‘Stop Erdoğan’ Billboard in Times Square: What Happened and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-06.

A Stop Erdoğan Billboard in Times Square Angers Turkey’s Ruling Party

In early March 2021, a digital billboard in New York’s Times Square carried a two-word message aimed at Turkey’s president: “Stop Erdoğan.” It was paid for by Advocates of Silenced Turkey, a US-based non-profit that campaigns on human rights in Turkey. Within days, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) had denounced it, blamed it on the Gülen movement, and prosecutors in Ankara had opened an investigation into the people behind it.

A paid advertisement in Times Square is not a statement by New York City or the United States. Anyone with a budget and an approved design can rent screen time there. What made this one newsworthy was the reaction it drew from Ankara, and what that reaction says about the long conflict between Erdoğan’s government and its critics abroad.

What the billboard said and who paid for it

The display was simple: the words “Stop Erdogan” in large type on one of the most photographed street corners in the world. Advocates of Silenced Turkey promoted it on social media on 2 March 2021, telling followers it was a way to raise their voice about human rights violations inside Turkey.

The group describes itself as a human rights organisation focused on Turkey. Turkish officials see it differently. They regard much of the diaspora activism on these issues as a front for the movement inspired by the cleric Fethullah Gülen. Whether the organisation has formal ties to that movement was not established in the reporting at the time, and the group itself presented the campaign as a human rights message, not a religious or partisan one.

How Turkey’s ruling party responded

Ömer Çelik, the AKP’s spokesperson, answered on Twitter. He attributed the billboard directly to the Gülen movement, which the Turkish state calls “FETÖ” (a label that brands the movement a terrorist organisation). He called the group “an enemy of Turkey and hence our president” and accused it of targeting Erdoğan with lies.

The response did not stop at words. According to the Stockholm Center for Freedom, which monitors rights issues in Turkey, the Ankara Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office opened an investigation into those responsible for the advertisement. No outcome of that investigation was reported in the sources we checked. Because the sponsors were in the United States, it is unclear what practical effect a Turkish inquiry could have had, beyond signalling how seriously Ankara took the message.

Who are the Gülenists, and why does Ankara blame them?

Fethullah Gülen was a Turkish Islamic preacher whose followers built a large network of schools, media outlets, businesses and charities, in Turkey and abroad. For years he and Erdoğan were allies. The relationship broke down publicly in December 2013, when corruption investigations touched people close to the government. Erdoğan called those probes a Gülenist plot against him.

Gülen moved to the United States in 1999, saying he needed medical treatment, and lived for the rest of his life at a retreat in the Pocono Mountains of Pennsylvania. Turkey placed him on its most-wanted terrorist list in 2015 and repeatedly asked Washington to extradite him. US officials said they had not seen evidence that met their legal standard, and he was never sent back. The European Union, the United States and the United Kingdom, among others, do not list the movement as a terrorist organisation. Gülen died in Pennsylvania on 20 October 2024, aged 83, more than three years after the billboard appeared.

The 2016 coup attempt and the crackdown that followed

The billboard only makes sense against the events of 15 and 16 July 2016. That night a faction of the Turkish armed forces tried to seize power. Tanks appeared on the streets of Istanbul and Ankara, and the parliament building was bombed. Loyal troops, police and crowds of civilians defeated the attempt. Roughly 250 to 350 people were killed, depending on the count, and more than 2,000 were wounded.

The government blamed the Gülen movement. Gülen condemned the coup, denied any role and called for an international investigation. How far his followers were involved is still disputed outside Turkey, but the attempt became the basis for one of the widest purges in modern European history:

  • A state of emergency declared on 20 July 2016 lasted two years, letting the government rule by decree.
  • By one emergency decree in late July 2016, 45 newspapers, 16 television channels, 23 radio stations, 15 magazines and 29 publishing houses were shut down.
  • More than 150,000 public employees were suspended or dismissed, including soldiers, police, judges, teachers and academics.
  • In February 2021, Turkey’s interior minister said that since the coup attempt about 622,000 people had been investigated and about 302,000 detained over alleged Gülen links, with around 25,000 still in prison.

Press freedom groups tracked the toll on journalism closely. The Committee to Protect Journalists ranked Turkey the world’s worst jailer of journalists in 2012, 2013 and again in 2016, when it counted 81 journalists behind bars. Freedom House has rated Turkey “Not Free” since 2018. These are the conditions Advocates of Silenced Turkey and similar groups point to when they campaign abroad.

Criticism of Turkey’s foreign policy

Domestic repression was only part of the picture critics had in mind in 2021. Turkey’s actions beyond its borders had also drawn strong objections from neighbours and allies.

Syria and Libya

Turkey backs a coalition of Syrian armed groups now known as the Syrian National Army. Some of these factions fought in Turkish operations against Kurdish-led forces in northern Syria, and some sent fighters to Libya when Turkey intervened there from late 2019. One of them, the Hamza Division, was sanctioned by the United States in 2023 over serious abuses in northern Syria, including abduction and rape. After Turkey’s October 2019 offensive against the Kurdish-led administration in the north-east (often called Rojava), the Alouk water station serving the Hasakah area was repeatedly cut off. Kurdish authorities and several aid groups blamed Turkey and its allied factions; Turkey rejected the accusations.

Nagorno-Karabakh

During the 2020 war between Azerbaijan and Armenian forces over Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh), Turkey openly supported Azerbaijan. Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 drones were used extensively against Armenian troops, artillery and air defences, and played a visible role in Azerbaijan’s battlefield gains.

The Eastern Mediterranean

In 2020 Greece and Cyprus protested Turkish gas exploration and survey missions in waters they claim, and the dispute brought warships from several countries into the region. In June 2020 France said Turkish frigates escorting a cargo ship suspected of breaking the UN arms embargo on Libya had locked their fire-control radar onto the French frigate Courbet three times. Turkey denied it, and France suspended its part in a NATO maritime mission in protest.

Why a single billboard caused such a stir

Times Square advertisements are expensive, short-lived and seen by enormous numbers of people, many of them tourists with phones. That makes the square a favourite stage for diaspora campaigns of every kind. The billboard itself changed nothing in Turkey. Its value to the organisers lay in the photographs, the social-media shares and, ironically, the official reaction, which carried the message to Turkish audiences who would never have seen the screen.

For readers trying to make sense of stories like this, a few points help:

  • A paid ad shows what its sponsor wants to say, not an official position of the city or country where it appears.
  • When a government blames a protest on a banned group, check whether independent sources confirm the link. In this case it was asserted, not shown.
  • Numbers about detentions and purges come mostly from Turkish official statements and rights monitors. They vary by source and date, so they are best read as orders of magnitude.

The conflict behind the billboard has outlived Gülen himself. Turkey continued to prosecute people over alleged links to his movement after his death, and campaigners abroad continue to use public spaces, from Times Square to European parliaments, to keep attention on the country’s human rights record.

Sources: Stockholm Center for Freedom; Greek City Times; Wikipedia: 2016 Turkish coup attempt; Wikipedia: Fethullah Gülen; Wikipedia: Censorship in Turkey; Wikipedia: Hamza Division; Wikipedia: Bayraktar TB2; Wikipedia: French frigate Courbet; Committee to Protect Journalists.

COMMENTS