11 Viral Photos That Fooled the Internet, and How to Spot Fakes

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Examples of Misleading and Altered Viral Photographs

A photo does not have to be edited to mislead you. Of the eleven viral images below, some were digitally altered, some show objects that are not what they seem, and several are completely genuine photographs attached to a story that is false. That last group is the hardest to spot, because no amount of zooming in on the pixels will reveal the problem.

The short version: before sharing a striking image, ask three questions. Has the picture been changed? Is the caption accurate? And does the photo really belong to the event, place and date being claimed? Each example below fails at least one of those tests, and the explanations show how fact-checkers and ordinary readers worked out the truth. A practical checklist follows at the end.

Real photos with false stories

These pictures are authentic. What went wrong was the caption.

The fawn and the bobcat "found under a desk"

A lynx and a deer were discovered in an office under a table. They were hiding from fires in California.

© junkyardmessiah / Reddit

cute animal (6)

This image resurfaces almost every time a wildfire hits the western United States, with a caption saying the two animals took shelter together under an office desk. In November 2018 it was shared as a scene from California's Camp Fire. Snopes traced it to May 2009 and the Jesusita Fire near Santa Barbara, and to the non-profit Animal Rescue Team. The bobcat kitten had actually been rescued a week earlier, dehydrated and close to death, and the fawn was brought in during the fire; with no large crates left, staff housed the two together, and they bonded.

The dog on its owner's grave

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

It has been 7 years now. The cemetery does not close the gates until he arrrives each night promptly at 6 pm. He sleeps there all night guarding the grave until the ground keeper opens the gate in the morning. This is a true picture of Capitan here. pic.twitter.com/UBZPmBzLwd

— Back To Nature (@backt0nature) 2 Μαΐου 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)

A widely shared post claimed that a dog named Captain had slept on his owner's grave every night for seven years, and that the cemetery waited for him before locking the gates. There was a real dog with this story: Capitán, a black-and-tan German shepherd mix from Villa Carlos Paz in Argentina, whose owner Miguel Guzmán died in 2006. The local newspaper La Voz del Interior reported on him in 2012, and he died in February 2018. The dog in the viral photo, however, is a pale Labrador-type dog, not Capitán, and PolitiFact rated the post False.

A polar bear stepping off a tram

“A typical day in Russia.”

© Moaml99 / reddit

Shared with captions such as "a typical day in Russia", this picture is an unedited photo, but the bear is a puppet. According to Snopes, it was taken in Brno in the Czech Republic, where two Greenpeace activists operated "Paula the Polar Bear" from inside as part of the Save the Arctic campaign. The puppet toured European cities to draw attention to oil drilling and melting ice in the Arctic.

A cruise ship "dumping waste"

This photo of a cruise ship surrounded by brown clouds in the sea went viral in January 2019 with claims that it was emptying sewage near the coast. The ship was off Punta del Este in Uruguay. Alejandro Nario, Uruguay's national director of the environment at the time, explained that the ship was manoeuvring to anchor and its engines had churned up sand and mud from the shallow seabed. The brown water was sediment, not effluent.

A goose "frozen to a pipe" sheltering a puppy

A goose frozen to a pipe warmed a puppy with its wing.

© Suzanne PadaPetra / facebook

In early 2019 these pictures spread on Facebook with a story that a goose stuck to a frozen pipe in Montana had wrapped its wing around a freezing puppy. The photos are older than that: they had been posted on Chinese sites since at least March 2017, including the user-content platform NetEase, with a different story about a roadside puppy and passing ducks. Where and when they were really taken remains unknown, so the Montana version should be treated as unverified.

Objects that are not what they seem

The wok full of flying rice

A guy mixing rice

© GeneReddit123 / Reddit

A guy mixing rice

© BobertMcGee / Reddit

A young man appears to toss a perfect wave of fried rice out of a wok. In fact the wave and the wok are a single plastic display piece, the kind of realistic replica food that Japanese shops sell to restaurants and tourists. A second photo, taken in a store, shows the same "Giga wave" sculpture in a glass case.

A megalodon tooth in a whale vertebra

A megalodon’s tooth in a whale vertebrae

© GallowBoob / Reddit

Megalodon was a giant prehistoric shark, and a tooth lodged in a whale bone would be a remarkable fossil record of an attack. This object is not that. According to its owner, who posted it on Reddit in 2012, a seller had combined a separate tooth and vertebra into a decorative piece, and similar items were reportedly listed online for around $125. A genuine find would belong in a museum, not a living room.

Edited and composite images

The rainforest "ten-year challenge"

Here’s what happened to a rainforest over ten years.

© kinkysatanx / Reddit

Here’s what happened to a rainforest over ten years.

© bigstockphoto

During the 2019 #10YearChallenge craze, this pair labelled "2009" and "2019" spread with a WWF logo in the corner. The logo made it look official, but the image was one aerial stock photograph split down the middle, not two pictures taken a decade apart. The stock listing describes rainforest in Borneo, Malaysia, cleared for oil palm plantations. Deforestation there is real and well documented; this particular before-and-after simply is not.

The mural that only appears in the water

Graffiti you can only see in the water.

© Bonnie817 / Reddit

Graffiti you can only see in the water.

© GoGoGadgetReddit / Reddit

The artwork is real. The Floating World was painted upside down in 2015 by the Lithuanian-American artist Ray Bartkus on the old dam building in Marijampolė, Lithuania, so that it reads the right way up in the reflection. The viral version, though, had its reflection retouched to look perfectly crisp. In the unedited photo below it, the reflection is softer and broken by ripples, and on a windy day it can disappear entirely.

New Year's fireworks over Paris

The New Year in Paris

© britainunwrapped / Reddit

This dazzling picture of fireworks filling the sky over the Eiffel Tower was shared as New Year's Eve in Paris. It is a composite: the bursts all appear at a similar size and distance, which real fireworks spread across a city would not, and Parisians on Reddit pointed out that the scene did not match the city's celebrations. Paris's famous fireworks at the Eiffel Tower are traditionally held on 14 July, Bastille Day, as in the genuine photo below.

The New Year in Paris

© BuckeyeEmpire / Reddit

A mountain shaped like a turtle

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

In January 2019 the Facebook page Amazing Nature shared a "turtle mountain" rising from a lake. No such mountain exists: the picture was assembled from several photos, including the two below, a rocky knob near Dobson, North Carolina, and a lake view from Glacier National Park.

A mountain shaped like a turtle’s head

© GlacierNPS / Flickr © Pixabay.com

Why misleading photos spread so fast

Most of these images share a pattern. They trigger a strong feeling, whether outrage at a polluting ship, sadness at a loyal dog, or wonder at a mountain or a perfect reflection, and strong feelings make people share before they check. A logo, a precise-sounding place name or a number of years adds a sense of authority that the image has not earned.

A common myth is that a photo is trustworthy if it has not been photoshopped. As the fawn, the polar bear and the cruise ship show, an untouched image can still tell a false story when it is attached to the wrong place, date or event. Another myth is that popularity proves accuracy. Tens of thousands of shares only show that a picture is moving, not that its caption is true.

How to check a viral photo yourself

  1. Run a reverse image search with Google Lens, Bing Visual Search or TinEye. Older copies of the same picture often reveal its real date and origin.
  2. Look for the first upload. Reposts strip away context; the original photographer or agency usually gives the real story.
  3. Check fact-checking sites such as Snopes, PolitiFact, AFP Fact Check or Reuters Fact Check, which have already investigated many recurring images.
  4. Read the details. Street signs, shop names, vehicles, seasons and languages can contradict a caption, as the Brno street sign did for the "Russian" polar bear.
  5. Look for physical oddities. Identical sizes, mismatched lighting, perfect reflections and repeated textures are common signs of compositing.
  6. Pause before sharing. If you cannot confirm the story, share it with a note of doubt, or not at all.

Sources: Photos credited under each image (Reddit, Flickr, Pixabay, Bigstock, Facebook users). Snopes: fawn and bobcat; PolitiFact: Capitán and the grave photo; Snopes: polar bear on public transit; Snopes: cruise ship dumps waste; Marijampolė tourism: The Floating World; originally compiled by Bright Side.

Related articles

COMMENTS