Cornwall, at the other end of Britain, and that one was explained as a superior mirage. The two pictures look alike but have different causes. Here is how each works, and how to tell them apart.

What Colin McCallum saw off Banff

Colin McCallum, a health and safety worker, was passing through Banff when the tanker caught his eye. He filmed it and posted the clip on Facebook the same day with a one-line caption calling it a real-life optical illusion. The video spread quickly, and British newspapers picked it up in the first days of March.

He later told reporters that he had to look twice because, in his words, he "genuinely thought it was floating". On closer inspection he realised it was simply a remarkable optical illusion: low cloud made it hard to see where the pale blue water ended and the similar-coloured sky began, and the ship's keel was in the water all along.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

Why the ship seemed to hover

Our eyes rely on the horizon to judge where things sit. When the line between sea and sky is sharp, a ship is clearly on the water. Take that line away and the brain has to guess.

Off Banff, low cloud and haze lay over the water between the shore and the tanker. The sea beneath it looked pale and almost the same shade as the sky above. Further out, the ship's dark hull still met the water, but that waterline was hard to see against such similar colours. The eye picked up a false horizon below the ship, and the tanker appeared to float above it.

This kind of effect does not need any bending of light. It is about contrast and colour: when sea and sky blend, distant objects lose their anchor. Pilots and sailors know a related problem as a loss of visible horizon, which can make it hard to judge height or distance in haze or over calm, glassy water.

The Cornwall ship and the superior mirage

A few days after the Banff video, David Morris photographed a ship off the Cornish coast that also seemed to hang above the sea. BBC meteorologist David Braine explained that one as a superior mirage, an effect caused by a temperature inversion.

Normally air gets cooler with height. In an inversion, a layer of cold, dense air lies on the sea with warmer air above it. Light passing from the distant ship travels through these layers and is bent downwards, towards an observer on shore. The result can lift a ship's image above its real position, stretch it, or even stack an upside-down copy on top. Braine said such mirages are common in the Arctic but only happen now and then around the UK.

The most dramatic version, known as a Fata Morgana, can turn ships, islands and coastlines into towering shapes that change minute by minute. The name comes from Morgan le Fay of Arthurian legend, and the effect is famously seen in the Strait of Messina between Sicily and mainland Italy.

How to tell the two effects apart

If you see a "flying" ship yourself, a few clues help:

  • Look for distortion. A superior mirage often squashes, stretches or doubles the ship, and the shape may shimmer or change. A low-contrast illusion like the Banff one shows the ship normally, just without a visible waterline.
  • Check the weather. Mirages favour calm, cold sea surfaces with warmer air above, often in spring and early summer. The Banff effect needs low cloud, mist or haze that makes the sea and sky match.
  • Change your height. Moving up a cliff path or down to the beach can change how a mirage looks, while a colour illusion usually clears once you find a better view of the waterline.
  • Zoom in. A telephoto lens often reveals the hull in contact with the water in a low-contrast scene.

Why so many ships pass this coast

Banff sits on the Moray Firth, a wide inlet off the North Sea. The North Sea is Europe's main offshore oil and gas region, and Aberdeen, about 45 miles from Banff, has long been called the oil capital of Europe. Tankers, supply vessels and cargo ships are therefore a common sight off this coast, and industry bodies have estimated that the UK offshore sector supports around 200,000 jobs directly and indirectly, although that number has fallen as older fields decline.

That busy traffic is one reason the photo spread so fast. People in the area see ships every day, which made it all the more surprising when one appeared to leave the water.

An illusion worth knowing

The Banff tanker is a reminder that seeing is partly guessing. When the clues the brain relies on are missing, it fills the gap, sometimes with a ship in the sky. Next time the sea and sky blur into one, it is worth looking out at the horizon: you may catch your own floating ship, and now you will know why.

Sources: Daily Mail: ship appears to sail in the sky (March 2021); Marine Industry News: optical illusion causes ship to float in sky; ARY News: man captures ship "floating" in the sky (March 2021); Fox News: Cornish coast ship photo and BBC meteorologist's explanation; Met Office (background on temperature inversions). Video and photo: Colin McCallum.

Related articles

COMMENTS